LIBRARY
Brigham Young University
FROM ."^^.':^-^.^..M^..WLy.ford Pou^^
Call !■■■■ Ace.
No. ^^^m . No — - —
/-l.-^
S'.
\J
Digitized by the Internet Archive
in 2012 with funding from
Brigham Young University
http://archive.org/details/puttingyoungamerOOwebe
The Magic of Music
From Drawing- by Claude Buck
Putting
Young America in Tune
How to Teach the Child Appreciation
of Music
BY
HENRIETTE WEBER
CHICAGO
FREDERICK J. DRAKE & CO.
PUBLISHERS
i».?!GH*W VOUNG UNlYtl.:. ^.
LIBRARY
PROyO, UIAJd
Copyright, 1920
By Frederick J. Drake & Co.,
Ciiicag-o
An Rights Reserved
INTRODUCTION
^^How can I make my child like music?'' is a
question being asked by countless thousands of
parents.
There is a national awakening to the fact that
music is a live factor in our modem civilization.
In our schools, in our homes, in civic life, it is
being reckoned with as an influence of the first
importance. That is because we are learning to
know music.
The one thing above all else that has brought
about this change in the popular estimation of
music is the mechanical reproduction of its litera-
ture. The player piano and the phonograph have
multiplied masterly interpretations to such an
extent that millions of people today are connois-
seurs who twenty years ago did not know one tune
from another. And what is more, did not care.
Our people are learning to talk glibly of much
that is best in opera, in song, violin or piano
literature. Artists whose records are liked are
sure of large and enthusiastic audiences wherever
they may appear. We say we are *^ becoming a
musical nation,'' quite forgetting that we have
been potentially musical all the time, only needing
to have this latent characteristic awakened. In
INTRODUCTION
like degree every child is ** musical. ' ' The thor-
oughly * * unmusicaP ' person virtually does not
exist.
It is the aim of this book to set forth as simply
as possible the practical problems that confront
parents in the development of the music sense in
their children, to emphasize the parents' responsi-
bility in this respect, and to prove that technical
knowledge is not necessary for this home training.
The points brought out here are a crystalliza-
tion of questions asked in a voluminous corre-
spondence extending over several countries, the
letters being the result of a series of articles in
Mother's Magazine and Home Life,
There is a degree of urge in these eager ques-
tions that would seem to be the best reason for
this attempt at an answer.
Henkiette Weber.
Chicago, June 1, 1920.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I The Magic of Music 9
General Introduction — Children and Savages
Alike in Their Reactions — Primitive Man's At-
titude Toward Music — Fairy Tale Beginnings.
II When to Begin Musical Training 21
Harmony in the Nursery — Babyhood's Response
to Sound — Witchery of Lullabies — Music and
Health— What a Xylophone Will Do— First Ef-
forts at Self-Expression.
III When Is a Child Musical? 31
Kindergarten Stage — How the Mother Can Help
— Home Preparedness — Music and Castor Oil —
Water-Glass Game — Baiting Tunes with Sugar-
plums.
IV Appeal to the Imagination 40
The Golden Key — Selective Listeners — Rainbow
Beauty of Tone-Color — Play Spirit of Music —
Useful Games — Every Child a Creator — Develop-
ing the Tone Sense.
V Developing the Rhythmic Sense 53
Rhythmic Pattern Underlies All Music — Chil-
dren's Games Rhythmic — Impulse to Imitate —
Psychological Effect of Rhythm Contagion — As a
Physical and Mental Stimulus.
VI Taking Lessons 63
Making the Right Start — Breeding Music-Haters
— What It Costs — A Teaching Revolution — Mak-
ing Practice Hour Fascinating.
VII Delinquent Parents 73
Specialists Allowed Full Sway — Parents Evade
Responsibility — Lack of Technical Knowledge
No Barrier to Parent's Helpfulness.
VIII In Our Public Schools 83
Music's Place in the Curriculum — What Progres-
sive Methods Can Accomplish — Unifying Influ-
ence — Proper Equipment — A Phonograph in
Every School-Room — Outside Credits.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
IX Linking Up with the School 97
Home Music — Cultivating Parents — Father Can
Help — Diversified Problems — Be a School Visitor
— On Encouraging Self-Expression.
X What About Your Boy? 107
Music Not Girls' Business Exclusively — The "Do
Something" Spirit — The Instrument for Your
Boy — What to Avoid — Do Not Sex the Arts.
XI Make Music a Family Affair 120
Household Harmonies as Blues Chasers — Home
Lure Strengthened — Family Music Games —
Neighborhood Opera Club — Music Tells a Story
— Good Manners.
XII Moral Inflltence 133
As a Character Builder — Does It Make Better
Citizens? — Psychology in an Irish Jig — Solving
Your Domestic Problems — Metamorphosis of a
Cracker Box.
XIII Cultivating Good Taste 146
What People Like — As to "Popular Music" —
Trashy Songs Harmful — Watch the Piano Rack
— A Qualified Defence of Ragtime — Popular
Music Is Familiar Music.
XIV What Every Home Should Have 158
Understanding Music — Art Not Exclusive — Con-
cert Audiences — Banish Hothouse Process —
National Anthem Etiquette — A Social Favorite.
XV The Business of Music 167
Artists and Human Beings — Standards Changing
— A New Recreation — Men More Musical Than
Women — Its Part in the Game of Life.
XVI Music and Our National Life 177
Answering the Call — In Our Public Libraries —
In the Church — Movie Music — The Woman's Club
— Community Music — Prohibition and Music.
XVII Every Man His Own Tuning Fork 188
Sound Not Mysterious — Vibration Laws — Recog-
nizing Tone — Why the Dog Howled — The
Farmer and the Trolley — Your Own Key-note.
XVIII The Home Repertoire 195
Titles of Music That Everyone Likes — Song Col-
lections for Children.
Index 190
PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN
TUNE
CHAPTER I
THE MAGIC OF MUSIC
The sacred power of music, who shall tell,
"Who find the secret of its mastery?
— Celia Thaxter.
*^No, I am not musical/' a friend said to me,
and at that moment jumped from his chair and
rushed to the window.
On the boulevard below his office a military band
was blaring a cheerful marching message, and
my ^^ unmusical' ' friend listened with eager atten-
tion while he drummed with his fingers on the
window-sill, in time to the tune.
* ' Then what did you do that for ! ' ' I asked.
^'Do what?" he returned, coming back to his
desk. ^*0h — the band? I simply can't sit still
when they go by."
Quite unconsciously he had flatly refuted his
earlier statement, for had he been truly unmusical
he would have paid no attention to the band, or
even if he had noticed it, would have found no
pleasure in it.
Much of the compelling force of musio is lost
9
10 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
upon US because we reactto it unconsciously for
one thing, and on the other hand lye do not realize
to what an extent pleasant sound-waves are filling.
the_aJT_alKmt4is^
We are — most of us — tone deaf, so music enters
our lives just through a very narrow door that
leads directly to a definite something, ranging
from a symphony concert to Susan's misuse of
the latest in her repertoire. We pigeonhole our
moments of musical relaxation in such orderly
fashion that artificialities hedge them about. We
^^o'' music in one form or another because it is
the thing to do, or someone else wishes it, or
nothing more interesting offers itself in its place^
Only a few recognize it as a need. Once in a
while you hear the remark, * * I am just hungry for
some good music." But as a rule we pay so little
heed to our instincts, or allow them to become so
over-educated that they just naturally lie down
and die.
Our apparently unmusical status as a nation is
suffering from artificial over-education and mal-
nutrition. It is a sad combination.
We have worked many centuries to squeeze all
the joy out of listening to music by making the
means of enjoyment more and more complex, until
now, when we find ourselves starving in spite of
the abundance about us, a dilemma confronts us
much like that of the little old man **who was so
wondrous wise'' that when he found a bramble
THE MAGIC OF MUSIC 11
bush had scratched out both his eyes, **with all
his might and main, he jumped into another bush
and scratched them in again.''
After s^tapa^^g.iIl^ljn]Jl^i^^^a^ and trying our
best, by wrong methods, to transfoxm-oux-xes^ction
to it into a lifeless, analytical and empty thing,
instead of th^ warm, glowing healthful reaction
it should be, we are at last busily working to put
it all back again into its rightful place as a joy-
giver.
There is no accounting for the magic of music
— the strange_pOT^r_that liesjn_a set of quivering
vibrations. It starts a man to dreaming7awoman
to weeping, a child to dancing. The immediate
response to a given piece varies with every list-
ener, "^t is there for you to get out of it what you
will — and what you need7
^^^^Ajid what do we need? A W>de jof_self-expres^
sioni That is as necessary to us as the air we
breathe.
<Griving voice to our emotions, our feelings, our
desires, is a primitive instinct, an elemental nee<Jr
The baby in the cradle yells its disapproval or
impatience with full lungs, whimpers its fear,
croons its contentment. The baby knows. And
its noises (beg pardon, baby) are as expressive
of its moods and emotions as are any more con-
scious modes of self-expression later in life.
Moreover they have the saving grace of being
absolutely sincere!
12 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
The ways of infants and savages are strangely
similar.
What the baby wants it goes after and gets.
So with the savage. The infant, to be sure, does
not use a club and brute force, but its methods are
no less direct. Just as the response to sound
sensations is instinctive and of an elemental sim-
plicity, so the child knows, perhaps sooner than
anything else, the power in the performance of
sound. Its first conscious act is to cry its wants
to the world, and it learns, soon enough, that such
self-expression brings desired results.
And these impulses later give rise to natural
and calculated expressions of states of feeling, to
gestures and varied cries (no longer just the
sturdy yell of the tiny cradle), and to bodily
movement and singing. Laughter and light, quick
cries are the natural accompaniment to a joyful
skipping about; darker toned shouts or growls
accompany the angry gesture, or at least express
the mood even if restraint somewhat curbs the
physical expression of it.
And so it is with primitive man. With him
sound and gesture were the mediums by which he
expressed his own emotions or excited emotion in
others. His primitive arrangement of sounds
which to him meant music, was indulged in per-
haps simply for the pleasurable quality, or to act
as a menace or warning, thereby becoming an aid
to the instinct of self-preservation.
THE MAGIC OP MUSIC 13
Tonal expression became an integral part of
his celebrations, his religious rites, and all public
gatherings. He strutted as he stressed his songs
of victory, languor and grace imbued movements
that accompanied his attempts to entice love, and
he bowed his body in anguish as he chanted or
moaned his song of defeat or grief.
The reaction to natural impulses here touched
upon may seem to be something far afield from
music as we know it. In fact it must appear, at
first glance, to be entirely too remote for any pos-
sible excuse as a place in this book. And yet we
shall see, presently, that instead of being remote,
the giving way to these impulses is the cue that
leads most directly to a practical solution of how
to develop the music sense in the child. Primitive
man was no more easily affected by these ^psy-
chological reactions produced by sound than are
'we, adults and children of the present day.
To find the origin of music we must go far
indeed, for music existed as a definite expression
of emotion long before it became a conscious art.
It is as old as creation and as new as the dawn,
as old as love and hatred and jealousy, as new as
every fresh joy and sorrow. And through it all,
from its very beginnings to its most complex
modern expression, there has been a steady under-
current of one thing that is always present, and
that isjib^^^m.
We might paraphrase that squib of sophistica-
14 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
tion, * talent is something but tact is everything/'
by writing it ^^ harmony is something but rhythm
is everything." Bhjrthm is the motive power of
expression tl^rough sound. It is the steam-engine
of music. And so we find it to be invariably the
basic principle on which musical expression is
founded.
Why this is so will be taken up in the next
chapter when the natural response to rhythm as
evidenced by the child will be discussed.
The potency and charm of artificially produced
sound, the peculiar effect of varying rhythms,
pitches and tone-colors — all this invested the
earliest attempts at music with such a mysterious
power that, like the equally inexplicable phe-
nomena of nature, the mind of primitive man
ascribed it to a supernatural source. Conse-
quently as an art it long remained as imperfect
as its legendary powers were portentous,
^^usic was looked upon as a supernatural force
given to man by the gods to be used as a bless-
ing, as a consolation, as a weapon of defense, or
for personal aggrandizement. Prom which it may
be deduced that even in this early stage of music's
history its kaleidoscopic nature began to be under-
stood. Even in its simplest form it began,
"^11 thJJt^ to all mtiii-f
The most picturesque pages in the world's
book of fairy tales are those devoted to the legends
that tell of the origin of music. Evidently its
THE MAGIC OF MUSIC 15
magic has held sway throughout the world, for
wherever we turn — from the bamboo covered
mountain tops of China to the dark forests of the
North American Indian — from the tropical banks
of the Eiver Niger to the stern rockbound coasts
of Finland — everywhere the miraculous power of
music has become entwined in the folklore of the
people.
No attempt shall be made here to treat this sub-
ject from a scientific standpoint. Just a few
legends will be indicated by outlines to emphasize
the true significance of music ^s fairy tale begin-
nings.
With pipe and flute the rustic Pan
Of old made music sweet for m-an;
And wonder hushed the warbling bird,
And closer drew the calm-eyed herd —
The rolling river slowlier ran.
— Austin Dohson.
C_So speaks the poet of the great god Pan, whose
wondrous harmonies subdued all living things
who heard him — even humans./ And here is the
story of how he came by the marvelous instrument
that could pour forth such sweet tones.
There was a lovely woodland nymph named
Syrinx. Pan, the god who presided over the
woods and dells, fell in love with her, but in spite
of all his wooing, she invariably fled at sight of
him. Now one day it seemed as though Pan would
surely catch her, so her sister nymphs trans-
16 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
formed her into a hollow reed that she might
escape her pursuer. But she sighed for the care-
free life she had lost, for she was now rooted to
one spot, and it is this soft music we hear even
to this day wherever reeds grow by the edge of
the water.
Pan also heard the faint sighing of his beloved
Syrinx, and so he cut a number of reeds to trans-
form the music to his own uses. With grasses he
tied several of these hollow reeds or pipes together
and blew into them, making a strange and melan-
choly music. This little instrument came to be
called the Pipes of Pan, and so miraculous was
the effect of these sweet sounds that the birds in
the tree tops would stop their own song to listen,
and even the wild beasts of the forest would draw
near and become tamed and subdued by its power.
The story of Pan, in one guise or another, runs
like a ribbon around the world, binding the edge
where myth merges into history. This tale of
spell-bound nature sets before us in a nutshell
the mysterious power of sound to which savages
and children give themselves up whole-heartedly.
It seems that we alone who are analytical grown-
ups cannot permit ourselves to be so susceptible.
That is something remaining for us to learn.
Pan with his flute (or pipes) was not the only
divinity who could produce such marvels, for, of
course, you have heard of Orpheus and his lyre.
The music of a stringed instrument was his
THE MAGIC OF MUSIC 17
medium of expression, for he was a mighty pagan
god, son of Apollo, and more important in the
scheme of things, so he believed, than a half wild
woodland creature like Pan. So Orpheus devel-
oped such mastery that when he played all living
things were at his beck and call, and he could
even move mountains by his wonderful music.
The GLlLb^j^ will tell you about their music-god,
jLonei, who seems to have been no less remarkable
than Orpheus. But Konei knew nothing of the
magic, either of strings or hollow reeds. For
him the wonders of nature gave up yet another
secret — the wizardry of sound in mighty stones.
By experimenting Konei found certain great
stones which, when struck, gave forth deep musical
tones almost like those of an organ. Some tones
were high and others so deep and low they fairly
boomed their message to the world. And Konei
was such a master too, that like Pan and Orpheus,
he could venture into the densest forest without
fear, for all wild creatures seemed to love him
and his music.
Of course you have heard about scales, and
you probably have learned to play them on your
piano and don 't like them a bit because they seem
dry and uninteresting ladders to musical pro-
ficiency. Or you have do-re-mi-f a-d them at school
until you are quite sure they are the most sense-
less contrivances ever invented. But in spite of
being so apparently prosaic, the musical scale
18 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
really had a wonderful beginning if we are to
believe the legend about the miraculous birds.
Many hundreds of years ago a certain emperor
became very impatient with the folk music of
his country. His people were forever bickering
about what constituted the true and correct basis
of their music, and they couldn't agree about the
scale at all. They kept on quarrelling until the
emperor got tired of hearing them disagree, and
in great haste summoned his prime minister to
appear before him.
**We must stop all this confusion. Go to the
Sacred Mountain and find a solution, '^ commanded
the emperor.
So the prime minister went up to the very top
of the Sacred Mountain, which was completely
covered by a forest of bamboo trees. He pondered
long as to what course to pursue, when suddenly
the wind blowing gently through the woods
brought with it a low, sighing monotone. This
gave the prime minister a happy thought. He
cut a piece of bamboo, made it hollow, and spoke
through it. Behold ! The tone it gave forth was
exactly like his natural speaking voice when he
was not agitated, only it was more pleasant and
sonorous. Scarcely had he sounded this marvel-
ous note three times when two miraculous birds,
with wonderful plumage, came and perched on the
nearest bamboo trees. One was a male bird and
the other a female, and each chirped a set of six
THE MAGIC OF MUSIC 19
notes. But the lady-bird sang just a bit higher
than the other, and these twelve tones constitute
to this day the notes of the chromatic scale.
Without music the world would be an impossible
place to live in the Japanese believe, and in their
beautiful cherry-blossom country you may hear
the tale of the sun-goddess.
She it was who brought light and happiness into
the world. But one day, in resentment at the
behaviour of an evil-disposed brother, she hid her-
self in a cave, and at once the universe was
plunged into darkness and anarchy. Everything
was tried to propitiate the sun-goddess, but noth-
ing would persuade her to leave the cave. The
people were in the greatest despair until one of
their beneficent gods conceived that the magic of
music might produce the desired miracle. So they
gathered all their finest singers and players
together and these poured forth their musical
offering until the lure of their enticing strains
proved so great that the sun-goddess came out of
the cave where she had hidden herself, and at once
light and happiness returned to the earth. So it
is no wonder, is it, that the Japanese call music a
blessing?
These and innumerable other legends tell us in
no uncertain way that music has always wielded a
miraculous power. But if we are to learn from
these legends their symbolic meaning, would it
not seem that music is not merely a sense-lulling
20 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
opiate letting us dream down the river of life, but
rather that its wider mission shall be to bring a
newer enlightenment into this complex modern
civilization of ours?
The response to music was instinctive in primi-
tive man, it is instinctive in the child, and it can
be instinctive with us if we make up our minds
not to be afraid of its power. In our harried
national existence we almost forget there are wide
spaces all about inhabited by beauty, serenity and
inspiration, and these delectable regions of the art
spirit can be acquired at the price of just one thing
— an attitude of appreciation that is at the same
time one of response. We must permit it to be
the sincere obeying of a natural impulse, for after
all the cradle of musical consciousness lies in the
human heart.
CHAPTER n
WHEN TO BEGIN MUSICAL TRAINING
All one's life is a music if one touches the notes
rightly and in tune.
— Ruskin.
The question uppermost in the minds of parents
as regards musical training is **when to begin ^'
it. The accompanying question, ^^How to begin '^
is not heard as frequently although it is of equal
if not greater importance. **When to begin '*
signifies with most people the age suitable for
commencing lessons on the piano or some other
instrument. The moment for *^ taking lessons,''
like a dose of medicine, has arrived. Tell us,
Doctor, what to do to have it over with !
And ^^howr'
^*0h! get a good teacher'' and be done with it.
No, you cannot dismiss it that way. The time
for ^^ taking music" begins long before the time
for calling in a professional teacher has arrived.
This is a fact not yet generally realized by parents.
So the answer must be: The time to begin your
child's musical training is in the nursery. And
the earlier, the better.
In the first place your child has a right to music.
Failure to develop his taste in this direction ^4s
a loss of happiness," says Darwin, **and may pos-
21
22 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
sibly be injurious to the intellect and more prob-
ably to the moral character.'^ So you see what
a formidable responsibility is placed on the
shoulders of music training. Your child's ulti-
mate happiness, intellectual development, and
moral character are at stake. Had you thought
of that? Then how could the training of a taste
for music begin too soon?
We have already seen in Chapter I that the
feeling for music is instinctive. Here we shall
find that the response to sound impressions is
one of the earliest manifestations of the infant
mind at work.
Sharp or sudden noises will make a baby jump
nervously. Soft and pleasant sounds, the more
purely musical the better, will soon bring a coo
of contentment and the first smile. Harmony in
the nursery is a much desired condition. Har-
mony of color and harmony of sound. In the
strictly musical sense harmony is here used pho-
netically rather than literally, for whatever music
is used for the baby's benefit should be of the
simplest possible.
Of all the beautiful music in the world nothing
can equal the crooning of lullabies. They are the
very essence of mother love, and it is not only the
low soft tones or the simple melody that sings
your little one to sleep with a seraphic smile of
contentment. It is the spirit of the music behincj.
the obvious melody winging its message from the
WHEN TO BEGIN MUSICAL TRAINING 23
mother heart to the baby's, that makes the
witchery of lullabies more beautiful than anything
else in the world.
The instinctive reaction to pleasant and un-
pleasant sounds, and the pleasurable sensations
manifested in response to the former, is the
child's innate sense of music. Denied the oppor-
tunity to exercise itself, it will remain latent and
perhaps die. It is in these days of early infancy
that your child's feeling for tone should be sub-
jected to the first training, for what, after all, is
training but a gentle guidance toward develop-
ment? It cannot be emphasized too strongly that
what you make of this great opportunity and
pleasant occupation is the influence that will make
your child later in life apparently a ^* musical"
or an '^unmusical" person.
A child brought up under circumstances where
it never heard human speech would fall back on
primitive means and sounds for the purpose of
expressing himself, and would be practically in-
capable of human speech. As a parallel it may be
pointed out right here that the music instinct so
deeply rooted, is a part of man's nature, not
merely a talent given to a select few. The man
who *^ can't tell one tune from another" is made,
not horn. He simply lost this precious possession
very early in life and then concluded he had never
had it.
"^ The first musical training, as such, commences
24 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
with the baby's first consciousness of rhythm.
That is the element in music capable of being
grasped long before there is any sense of melody.
But rhythm consciousness must not be confounded
with the reaction to sound sensations already
described. The latter is merely a reaction of feel-
ing. Unpleasant sounds jar. Pleasant sounds
sooth.
Imitative response to rhythm is, on the other
hand, a conscious act, and can be awakened and
developed as soon as the infant mind can take
hold and retain anything. The baby sitting in its
high chair pounding the table edge with a spoon
will soon imitate your beat when by pounding you
gain its attention. At once the baby commences
to get real fun out of the rhythmic swing.
Just as rhythm is one of the most marked char-
acteristics in music, so the feeling for it is one of
the strongest impulses. Children and savages are
alike in this. Primitive music is always built on
a rhythmic pattern. Any conscious expression
of sound for the purpose of bringing about a
definite emotional effect is put on a time basis.
How naturally children follow this instinctive
mode of procedure is shown by the rhythm under-
lying all of their play. This will be described
more fully in Chapter IV.
To go back to the infant, we find that the first
mode of self-expression that can be classified as
something quite separate from the expression of
WHEN TO BEGIN MUSICAL TRAINING 25
desires, is governed by rhythm. This sense, then,
is present long before there is any realization of
beauty of melody. The baby's reaction to just a
plain noise or the mother's song does not denote
an ability to appreciate the difference, excepting
as it jars or soothes. It is simply an instinctive
animal response to what is unpleasant or pleas-
ant, classifying under the same head as a pin-
prick or a nice warm bottle of milk.
Now no mother would deliberately subject her
offspring to pin-pricks. By the same token she
should keep discordant noises out of the nursery
and supply, instead, those that any human would
like. We shall see in the next chapter that a chaos
of unnecessarily disagreeable sounds is likewise
to be kept apart from children in the kindergarten
age.
Meanwhile we find the baby has an ear for
music. Although its shudder at a slamming door
and its cooing obligato to a lullaby at first are not
concerned with any conscious sense of anything
except the fundamental difference between what
disturbs and what does not disturb, we find, even
before many months have passed that the baby
likes some musical sounds better than others. It
is already commencing to be a selective listener.
And this appreciation of different tone qualities
may be greatly developed during the first three
years. By beginning this training early you are
planning for the child an heritage of pure joy.
26 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Eight here is where the foundation for musical
taste is most securely laid.
Rhythm coordinated with soft sweet sounds is
the perfect child music. And baby specialists are
now advocating the use of suitable rhythmic exer-
cises to the accompaniment of music, beginning at
the age of one year. It is a proved theory, suc-
cessfully practiced, that this musical treatment
started so early and judiciously continued
throughout childhood improves the baby^s health,
develops the muscles, and somehow helps to put
even a very tiny atom of humanity *4n tune with
the infinite. ' ' At least its tendency is toward that
millennium. In any event it has a distinct and .
beneficial effect on the child's physical well-being.
Coming back to tone qualities, it is easily demon-
stratable that children like certain ones better
than others. They prefer a xylophone, for in-
stance, to a piano. And they are especially fond,
too, of a flute or a violin. Probably the piano
would be more popular with the small child if it
were used with skill and loving care. But more
generally it is thoughtlessly banged on by various
members of the family, more often than not it is
badly out of tune, and the youngest member of the
household — still in possession of an unperverted
taste in music — very naturally places this bang-
ing right in the category where it belongs, that of
noise. Children's instinctive taste for music is
always good.
WHEN TO BEGIN MUSICAL TRAINING 27
If you care for their musical welfare you should
by all means have a little xylophone in your house.
One of several octaves and amply fulfilling every
requirement can be obtained for about twenty-
five dollars. Smaller ones for much less, and then,
of course, you can go up to four hundred dollars.
But that is neither necessary nor desirable. The
twenty-five dollar one will do perfectly.
Its clear silvery tones delight even the very
young baby, and mother can follow the book of
instruction and easily learn to play a variety of
tunes on it even if she knows not a note of music.
Before long the two-year-old will experiment with
it himself. The sense of melody and rhythm at
that age begins to develop rapidly, you will need
instrumental aid, and soon you will learn to look
upon the xylophone as the most valuable piece of
furniture in the nursery.
But playing even on the xylophone is not a
child's first conscious attempt at making music.
Long before a baby can carry a tune, that is, can
imitate melody, he enjoys melody. Even when
only a year old he will hum funny little tunes of
his own invention. This is one of his first con-
scious efforts at self-expression, and curiously
enough these little musical meanderings take on
a definite form. They are the baby's property
and he brings them out to use at his will. He
should under no circumstances be discouraged,
nor should his virtuoso efforts be laughed at or
28 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
applauded. He must not be made self-conscious
with this first accomplishment. This music-mak-
ing is a precious thing. In his own baby fashion
he is enjoying his God-given instinct for music —
the instinct that our modern education has with
great care almost eliminated from our make-up.
There our over-education is at fault again!
Now we are completing the circle and trying
to undo what we have done. Individuals and
national organizations are cooperating to put the
music instinct back in our souls. They think
community music will do it, and it is having its
abundant results no doubt, although it is difficult
to teach an old dog new tricks. But it is the best
that can be done with the present non-musical
generation. Let us see to it that with the coming-
on set of humans no such uprooting need take
place.
We have amply demonstrated in ourselves the
truth that any instinct, if starved, will just nat-
urally die like other things subjected to the starva-
tion process. "What of music? It became an arti-
ficial feature of our cultural training. It was arti-
ficially applied. It was made ugly where it should
have been beautiful, tiresome where it should have
been a delight. No such thing as a music-hater
was ever bom in the world, but we have been bus-
ily manufacturing them for many years. No won-
der we have been described as an unmusical peo-
ple. Slowly the pendulum is swinging the other
WHEN TO BEGIN MUSICAL TRAINING 29
way. Every effort is being made to transplant our
dying musical instincts, and happily, as we shall
see in future chapters, the transplanting is bring-
ing welcome results.
Meanwhile do we pause to reflect that music is
as natural to the human being as speech? And in
fact that the music instinct is given utterance
first? We have seen already that this is true of
the child. It is also true in the history of the race.
Music — in other words, the song imitation of
sounds in nature — came before intelligible speech.
These imitative sounds were for the purpose of
interpreting human feelings, and so eloquent was
the medium even in its primitive form that it
seemed to primeval man to be a thing far greater
than himself — something of divine origin.
And must we not suppose that the infant's little
song means much more than the atom of humanity
has any idea of? "With the music instinct so
deeply rooted, the child bursts into song on the
slightest provocation. It is only our mistaken
notion of its true function and the foolish limit
of exclusiveness we have tried to label it with that
has fairly killed the art in its broader aspects, and
almost driven it out of the modern scheme of
things as far as being a live factor is concerned.
A recognition of the true function of music as
being much jnore than a mere cultural asset is
bringing about the national awakening that will
in time give the art its due place. Meanwhile it
30 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
will do no harm to remember that just as the child
apparently repeats the history of the human race,
just as every spontaneous tuning up in the nursery
is as new as every love song, so it is a precious
treasure that should be guarded with the greatest
care.
Every child specialist is realizing the value of
music as a due preparation for life. And not the
least of these, in the first few years of babyhood,
is the effect of music upon the health. Pleasing
sounds are good for the nerves of every one of us.
Then why not for the child? Make the nursery
the center for pleasurable sensations. Keep out
what is harsh just as you would what is ugly.
Let it be remembered that this time of infancy
is one of exceeding preciousness in the develop-
ment of the child ^s musical culture. With just a
little thought and intelligent care the miracle of
'^appreciating music'* may here be well started on
the road of complete accomplishment. Let the
baby mind become accustomed to ' ^ the concord of
sweet sounds *' and you will give him a gift for
which your child will bless you all the years of his
life.
CHAPTER III
WHEN IS A CHILD MUSICAL?
Children are the representatives of intuitive
knowledge. >
— Dorothy Miller,
We have now reached the important age, from
three to six years, when you can quite definitely
determine how musical your child is. It is the
kindergarten stage of music training, during
which a great deal may and should be accom-
plished. Still too young to ^Hake lessons,'' chil-
dren of this age nevertheless are ready to learn
a great deal about music. Instead of this being
a rather barren period, quite void of results as
far as appreciation goes, it is right here where
you can either make or unmake the musical nature
of your child.
Few parents understand or believe that this may
be the most important formative period in the
child's musical training. And furthermore they
do not realize that they themselves can function
during this time as very successful teachers with-
out the aid of technical knowledge. *^I don't play
any more" or **I haven't kept up my music" is
the general plaint among mothers.
To which one can truthfully answer: **No?
31
82 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
That doesn^t matter. There is still a great deal
you can do. ^ '
Every mother hopes her child will be ** musi-
cal, ' ^ but few mothers know that the hoping may be
turned into fulfillment if only the right recipe is
used. During these early years the thoughtful
parent can play a larger part than anyone else
in bringing this about.
We have already seen that even in the nursery,
during the period of infancy, the child shows its
musical tendencies, and it has been pointed out
what may be done to develop them. But at best
the mother's or nurse's role during that stage of
the child's musical development is but a com-
paratively passive one, and the child's response
is more instinctive than conscious. The tenden-
cies are watched and permitted to develop almost
undisturbed except for the gentlest of guidance.
But now it is different. Again comes the anxious
query : ^ ^ When is a child musical ? ' '
We might parry the question, yankeewise, by
asking another.
What is a musical person anyway?
Is it someone who has been especially gifted
by the gods? Not at all, though that is the gen-
erally accepted notion. It is an attribute that be-
longs potentially to every one of us, for we are all
responsive to melody and rhythm. There is a dif-
ference only of degree.
The mother who wants to find out the musical
aptitude of her child must know, in the first place,
WHEN IS A CHILD MUSICAL? 33
how to awaken this sleeping talent. It is hoped
that a few practical suggestions offered here may
throw some light on the way to make home help
in music study effective.
Generally the mother who feels she should have
a more active share in her child's musical educa-
tion than is represented by engaging a music
teacher and persuading father to foot the bills,
scarcely knows how to set about it. To be sure
she tries conscientiously to instill a love for music
by the various means at her command, such as
playing the piano or some other instrument, sing-
ing to her children, or having them listen to phono-
graph records, or even taking them frequently to
concerts.
All this is sensible, inspiring and helpful, but
it does not go to the root of the matter. It does
not touch the fundamental principle that makes
music the art most universal in its appeal. Many
a child fails to respond to these (for it) somewhat
complicated forms of appeal, and is therefore set
down as unmusical, when the case would have
been altogether different had this effort at de-
veloping the music sense been preceded by the
right sort of preparedness, a preparedness in
regard to which most mothers need to be enlight-
ened.
The fact of the matter is that children, long
before they arrive at the age of ^^ taking lessons,'*
should be taught many things about music before
34 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the actual study of it begins. And it is at home
where this can be done the best of all. Parents
are mainly responsible for the musical awaken-
ing of their offspring.
It is important that the child, at this age, be
not permitted to remain passive as far as his
music is concerned. What he cannot share he has
little interest in. But make him a pai-tner in this
musical game and see how he profits by it. As
soon as he ** helps,'' what joy he gets out of it.
No child is willingly a passive listener.
I am reminded of an amusing occurrence of a
little three-year-old who thus had listening thrust
upon her. It was Christmas day and the baby girl
was much engrossed in making the acquaintance
of her new doll and other toys, when this pleasant
pastime was interrupted to **come and hear
auntie play. ' '
Now auntie happened to be a professional
pianist, and she had carefully selected some of
Debussy's pieces from *^The Children's Corner"
as especially appropriate for her youthful audi-
ence. And they would have been had there been
preparation for the musical onslaught. As it was,
it was rather hard lines being required to leave
your toys and the wonderful Christmas tree and
everything just to hear someone play the piano.
But our little Miss Dutiful obeyed the summons,
pulled her tiny chair near the piano^ and while
** auntie" played, listened gravely — for about two
WHEN IS A CHILD MUSICAL? 35
minutes, then got up and with an air of sophisti-
cated politeness saying *^You play very well,
Auntie, ^ * ran back to the exciting playthings.
To make listening a duty is bound to seem irk-
some to the child, tiresome, dull, stupid. The
little one is not in the confidence of the performer.
Very soon, were such a mode of procedure per-
sisted in, he would become downright ** unmusi-
cal,*' destined ultimately to join that vast army
of * * can 't-tell-one-tune-f rom-another ' * persons.
A too well-meaning mother of my acquaintance
made just this mistake with her four-year-old boy.
She was a musically educated woman who had per-
fectly ironclad theories regarding everything
under the sun, including her boy's musical educa-
tion. He was musical. Why, of course! Wasn't
he her son? So that settled that.
So with his fourth birthday the time had
arrived for him to begin to *4ike music.'' There
had been no loving preparation beforehand, no
appeal through the wonderful play spirit in music,
no sympathetic attitude toward his baby leanings
towards music. That was all nonsense, of course.
He had consequently learned to toot vociferously,
to drum a continuous din, and generally to bang
his way along childhood's path when suddenly —
suddenly, mind you, came a change. He was to
sit quietly in the parlor for fifteen minutes at a
certain time each day, while mother played for
him beautiful music on the piano.
36 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Was it beautiful music to that small boy! In-
deed no ! His frowning face, his uneasy squirm-
ings, and his eager '* Mamma, can I go nowf all
showed the trend of his mind. He liked that daily
music dose about as much as castor oil, but it
didn^t do him as much good. Undoubtedly both
were catalogued in his youthful brain as things
to be carefully avoided ^^when I grow to be a big
man.''
That boy was undoubtedly innately musical.
By inheritance he should have been especially so.
But giving him musical food which he could not
digest not only failed to arouse his interest but
turned his passive indifference into active dis-
like. The appeal of the preceding chapter that the
music instinct should be carefully nurtured may
be repeated here and even more strongly empha-
sized. And again and always make your young
person your partner in your musical under-
takings.
Material for musical illustrations is to be found
on all sides — right at your elbow, if you wish.
There, for instance, are the water glasses on your
breakfast table — one of the best musical instru-
ments you can find. With a fork give a short
quick tap to a glass partly filled with water. It
will give a pleasant sound. Fill it full, the tone
will be lower. Empty it, and its song will now
be pitched much higher. Tap another glass, its
sound will be different. Eange several glasses in
WHEN IS A CHILD MUSICAL? 37
line, and with varying amounts of water you will
get quite a variety of tones.
Now you may begin to ask the child to co-
operate after the first attention is secured. Ask
him to imitate the sound of a single tap by singing
it. Although only a tiny tot, he will try eagerly,
and you will be surprised to find how the ability
to imitate the pitch will develop. Another tap
elsewhere. The alert child mind quickly heeds the
difference, at least after a few repetitions, and
the great principle of the up and down in music
(the difference in pitch) ding-dongs its way into
your child's consciousness. The process is as
pleasant as it is effective.
Play on your piano the note nearest in pitch
to the sound of the glass, or if you have that little
xylophone in your family, play it there. Then
sing it, using the syllable La. Ask the child to
sing it too. Then you might play a guessing game
by sounding the same pitch note on the different
instruments, provided you have more than one,
and sing the tone yourself, followed by some
other member of the family. Have your young
person blindfolded and get him to guess where
the tone comes from. And as simply as this you
can touch upon the fundamental principles of
pitch and tone quality (tone-color), thereby laying
the foundation for other amazing possibilities.
The further development of the sense of pitch
and tone quality will be the subject of succeeding
38 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
chapters. The subject matter given here is to be
used as a start in the important phase of music
sense development that must come in these early
years.
Music study, even when it comes to the way
music is made, may be so enticing that we might
call it baiting tunes with sugarplums. And if the
curibus signs and funny symbols that make music
visible are not exactly sugarplums at least you
will agree, if you know them well, that they are
something quite as desirable. There are several
good books dealing with basic music material
that are especially adapted for this home music
study. By judicious selection any mother can find
an easy and delightful way to tell Tommy and
Jean all about notes, and time, and clefs, and
staffs, and everything else that belongs to the writ-
ing of music. The teaching of the fundamentals
of music should always be made attractive.
The entire aim of modern music teaching — and
this concerns the mother as vitally as the teacher
— lies in letting musical symbols reveal them-
selves through their self-evident functions. They
should not be in the way of a child's enjoyment
of music, but simply its tools. A small black-
board in the nursery would be a great help with
a music staff painted on it — or two staffs. And
then proceed to tell your story, bit by bit as the
days pass. Children will absorb a surprising
amount of knowledge in this way, and if rightly
WHEN IS A CHILD MUSICAL? 39
administered it will simply wet their appetite for
more.
As a further step the time has now arrived for
simple music stories. An anecdote of a famous
composer's childhood whose piece you have just
heard on the phonograph, or that mother has
played on the piano, will serve to supply a new
angle of interest. Children like simple, healthy
tunes, and they like stories. Learn to correlate
them. You will be surprised to find how easy it
is to do this. Besides it is one of the ways to
make music in the home not only a study but a
real pastime.
Here then is the mother's task determined for
her. There are delightfully illustrated books
ready to aid the work, and all sorts of devices for
making home-help in music study reach its best
efficiency. If mother has not * * kept up ' ' her music
then now is her big chance to come back. Home
preparation, the creating of a musical atmosphere
calculated to meet childish needs, will do wonders
in developing your child's appreciation of music.
In his later life it will become one of his dearest
possessions, but he only truly possesses it for
whom the beginning was made in childhood.
Try then to teach your children the secrets that
lie in musical sounds, the fascination of different
tone-colors, the pulsating contagion of rhythm.
In the process do you believe you will discover
your child to be musical 1 Just try it and see !
CHAPTER IV
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION
On the seashore of endless worlds the children
meet with shouts and dances.
— Rabindranath Tagore.
We have seen in a general way how very impor-
tant these kindergarten years are in yonr child's
musical development. It has also been pointed
out how large the mother's share in this develop-
ment may be even without any real technical
knowledge. The lines to be followed — they were
merely suggested in the preceding chapter — will
be indicated more definitely here.
We are concerned in a very practical manner
now with the ** magic of music. '* The art that has
given rise to the most beautiful fairy tales in the
world — the art that even primeval man invested
with mysterious supernatural powers — this art
holds the golden key to the Palace of Imagination.
Beyond its doors lies a fairyland of beauty that
anyone may enter, and children most easily of all.
The golden key is Liking Music,
That seems simple enough, doesn't it? And yet
there are any number of perfectly well-meaning
parents and teachers who by their wrong ways of
telling about music turn the child's potential lik-
ing into the very opposite! The responsibility for
40
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 41
the proper use to be made of this period of home
help rests ahnost exclusively with the mother.
The day of the professional teacher and the time
for the formal ceremony of ^* taking lessons''
have not yet arrived.
Meanwhile let us see what the child is doing.
A small beginning has been made to develop a
sense of pitch and of tone quality. Simple little
songs are sung to him and with him. But aside
from this rather general training of the music
sense there are two elements entering into the
process that are of sufficient importance to be
given special attention. These are the appeal to
the imagination, and the development of the
rhythmic sense. The latter will be treated in a
separate chapter. Although these two character-
istics of the music sense are worked out together
each has its own functions.
The one great thing to remember always is that
the music sense is a tender thing that can easily
be killed by the wrong kind of care. With young
children as soon as music is a duty study, a task,
a burden, it at once assumes the nature of some-
thing to be avoided, and in later life it is avoided.
Now let us go back and find that golden key we
were talking about, and having found it, keep it.
"We want to appeal to the child ^s imagination.
To make him really hear music. But hearing
music does not mean merely folding your hands
and listening to a melody. It means hearing all
42 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the lovely things that music actually says to us —
and that can only be accomplished by practice, in
other words, by learning to be selective listeners.
Learning to open our ears is as much a matter
of training as anything else. Let us see what
Tommy can hear when he shuts his eyes and you
tap on one of those water glasses. Will he know
what you are tapping! Now rap on the table.
Does it make as pleasant a sound? Tap the arm
of a chair (if it is of wood) and back to the table.
Is one sound higher or lower — ^up or down? Tap
gently a bit of metal or stone in the room. Does
this sound like the wood tappings ? Play a musi-
cal note on the glass again. Then on the piano,
if you have a piano, or on the xylophone. Rap on
the window pane.
This may readily be turned into an amusing
guessing game with the faculty for distinguishing
the difference in pitch and quality growing more
acute every time it is tried.
But very possibly you are not a city flat-dweller
with only the park to go to for an outing. If the
great out-of-doors is right before you, then indeed
a whole new world of music is open to you and
your children, and all the marvels that comprise
the rainbow beauty of tone color are placed before
you for your pleasure and appreciation. So out
you go into your garden, and begin to listen.
'*But it's all still and quief the child will say.
But after a moment : ^ ^ Oh ! I hear a bird ! ' ' And
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 43
then will gradually come the consciousness of
other sounds — queer busy insects singing, maybe
leaves rustling, or there may be the tinkle, tinkle,
of a brook of running water. Nature is a whole
orchestra if only we will learn to hear its mes-
sage. A process very similar to the one conducted
indoors may be carried on here. Which sounds
are more musical (or pleasant) than others! Is
this one higher or lower than another! Can you
sing it ? The rainbow beauty of tone color is only
fully appreciated by those whose ears are open.
Appreciation of it gives a new meaning to music.
This ear training through a variety of sounds
should be done only a little at a time, and always
as nearly as possible by way of entertainment.
Never let the play spirit of music get out of your
sight. Now you can begin to correlate the bird
song you hear in the garden or through the open
window with simple songs about birds. Let the
child learn such a song. Play bird-song or bird-
call records on your phonograph.
As for the notation symbols of music, with the
aid of suitable material any mother can teach her
child all about *^ notes '* and *^time.'^ It must
be done gradually, and always with copious illus-
trations. In this, as in everything else pertaining
to the development of the music sense, let the
child be active, not passive. Make him a part of
the game.
King Harmony and Queen Melody, who together
44 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
rule in Musicland, are far too often surrounded
by dreadful bugaboos in the shape of dry, tire-
some, unexplained exercises that make the king
and queen just sit stoically on their thrones, with-
out the least bit of human interest for anyone.
So they remain very stiff and haughty. But how
gloriously resplendent King Harmony and Queen
Melody become when all their power and beauty
are revealed. You see they like to be courted and
flattered and enticed and pleased, and this all the
lovely and queer and interesting things that go
to make up our music can do so well if they are
but given a chance to show their real selves.
Many typical music games planned for class
teaching in the kindergarten cannot be easily
applied to the home teaching campaign. But any
mother knows or can learn the few notes of the
scale, c, d, e, f, g, a, b, c, and the corresponding
syllable names, do, re, mi, fa, sol, la, ti, do. Instead
of a class you have at home, we will say, two
youngsters near enough of an age so you can do
a music game with them. (Of course the game
can be played with only one child too.) Children
and mother seat themselves about a table on which
are eight blocks selected from Tommy's assort-
ment— six the same size and the two Do's larger.
Or you may just cut squares of cardboard for the
pui-pose. In that case they can be marked by
their letter and syllable names.
Now build your scale first. Sing Do, using mid-
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 45
die C on the piano if that will help yon, or sing-
ing any tone in the lower range of your voice so
the successive tones of the scale may be easily
sung. Better yet, and possibly more impressive
to the children, will be the use of a pitch pipe.
This gives the mother, who is not sure of her pitch
and has no musical instrument, a secure guide.
You are now ready to practice building the scale.
The squares (or blocks) are divided among the
players. You call for Do. Do must answer by
appearing on the table and being sung too. Re is
called for, etc., until the scale is built.
Something of this sort can be played often until
the actual building of the scale is an old story.
Now have three or four sets of your syllable
names cut into pasteboard squares with your Do
always larger because you are now going to com-
mence building melodies. The safest way to begin
your melody is with Do. You see he happens to
be a very important person indeed in the music
game. After Do is out on the table the next player
has his turn for calling the melody note, and after
him the next player until you have a song of at
least eight or nine notes all finished. Now let each
player in turn try to sing what the combined com-
pany has written. Of course this union-made
music may not turn out to be an inspired compo-
sition but it is fun and it brings music at once
close to the little people.
Let us imagine the following melody: For in-
46 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
stance Bo, Mi, Sol, Mi, Fa, Re, Do, Do, Do. There
they all are in a row. A nice little song to sing
especially if you make the last three Do^s longer
than the rest of the notes. Mother can attach
words if she likes. ^*0h, how sun-ny is the day."
Or ^'Birdie likes to fly a-way," or anything else
that comes to mind. Encourage the children by
all means to make their own songs and if their
first attempts do not conform to the rhythm, be
sure and point out what is lacking. Make your
own song definite. Every child must be a creator
if the music sense is to be properly stimulated.
This may all sound very much like regular
kindergarten teaching and it is, but it is quite
within the reach of any mother to carry on this
amount of preparation at home. And it can read-
ily be seen that when the time comes for more
formal music study, the child so prepared is in an
infinitely better position to profit by the teaching
than one who does not know how to listen.
Children are imitative. They will learn certain
little songs telling about birds, or flowers, or sun-
shine, or rain. And they will like them. More-
over they will soon hear the basic difference be-
tween what is bright and gay and what is dark
and sad. And by a very little judicious guidance
they learn to associate gaiety with quickness in
and something sad with slower, deeper tones.
The creative instinct begins to assert itself very
early and with a surprising definiteness. Now is
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 47
the time to encourage the child to set down his own
ideas, thoughts, and experiences in music. He
soon finds that music is a wonderful language of
tones in which almost anything may be described.
Sometimes a child will express a single thought
by a simple phrase, indicating a strong individual-
ity. Just as frequently the recital of an entire
story is ventured upon. All this is just a step
further away from the funny little chants baby
hums to himself while he sits on the floor of the
nursery and is busy at play.
A case in point where a child sets out to tell quite
a complicated story is that of a little girl who had
already shown considerable aptitude in this direc-
tion. She surprised her mother one day with a
complete narrative. Her * Apiece'' had the cheer-
ing title, *^The Horse is Dead.'* And there she
had it in her music — ^the impression made by
watching a horse jogging along until it fell in the
street. There came a wild but futile struggle,
spasms of energy that grew weaker and farther
apart, and finally utter helplessness and **the
horse is dead.'' The music told every bit of the
story — the rhythmic jogging, the fall, the strug-
gle, and the quiet end. It was a photograph in
tones.
But aside from the idea that their little original
efforts can tell a story, music is good for oh! so
many other wonderful things. Chief among these
is the development of the tone sense by phrases or
48 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
musical sentences and their general characteris-
tics. Here is a piece by Debussy called *^ Dancing
Snow,'' and just listen! It does actuall^^ sound
just about like the gambols of the millions of tiny
white flakes as they come dancing down to earth,
bumping into each other on the way like so many
white imps.
And when you listen to Chopin's *^ Raindrop'^
prelude, can you not shut your eyes and imagine
you are hearing the pat, pat, of the rain on the
roof? And still another very obvious nature
piece is Rive-King's ** Bubbling Spring."
These examples are mentioned simply in the
nature of hints. If you have a player piano or a
phonograph, get rolls or records dealing with
nature subjects, or play them yourself on the
piano. And it is not too soon to begin, even at this
early age, to teach the youngsters that when some
one is playing for their entertainment they must
listen quietly, that it is impolite and even rude to
talk. This is an entirely different matter from
the example in an earlier chapter where a small
boy was made to attend to his mother's playing
without being told anything about music before-
hand. The idea was that he was to absorb it like
a sponge, and the unnatural procedure very natur-
ally failed to work. But learning to listen, ad-
ministered in proper doses is easy. Concert
manners are as necessary in the home as in public
gatherings.
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 49
In these ways children begin to find out that
music can mean something in the abstract. A too
photographic adherence to ^^ story'' in music
hampers the imagination, or rather, guides it only
in a certain sense. We must always bear in mind
that all truly great music pictures moods and emo-
tions, and only rarely, photographs.
In the process of developing the tone sense,
children mil be found to have a predeliction for
certain tone qualities over others. They like the
xylophone with its clear tinkle, the flute, and
stringed instruments especially.
Not in many households are a variety of instru-
ments available but there is one that should be in
every home, in addition to the ubiquitous piano,
and that is the phonograph. Comparatively few
phonograph owners of the millions of people who
have them realize the manifold possibilities of this
mechanical reproduction of music. They read the
advertisements telling them that practically all
the great music in the world is reproduced for
them here, and then they go and buy their favorite
John McCormack record and the latest jazz, and
consider their duty done.
Now there is nothing to be said against buying
any or all of golden-voiced John's records, and
at the other end of the pole, jazz has its rightful
though limited space too. But there is a world
of music in between that should not be overlooked.
In the meanwhile we are not ready yet to take
50 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
up the question of home repertoire, but we are
ready to find out more about training Young
America's sense of tone-color.
Symphony orchestras are not available except-
ing in a few cities, and even so it is only in New
York, and Chicago, up to the present time, (1920),
that orchestral concerts for children have been
attempted and given successfully with explana-
tions about the compositions. Moreover these are
intended for children of public school age and our
tiny tots are scarcely ready for these concerts even
if they live where they can get to them.
But records have now been made for a great
variety of instruments, and if you will ask your
local dealer to send for the educational record
list you will find there the different instruments
nicely catalogued. Only a few simple records of
the flute (something birdlike) or the piccolo or
the drum would be liked by the very young chil-
dren, but it is a suggestion for the way in which
the home campaign for good music can be con-
ducted later. Start right now. Training the
music sense can never begin too soon.
In this early training of the tone sense it is
important, too, to avoid harsh and discordant
sounds. Be careful in the kind of toys you give
your children. You might just as well give them
something pleasant to play on as something ear-
splitting. A drum is better than a shrill whistle,
or if your small boy must blow, get him a jewsharp
APPEAL TO THE IMAGINATION 51
or a small fife. The xylophone again is brought
forward as an important adjunct of the nursery
and play room. With a padded stick it makes a
pleasant musical sound. It is just as great fun
as any kind of a discordant musicbox in the shape
of a ^'play'^ piano, and far better for your child's
musical development. As has been pointed out
before, it is inexpensive, too, the smallest costing
only about four dollars. It has a tone quality
children love.
All of this time you have been teaching the child
to realize that music is everywhere — not just
imprisoned in the wooden box of piano or phono-
graph. And you have taken the first steps to
prove to your child and yourself (for parents
need to be educated along these lines too) that
learning about music may become just a fascinat-
ing game. Its object may be entirely educational,
but it functions as much more than that, and much
of this ^^more^' is embodied in the appeal to the
imagination.
And so it is up to the parents, and the mother
especially, to guide her young hopeful on his
musical way. The imagination of the child,
always easily touched, finds in this journey
through music land as much to marvel at as ever
did Alice in Wonderland. Here in this Wonder-
land are to be found rainbow-hued tone colors,
wildly contagious rhythms, and beautiful melo-
dies. And by giving your child the golden key
52 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
called ^^ Liking Music" you open to him the door
that leads to this rich heritage for which he will
be increasingly grateful to you during each suc-
cessive year of his life.
CHAPTER V
DEVELOPING THE RHYTHMIC SENSE
And in their first learning of notes they shall
be taught the great purpose of music.
— Ruskin.
The play of imagination in music is seldom
quite free from the rhythmic element. In fact it
might be roughly stated that it is the combination
of the two that makes musical sounds and music.
And it is not only in formal musical composition
that this is true, but the law of time, of persistent
iteration of a definite pattern, is the fundaraiental
characteristic of all musical sounds in nature. It
is only noise — the Bolshevik in the world of
sound — that apparently knows no law.
We all know how regular a bird-call is and how
individual. And what more accurate pattern of
sound could you ask for than the song of the
whippoorwill, the katydid's alternating ^^Katy
Did'' and ^^Katy Didn't," the cricket's chirp, or
even the bull frog's basso prof undo? Law and
order in nature everywhere.
The persistent repetition of the same musical
figure is what first excites our attention, then,
secondly, makes us familiar with the tune so that
particular song comes to be connected with
53
54
PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
certain familiar creatures, and even bespeaks
definite nature moods, like the robin's ''Rain
Song.''
This system of law and order indulged in by-
nature's orchestra very naturally carries over
into man's first attempt at articulate emotional
expression. Primitive man soon found that to
make his grunts or his cries take on meaning
they had to attain individual character, so that
they might be differentiated from each other. So
his short phrases of sound gradually emerged into
the pattern state until primitive speech — and
similarly primitive ^* music" — took on the quality
of an interminable repetition as the most marked
of its characteristics.
Here is a favorite song of the natives of New
South Wales in Australia:
^
^-4;> — ^— h-f^ \) \) ["> -y
^ ^ 4
Bar ra bul a bar - ra - ma bar ra bul a bar-
i
fF^Ft^
:l5=t5:
.U^ D J^ r^
atzt
-w^w
WW
ra • ma bar ra bul a bar - ra - ma bar ra bul a bar-
^^
fl Tr
etc.
ra - ma bar ra bul a bar - ra - ma
And so it went on forevermore.
DEVELOPING THE RHYTHMIC SENSE 55
Beautiful, isn't it? At least you will admit
that it is a distinct time pattern. After several
repetitions on a given pitch the chant is trans-
ferred in toto to the next lower tone and so it goes
on for almost an eternity.
With savages their beginnings of music were
always accompanied by gesture, and considering
the monotony and limited range of their music
expression it is not surprising that gesture was
needed to make it intelligible. As civilization
progressed, the spontaneous expression of human
feelings through music developed into the folk
song, and the true folk song was almost invari-
ably an action song.
This translation of the folk spirit in music is
accurately reflected in the play of our children.
All childish pastimes in the way of games are
governed by time laws. The rhythmic pattern is
everywhere in evidence. They skip rope to a
regular beat, clap hands in time to familiar jingles,
sing songs in regular time, hop, skip, jump, and
make up words to accompany certain activities,
all of them with a regular rotation of accent.
Wherever a group gathers rhythm obtrudes itself.
Even the boy who goes whistling down the street
alone with a stick in his hand, will whack at pass-
ing objects on a regular time schedule.
This rhythmic expression is, of course, entirely
spontaneous and evidently necessary to the satis-
faction of an innate sense and desire. Without
56 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
regularity expressive movement loses its mean-
ing— becomes expressionless. It does not carry.
And while neither savages or children know this
or reason about it, they instinctively obey this hid-
den law that governs all emotional expression
indulged in for an ulterior end.
If we need any further proof that rhythmic
expression is the answer to an inner law, we need
merely note the contagious effect of rhythm. It
invariably sets up an impulse to imitate, to go
along with it, even as the small boy trails the mili-
tary band and keeps in touch with its martial
music. And not only he but every grown up
within ear shot does the same thing, the only dif-
ference being that the grown up child obeys the
impulse somewhat sheepishly, and often even
breaks the contagious circle by refusing to obey
it, although it is only with a wrench that this is
accomplished.
Meanwhile what is the psychological effect of
that stirring band music! Does it make for
slouchiness of carriage, for a shambling walk, or
anything that speaks of ill directed energy? Cer-
tainly not. The boy who obeys the impulse it
creates walks with head erect, shoulders thrown
back, a firm step, and energy galvanizing every
limb. Followed long enough it awakens ambition,
brings dreams of power, breeds incipient success.
Some of the psychological effects of rhythms as
applied to household problems will be touched
DEVELOPING THE RHYTHMIC SENSE 57
upon in a later chapter. What concerns us more
directly now is the usefulness of rhythm when
properly applied to the development of the music
sense in the child.
It has already been noted that the baby will
imitate a rhythmic tapping on the table long
before he can sense a melody, and so it is but
natural that this innate feeling for rhythm
responds most heartily to a demonstration of it
in nursery rhymes and jingles and tunes.
Falling back on dear Old Mother Goose — what
would we do without herf — these familiar jingles
lend themselves very naturally to musical treat-
ment. They have been placed in innumerable
settings, and any mother can get some of these
through her local music dealer and play them on
the piano. Or they can be had in phonograph rec-
ords and even player piano rolls. The desirable
way in any case, to get the child's cooperation, is
to make him an active partner in doing these songs
and rhythmic games. That is just it. They must
be done, not merely sung. That passive listening
process is to be carefully avoided, excepting for
the rare occasions when a piece by a famous com-
poser is to ^^ entertain '^ the nursery habitues. In
such instances — it has already been emphasized —
it is most desirable to impress with the fact that
the *^ polite person '^ listens quietly to music made
for his entertainment, just as he must listen to
anyone talking to him.
58 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Let US take a concrete example by way of illus-
trating what can be done with one of these action
songs. For instance you are concerned for the
moment with a lively march. If mother plays it
herself on the piano, and the family consists of
only one child, then mother can count the time
out loud, and get Jean or Tommy to march around
the room in time to the music. Play at ^* High-
stepping Horses,^' or *^ Brave Soldier, '^ or any-
thing that will make it definitely a game. When
the first step is accomplished, let the small boy
march along clapping his hands together on the
first beat. Perhaps sister is there and will accent
the beat by a tap on her xylophone.
If the mother is alone in this teaching game a
phonograph is an invaluable aid for it leaves her
free to suggest and play with the children. Every-
one likes to beat time and children are so suscep-
tible to impressions that they catch and follow any
simple rhythm very easily. Learning to keep time
can also be done by tapping with a ruler or pencil
or little stick on the table. There are many differ-
ent ways of doing just this one simple thing that
will readily suggest themselves to any resource-
ful mother. While developing your child 's imag-
ination do not neglect your own.
While we have been busily discussing the
aesthetic value to the child we have almost over-
looked one of the most beneficial results of the
development of the rhythmic sense and that is a
DEVELOPING THE RHYTHMIC SENSE 59
purely physical one — the effect on the child's
health and his bodily grace.
While the mother at home cannot without due
study and technical knowledge carry this idea
very far, there is nevertheless opportunity right
at home to develop this phase of physical expres-
sion. Ehythmic movements are almost always
graceful, for the fact of being engrossed with
rhythm frees the child from a natural awkward-
ness. Grace of body, improvement in carriage,
with their attendant good effects on the general
health, are the result. In fact grave physical
defects and ailments have been cured through
such exercises. But to obtain curative results for
a physical disability the child must, of course, be
placed in care of a teacher who has made a thor-
ough study of this.
Music is a wonderful stimulus to any kind of
physical training, as it is infinitely easier to go
through any drill with the urge of rhythmic
melody weaving its magic spell.
While the bodily motion in time to a tune makes
the sense of rhythm more acute, the carrying out
of the action by way of illustrating the words is
going a considerable step further. The child
swaying his little body while he sings of the wind
swaying the branches of the trees becomes at
once a creator. He is virtually making the song
all over again and living it himself. His sense of
spontaneous musical expression having not yet
60 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
been educated into a self conscious nothingness,
he naturally loves to sing, and it is easy for Mm
to associate the words with the right expressive
action and the music.
It now lies with the mother to bring into this
teaching as much of beauty as she can. The cor-
nerstone of the love for beautiful things, including
music, must be laid in childhood. Therefore it is
of the utmost importance to make the music atmos-
phere you are creating in the home consistent with
itself. See to it that your children learn to know
the best. Having come to know it they will love
it.
But children should not be bored by being made
to listen to music for which they are too undevel-
oped. Don't force Beethoven sonatas and sym-
phony concerts on them against their will. It is
just as easy to instill an antagonism against music
as to develop liking and appreciation for it.
The time is now ripe to commence the process
of ** learning to like'' works by famous composers.
Compositions having direct melodies and strongly
marked characteristics, either in rhythm or in a
descriptive sense, should be used for these first
home concerts. By the judicious first training in
which the child is made to distinguish sounds in
nature, and something of individual tone qualities
(actually tone colors) this followed by the right
beginnings in music itself, the child has now
reached the point where the action songs, the
DEVELOPING THE RHYTHMIC SENSE 61
rhythmic drills and the tone sense exercises may
safely be interspersed with occasional episodes of
passive listening.
All the beautiful things they know children will
find paralleled in music. All their experiences
are here reflected, somewhere, somehow. Such
pieces as ^'The Happy Farmer^' by Schumann,
^^ Simple Confession'' by Thome, ^^The Anvil
Chorus'' from *^I1 Trovatore" by Verdi are
examples of melodious pieces that children enjoy.
A full list of music for the home repertoire will be
given in the last chapter. All such music may be
obtained as records or player rolls or in arrange-
ments for piano, violin or other instruments.
In collecting your phonograph library it is
quite as important for the sake of the youngsters
in the family as well as the older people that the
collection be as carefully watched as the piano
rack. The music in the home should be good but
always easily likable. Again you must be
reminded here that appreciation of music must
not be exposed to a forcing process.
In connection with a composition by a famous
composer it is most useful to tell something about
the man who made the music, and of course the
title should be explained too, if it does not tell its
own story. Some mothers have even undertaken
with success to gather together a group of chil-
dren in the neighborhood once a week for a very
special music playtime. Then indeed all the pos-
62 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
sible music games, such as the tone-guessing
game, singing and action games, and regular
music-lesson games, like the building-melody
games, described in the previous chapter, can
become of exceeding usefulness.
Can one doubt the value of this introduction to
music under the right auspices? The develop-
ment of the music sense depends absolutely on
these earliest impressions. Bugaboos and tire-
some tasks must be side stepped. Sensible
methods must be substituted.
And the finest thing about it all is that the
mother, even without any practical training and
technical knowledge, can open a whole new world
to the child. The sound-world is quite as wonder-
ful as the world we see, and yet nearly all of us
are quite deaf to its infinite variety. Learning to
hear means opening an additional world of beauty
to the soul of a little child. Instinctively music is
welcomed by the budding intelligence for all it
has to give of soothing harmonies and stimulating
rhythms. A child surrounded by good music from
its infancy learns to like it as naturally as it
learns to speak. And once rooted in the child
heart it will blossom into a flower of happiness
that will be the richest heritage your child can
possess.
CHAPTER VI
TAKING LESSONS
Five and thirty black slaves,
Half a hundred white,
All their duty but to sing
For this Queen's delight,
Now with throats of thunder.
Now with dulcet lips,
While she rules them royally
With her finger tips.
— William Watson,
Now we have arrived at the stage when * * taking
music lessons ^^ is conceived to be a necessary-
factor in every child's education. It is. Only it
is rather appalling to see how much misdirected
effort, money, talent, and energy have been wasted
in this direction.
There are two reasons for this : wrong methods
of instruction, and lack of preparedness in the
home. Perversely we shall take up the last point
first.
Lack of preparedness has much to account for
because to it is the fact that many potential
musicians never come into their own. And by the
word ** musicians'' as used here, the professional
music-maker is not necessarily referred to, but
rather just that regular human being who was
born with the love of music in his heart but whose
63
64 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
natural instincts in this direction became killed
through neglect and lack of exercise.
Now your child is such a potential musician to
whom you naturally wish to give every advantage.
So the question uppermost in your mind now is :
At what age shall my child begin music lessons?
And by *^ music lessons'' the reference is almost
invariably to the piano. Even where the study of
another instrument is contemplated, some study
of the piano should come first.
If the child is well and strong, six years of age
i^ the time to begin, or as soon after that as pos-
sible. And get the best teacher you can find —
never mind the expense. Banish the thought that
^^ almost any teacher'' will do for a beginning.
The right teaching is more important then than
at any other time. You know what happens to
the young sapling that is not made to grow
straight from the first.
The harm done by careless or incompetent
teaching is not confined to a waste of energy, pos-
sible talent and money — although all these are
precious enough in themselves — but its most costly
result lies in the stultifying of the music sense.
It is quite as easy to turn out music haters as
music lovers, and the antiquated ideas that pre-
vailed (and unhappily still prevail to a large ex-
tent) regarding the teaching of music, were the
most prolific breeders of music haters one could
possibly imagine.
TAKING LESSONS 65
Look about you at the number of persons who
*^took music'' in their youth. How many have
*^kept it up/' or are now apparently lovers of
music? Very few indeed, in fact a woefully small
percentage, in view of the fact that ^* taking
music" at some time in our lives is an almost
universal penalty. Yes, penalty is right. Even
if you can point out a few bright and shining
examples of really musical persons who retained
that much desired attribute in spite of mistaken
pedagogic notions through which they fought their
way, their ultimate triumph but emphasizes the
rarity of the occurrence. Do any of us need to
be reminded of the hemi-demi-semi-quaver method
of our youth? Can we ever forget the hours of
toil dragged out in weary attempt to capture the
enigma of minor scales, or to solve the obstinate
vagaries of ^ ^ time ' ' ?
And then there was your thumb! It just
wouldn 't go under the right finger. With sheer ob-
stinacy it floundered about with all the grace of a
fish out of water, and was quite as unmanageable.
In school or out of it you learned your songs ^^by
rote," didn't you, with a lot of meaningless do-re-
mi-fa's thrown in that rose up and smote you
with bad marks if you tried to disentangle them
from what seemed a silly procession of sounds.
Your child mind was so taken up with watch-
ing fingers, or black dots, or syllables, that you
didn't hear the tune at all, did you? And as for
66 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
harmony — the marvelous combination of sounds
that makes music — why it might just as well not
have existed at all. No wonder you hated to
practice when every minute spent over music page
resolved itself into a period of black drudgery
from which you were only too eager to escape.
Making children **hate to practice*' means mak-
ing children *^hate music/' and this antagonism,
so unwittingly instilled, requires many years to
eradicate. Only with maturity when music has
become a part of our cultural existence, is reborn
the desire to know something about it. And this
desire is most frequently embodied in the familiar
remark *^I wish my mother had made me prac-
tice!'' Do you realize that in most cases
^'mother" did I That she used all the persuasive
means in her power from bribes to punishment,
according to her individual light! Mother did,
you may be sure, until her patience and father's
purse gave out. Then daughter's music was
stalled half way down the road to anywhere, re-
maining but a fitfully flickering accomplishment
of a sort that gives more pain than pleasure.
Has it ever occurred to you that when you view
at maturity the ruins of what was once intended
for a musical education, instead of saying **I
wish my mother had made me practice" you
should say ^^I wish my music teacher had had
some sense"? Mother, you must remember, had
the patience, mother was eager to help, mother
TAKING LESSONS 67
was ambitious for you, and you may rest assured
she worked harder in her tender watchfulness to
make a musician out of you than did either you or
your benighted teacher. But how could mother
be expected to know that the expert was at faulty
and that there must be some real reason, quite
outside of music itself, that made you so hate to
practice ?
Yes, that is the calamity. The child dislikes,
the practice hour, must be .driven to it. And the
most natural course of reasoning to follow (and
this is followed by most parents) is that if the
child dislikes to practice, he must be unmusical.
This is not true. The child dislikes to practice
because he is not being taught in the right way.
The inner mind of the greater part of the vast
army of music teachers seems to be a solid phalanx
of black notes arranged into exercises. These
meaningless arrangements of notes that in them-
selve have no good reason for being are thrust
upon the child with the admonition that they are
good for him — that without practicing them he
cannot learn to play. They are to be done so and
so many times, and must not on any account be
neglected for the more pleasant 'Apiece.''
It is at the door of this fetish, the mechanical
exercise, that so many musical deaths must be
laid. Nothing so easily dulls the interest, finally
causing an actual loathing as the senseless repeti-
tion of a dry and useless task. It gets the pupil
68 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
nowhere, but takes the edge off his interest even
if it does not completely exterminate his ambi-
tion. And worst of all it does not help his playing.
Once more, if there are those who come through
the antequated methods with flying colors, it is in
spite of them, not because of them.
You ask why it is that such wrong ideas have
been permitted to dominate the teaching of music?
Because the beauty of the art was lost sight of in
the contemplation of technical proficiency. The
mechanics of music became the end and aim with
the interpretative values left to shift for them-
selves. Moreover there has been no standard of
teaching possible. Anyone who wants to do so
can teach music. There is no law to stop him.
And to such a one (and to many of greater knowl-
edge) music is just so many black notes! No
wonder the object of such a method learns to dis-
like music and later in life avoids it as he would
the influenza.
The old-fashioned idea about music study made
of it a deadly serious business. It was supposed
and expected to be tiresome, dull, uninteresting.
The object was to learn certain set ** pieces'' that
could be played. The showing-off notion was for-
ever kept in the foreground, and was indulged in
on every possible occasion, much to the politely
concealed distress of the listeners. There was a
definite cut and dried method. All children were
subjected to the same process. So and so much
TAKING LESSONS 69
of this, such and such a time for that. If every-
thing went all right, in due time a musician
(heaven save the mark!) was manufactured. He
was union-made, a replica of all those who had
gone before, and with all the individuality crushed
out of him.
Now all this is being changed. Psychology has
come to the aid of music teaching as it has come
to other branches of pedagogics. And there is
besides, an awakened sense of the beauty as well as
the usefulness of the art. Music study is no longer
considered by progressive educators as simply a
frill, an accomplishment. It being accepted as a
first-class mind-trainer, and as a practical and
cultural factor in the general educational scheme.
And with these progressive ideas the music pro-
fessor is rapidly falling into line.
The up-to-date teacher, with modem ideas and
a new knowledge, teaches music, not notes, and
live children, not automatons. The kind of
musical bent is considered, and the potential talent
is brought from hiding where neglect had rele-
gated it, and made to show what it can do. The
most unmusical on the surface is perhaps the liv-
ing receptacle of hidden fires. One backward
pupil, with tender watchfulness, sometimes be-
comes a star. The work assigned is cut out to
meet individual needs. And above all the beau-
ties of tone-color, or rhythm, or character in
music, is made clear.
70 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
All the undesirable elements of hackneyed
methods are becoming properly unpopular. The
new ways are bringing results that are not only
infinitely better than the old ways, but much
quicker. (Though not too quick!)
Children know more about real music now after
six months * study than many of their elders have
ever known. That is because music study is no
longer a bugbear but a delight, an educational
pastime instead of an abhorred task. These new
ways have sincerity of purpose and thorough
knowledge behind them. Every step is logically
prepared. Every new group of facts is presented
at the right psychological moment. There is no
senseless leaping forward into the unknown, no
contradiction of terms and reasons. From the
very beginning the child is taught to think music
and to feel its beauty.
The big, helpful, transforming influence of the
art is finally coming into its own. Our children
are exposed to very different treatment from the
semi-quaver days of our youth. Notes are being
relegated to where they belong as symbols, and
symbols only. ' ' Time ' ' and ^ ' beats ' ^ and ' ' signs ' '
are no longer permitted to usurp the thought of
the child as though they made the music, when it
is music that has made them. And so the rocky
road of music study is being made smooth. The
path is finally being cleared for the real beauty
of the art and its almost uncanny potency.
TAKING LESSONS 71
To primitive man music was a wondrous thing
emanating from a supernatural source, a gift of
the gods, holding within itself a strange mysteri-
ous power. And that power, to which we vibrate
with varying degrees of responsiveness, it felt by
all. Only the child, like the primitive man, is
touched even more readily than its elders.
The aim of the modern teacher is to forget the
obvious complexities of musical symbols, simply
letting them reveal to us the direct message of
music which is, after all, their self-evident func-
tion. The ^^new'' way of teaching music takes
into consideration the instinct for rhythm and
the feeling for tune. Even the color blind can
see outline and object. Even the tone deaf can
sense many definite gradations of pitch. ' ' The up
and downness is so exciting!'^ one little girl
exclaimed after she had eagerly sung the melody
exercise just placed upon the board. And she was
only one of many profiting by progressive methods
of teaching.
Thought and care go into the scientifically
planned study whereby the maximum of result is
attained with the minimum of effort, and the study
path is so strewn with roses that the eager, ques-
tioning child mind is held and fascinated. In
other words the new way is bringing happiness
where formerly there was only drudgery, and the
number of music lovers being grown promises a
bumper crop. After all, learning about music —
72 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
if it is presented properly — is one of the easiest
things our children do.
And in all of this the mother can help wonder-
fully. While the actual practice should be ad-
hered to strictly according to the lines laid down
by the teacher, the musical atmosphere created in
the home will do much to further development.
The child must ^^get its music lesson'^ but any
other music entering into its life (if judiciously
guided) will be a help, not a hindrance. The child
should be encouraged to play with the piano — to
look upon the instrument as a friend. By trying
some of mother's music lying on top of the piano
there is an added stimulus in finding new fields to
conquer. And any such spontaneous playing
around will make for a greater love of music than
if every note but the prescribed lesson is forbid-
den. It is up to the mother to see to it that the
lessons are properly prepared and that time spent
otherwise with music be in due proportion.
CHAPTER VII
DELINQUENT PARENTS
If parents would remember that upon the first
lessons rests nearly everything, the sending of
impressionable minds to teachers without a stan-
dard of educational value would cease. And how
it would weed out the teachers!
— T. Carl Whitmer.
We have already seen that to cultivate musical
taste the beginning should be made in infancy.
The time to start the development of the music
sense actually does begin with the mother ^s first
lullaby, of all the songs of occupation the most
beautiful. It has also been pointed out that an
amazing amount of musical preparedness may be
done — and the musical millennium will have
arrived when it is done — throughout the first six
years, or until the time for ^ taking lessons^'
arrives. The benefits resulting from awakening
the listening sense, from unstopping little deaf
ears, from appealing to the imagination, all these
will bring in an accrued income on which the only
tax will be a more developed personality.
And one of the main objects of this discussion
is to prove to parents that they have an obliga-
tion to fulfill as important as any for which they,
as parents, are responsible.
There is no reason why the home training
73
74 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
should be entirely transferred to the shoulders
of the specialist when he is engaged as a teacher
and the properly trained parent who, up to the
time of engaging a teacher has been trying to
spread the gospel of melody in the household,
is not likely to lay down that activity with the
advent of formal study. But unfortunately very
few parents, up to now, realize the value of this
formative musical period, and while they may try
to make up for their neglect later on their very
natural tendency is to let the teacher do it.
Now we will assume for the moment that this
is your attitude, but that you are fortunately in
a position to engage a well-equipped progressive
teacher who is acquainted with modem methods
and practices them. You arrange for the time the
lessons are to be given, the matter of price and
the terms of payment are agreed upon, father is
notified of his share in the proceedings, which
means paying the bill, and then at 4 o 'clock Tues-
days and Fridays, for a space of thirty minutes
six-year-old Jeanie is to be given music.
Has it occurred to you what an insurmountable
task you are setting even the best teacher in the
world? During that half hour time must be found
to explain something of the symbols by which
music is made visible to us, the mysteries of time
and accent (rhythm) must be gone into, the key-
board of the piano must become as an open book,
the child must be taught to hear, to learn the
DELINQUENT PARENTS 75
meaning of music, why and when music is fast or
slow, something of the general character of the
piece being studied, and enough of information
about the man or woman who wrote it to create
interest there.
Not only the practice time but the way to prac-
tice (more important than the amount of time)
must be gone into. And all this must be done with
so much zeal, so much of live determination and
sensible equipment that the young mind will catch
the impetus of the inspiration to such an extent
that it will carry over and through the interven-
ing days. After all you are demanding quite a
little of teacher are you not ?
Now the worst of it is that in the vast majority
of cases the mother explains that she would pre-
fer to have Jeanie take only one lesson a week.
**I don't want her to work too hard,'' and then,
too, there may be a question of finances.
When you realize the many-sidedness of the
music study problem, is it any wonder that there
are such miles of failures to one success ? Or that
so many do not ' ' seem to get on ' ' until finally the
stimulus of the initial interests changes into in-
diiference and ultimately, in many cases, into ac-
tive dislike? Lack of proper progress is discourag-
ing alike to pupil and parent. Finally after five
or six years of a desultory pursuit of the will-o'-
the-wisp of musical excellence, the entire thing
is given up as a bad job. ^* Jeanie likes to hear
76 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
music but she never liked to practice.'' Poor
Jeanie ! Poor teacher ! Poor mother ! And do we
hear a sort of basso profundo echo, Poor father !
For it is Dad who in all probability has paid the
bills.
Now the most appalling phase of all this is that
Dad's outlay in dollars and cents represents only
a fraction of the wasted expenditure. And what
has gone into the maw of futile effort is some-
thing more precious than money. They are energy,
ambition, perversion of talent, your child ^s right
to music, and her ability to enter this unseen world
of beauty. The child's instinctive music sense has
been weakened and possibly actually killed by this
unintentional but nevertheless serious neglect.
It is but natural to blame the teacher for the
inevitable result, and yet even if the instructor
represents the best of his class, the result is very
apt to be just what has been indicated here. How
much more likely then, that apparently unmusical
humans will be the result of teaching that is not
the best, or even half way good. Unhappily the
new and broader vision that is revolutionizing the
teaching of music is only fairly started in its fight
to overthrow the strongly entrenched methods of
a former generation.
The cumbersome, inefficient, uphill way, paved
with good intentions to be sure, but strewn with
the dead stones of meaningless exercises and un-
alloyed dullness, is still much in the ascendancy.
DELINQUENT PARENTS 77
Pedantic textbook knowledge still proudly waves
its banner even in the face of the inroads made
by progressive ideas that have called applied
psychology to the rescue. Teaching music, in the
eyes of the vast majority, still consists of notes
and beats. There are only a few who are daring
to substitute for these tone and beauty.
But whether the teaching is good or bad, the
active cooperation of the parents, and probably
especially the mother, is not only desirable but
necessary if worth while results are to be attained.
Here is a responsibility that cannot and should
not be turned over to the teacher. You should
know, to the best of your ability, how and what
your child is being taught. The mother, if she
does not want to be set down as a delinquent par-
ent, will try to be present when the lesson is given,
and even if she has not kept up her own playing
she nevertheless can follow easily the general
course pursued by the teacher.
For another thing the child ^s practice should
be supervised as closely as possible that the in-
tervals between lessons may be employed to good
advantage. This is of great importance for the
'more intelligently the child practices the more
rapid will be the progress, and progress brings
contentment of spirit and joy in the doing.
'^ But there is another side to the shield. The
parent's desire for progress should not lead to
direct or indirect interference with the teacher's
78 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
plans. The familiar flower of the showing-off
spirit generally manifests itself about the time of
the second lesson. **How soon can Tommy have
a piece?'' And Tommy, big-eyed, looks at his
teacher-fate and eloquently though silently sec-
onds the implied plea.
Now if the teacher is weak-kneed, he succumbs
to the wdshes of the fond parent and the carefully
laid plan of study is given the first blow. With
this precedent established, other evasions soon fol-
low, and it is only later that the folly of the too
supple specialist is revealed. This interference
by parents is no idle tale. It is happening right
along and plays havoc at every turn.
What the teacher should have is cooperation,
not interference. But how can the parent be help-
ful without becoming acquainted with the details
of the music teacher's plans and ideas of work?
Pigeonholding your child's education by labeling
these hours at school or with a governess, those
hours for exercise, and such and such hours for
music, may imply a systematic arrangement, but
it is not particularly sympathetic. In the homes
where many social duties relegate the child's ac-
tivities largely to the guidance of teachers or
servants, the neglect by parents of the most essen-
tial element in the child's development — that of
sympathetic help — is frequently appalling.
I am reminded of a recent occurrence in the
leading music store of one of our largest cities.
DELINQUENT PARENTS 79
At one of the counters sat a very well dressed
alert young woman of twenty-eight or thirty, read-
ing a book. A few minutes earlier she had given
a clerk a slip of paper with the admonition,
** Please fill this." Evidently the long list was
a musical prescription. It had been made out
by a well known and very successful teacher.
Among other things the list called for a key-
board chart, one of the several devices now in
use for making clear the composition of the piano
keyboard.
Presently the clerk returned with several dif-
ferent charts and disturbed this very modern
young mother at her reading. *^ Which one of
these do you want. Madam?''
Impatiently the customer looked up from her
book, glanced at the charts unseeingly, and ex-
claimed, **Why, I don't know anything about it.
This list was made out by my little girl's music
teacher. Put it together the way you think best
and don't bother me with it."
This was letting teacher do it with a vengeance.
It showed an utter lack of interest in this phase of
the little daughter's education and development,
and was a distinctly unsympathetic attitude. And
yet this parent would be highly incensed at being
placed in the delinquent class. **Why! we do
everything for our little girl. Give her the best
teachers and the best of care!"
That is all very well, but in the development of
80 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the music sense there is something very precious
and very tender that must be nurtured by love
and sympathy if it is to grow into the beautiful
flower of music appreciation later in life.
Another very common delinquency on the part
of parents concerns most especially that omni-
present household utility, the piano. No other
piece of furniture in the home is so mistreated.
A sort of step-child of the household gods, one
would imagine, for it seems that anything is good
enough for it. It is placed near an open door or a
steam radiator or a thin outside wall where the
alternating heat and cold play havoc with its
insides. All sorts of coverings are permitted with
a view to enhancing its charms to the eye, although
they muffle the tone and interfere with its song.
Various objects ornament its top and then beat
a kind of accompanying tatoo whenever the piano
is played.
But worst of all the inside works are allowed to
deteriorate for lack of the proper attention. It is
only when the poor decrepid thing is so far run
down that its condition is pitiable, that the piano
doctor, otherwise the tuner, is called in to do his
worst.
The admonition to keep the piano in tune which
went with its sale was promptly forgotten or con-
sidered unnecessary. And the family ear was not
acutely enough attuned to pitch to hear when it
began to get out of tune. So probably the tuner is
DELINQUENT PARENTS 81
not called in until the abused box of ivories cries
out in agony, sending out an s. o. s. signal in the
form of a rattle. Then the tuner comes and fixes
it up as best he can, but in the meanwhile, if the
neglect has covered a considerable period, a
deterioration has taken place that is beyond
repair.
Few people realize that to permit a piano to
stand out of tune results in a real injury to its
quality. And furthermore when a piano is badly
out of tune, the strings will not hold when they are
pulled up again to the proper pitch. A piano,
to give the best service and have the longest life,
should be tuned four times a year. Then it will
act like one of the family instead of like a dis-
graced step-child, and will reward you by good
behaviour.
Another item. Having an instrument out of
tune in the home spoils your sense of hearing
music. It demoralizes your ear for music. You
and your family become so accustomed to the in-
harmonious tinkle that you actually are not aware
of its disagreeable effect. This is directly harm-
ful to that development of the music sense which
we are talking about.
These then are a few hints which the fond
parent, with or without technical knowledge, can
use in order to be an active partner in the child *s
music study. Intelligent and sympathetic coopera-
tion, ranging from non-interference to keeping the
82 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
piano tuned, will turn into a well paying invest-
ment the money spent for music lessons, and will
lift the parent out of the delinquent class into that
of a first aider.
CHAPTER VIII
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
Every well-trained youth and girl ought to be
taught the elements of music early and accurately.
— Ruskin.
In order to continue the journey of the child ^s
musical education we must leave the home training
for a time and consider what is going on in our
public schools. A story of remarkable progress
we shall find there. But like all good things it
has had to fight for its present position, and is
still fighting.
Not so very long ago quite a well-known edu-
cator stated in a book (on high school studies)
that ^^ music is still a doubtful member of the
academic family.'' And this old-fogy idea of his
is still shared by an overwhelming number of
school men who have not concerned themselves
with the harmonious revolution that has gone on
about them. Because music didn't count for any-
thing in their school days, they are sleepily abid-
ing by their own experience, instead of opening
their eyes to the present day status of music and
the modem methods of teaching.
It is almost impossible to think what our public
schools would be like without music, its part is so
essential and beautiful. And in those first early
83
84 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
days at school, in the lower primary grades or in
the kindergarten — how much music means then!
The game-songs are such fun, and they do so
help you to get acquainted and make friends, and
take the edge off the strangeness and awsomeness
of it all. They help mightily, and the memory of
them constitutes a sunshiny background through
all the school days to come. Yes, and after the
school days, too!
The inclusion of music in the school curriculum
as an educative factor of the first importance is
nothing new. Only its present day application
is new. The Greeks recognized and preached the
value of music. **It is the essence of law and order
and leads to all that is good'' said Plato. *^ Music
is one of the best mind-trainers," say our modem
educators. And Dr. P. P. Claxton, Commissioner
of the National Bureau of Education, says:
** After the beginnings of reading, writing, arith-
metic and geometry, music has greater practical
value than any other subject taught in the
schools."
But meanwhile, as was pointed out before, in
the school-room music has had to fight for its life.
Unthinkingly it was set down as a frill, a pastime,
an educative fifth wheel. All very pleasant, per-
haps, but of no real practical value. And the
impetus so thoughtlessly set in motiom gained
force and weight until it has taken a real cam-
paign for musical righteousness to bring the tune-
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 85
ful art back into the educational scheme where
the Greeks of old, in all their wisdom, first
placed it.
All the way down the road and back again we
have come, until finally it was raised to the dig-
nity of the ^^ Three E's,^' and today the new
algebraic symbol for rudimentary education is 3
E's + M. The view that ^^ anybody can teach
music '^ is long dead. Instead of being an added
function placed upon the already burdened shoul-
ders of the school teacher for the purpose of
interpolating a bit of relaxation from the arduous
mental labors of the three E's, music is now being
taught by highly specialized teachers who have
been duly prepared for the work, and the study
has gained correspondingly in importance and
value.
Modern music methods are demolishing the
old-time mechanical training that spent its time
anxiously over the cataclysmic difference between
F sharp and G flat, but had no time for th^nes-
t^sage of beauty and emotional reaction that is the
true function of music./ All this is being changed,
and music is being used to develop perception, to
train the memory, to stimulate the imagination,
to encourage concentration. It brings poise and
confidence to the backward pupil, it makes the
alert one reach out to the limit of his capacity.
In the right hands it can be made the most pleas-
ant and unifying element in school life. And best
86 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
of all, its beneficent influence will not stop with
the slamming of the school door, but will con-
tinue to exert its helpfulness throughout all the
years of one's life.
The subject is one entirely too big to permit of
exhaustive treatment here, but I shall try to point
out briefly a few of the outstanding advantages
of modern methods as applied to public school
music, and to show what progressive teachers are
doing that gives music the right to be included as
one of the Big Four in the educational scheme
to which we subject our children.
Here is a room full of tomorrow's citizens,
gathered from all kinds of homes. It is the first
day of the new school year. They are youngsters
ready to start in *^ first year" or even at the kin-
dergarten stage. Here are musical children and
^^ unmusical" ones. Those who can carry almost
any clearly defined tune. Those who can't carry
any at all.
What shall we do with them? Is it wise to fol-
low the accepted notion that those who do not
carry a tune are incapable of it? Shall these be
gathered under the heading of ^* monotones" and
not be permitted to join in the class singing?
This is a question answered variously; but the
most progressive teachers of the caliber of Agnes
C. Heath, at the head of the school supervisors in
the public schools of Chicago, and the willing
workers under her, take the stand that the child
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 87
actually incapable of following scale or interval
progressions is almost an unheard of phenomenon.
Pupils are placed under three groups. Those
who can follow a tune, those who waver and are
equally likely to go right or wrong, and those
whose rhythmic and oral sense still need awaken-
ing. By urging the lagging ones to join in, even
if they don't get it right, by encouragement of
their efforts and by relieving them of self con-
sciousness, the fight is in itself almost always won
right there. This spirit of getting together, en-
tirely aside from the effect it has on the child's
vocal development, brings us at once face to face
with one of the wider aspects of music education.
The resultant training brings poise, self expres-
sion and a desire to be one of many. Its socializ-
ing influence is invaluable.
Verily in class singing the child becomes the
song. It is a personal act he is performing. He
is now a creator, and as such, takes pride in what
he is doing and experiences the joy of accomplish-
ment. Is it any wonder that, under such training,
the music hour passes all too swiftly!
Music study makes for alertness. Let us take
up this point. By way of illustration we may
consider a typical kinderband. Here is a room
full of mere babies with wide open, eager eyes
watching *^ teacher." They have been in the pub-
lic school kindergarten only two weeks. They are
standing in a circle, four with ^'nightingale"
88 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
whistles, six with tambourines, several with tri-
angles, one with a bell, four others with a sort of
beating rattle, one young gentleman proudly
manipulating a drum, and another fairly bursting
with importance as he stands alert for the signal
to clash his cymbals.
Alertness is certainly the key-niite. Every
little body is fairly tense with the earnestness with
which they follow their task. There they stand
in a circle, with teacher in the center beating time,
while the accompanist plays a few measures of
introduction. Every eye is glued on the waving
hand, watching for the signal to begin, and — there
they go ! Eight on the dot ! They know that they
must play on the accented beats and away they
go, without a hitch, every small person there a
bunch of concentrated energy. A slight gesture,
and the tambourines suspend activities, and the
bird whistles likewise, the rattles too, and only
the triangles and cymbals, the drum and bell, keep
on. Then these also, all except the bell, get the
desist signal, and the young lady of the bell plays
a solo. Proud? Dear me, do you really expect me
to put it into words!
Presently they lay down their instruments,
group themselves near the piano, and from this
rhythmic instrumental training change over into
suitable little songs. Is it not natural that the
practice in keeping time should percolate into
their singing too? They sing softly, musically.
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 89
No loud, shrill voices are heard here, or permitted.
But they sing with a smile on their faces and they
tell of birds and flowers or the wind or Jack Frost.
And liking the songs, and knowing and loving the
things they sing about, they naturally learn to use
a diction that many an older vocalist should envy.
Because it means so much to them they put their
little hearts into the music and it **goes over*' in
a manner that many a trained singer is too self
conscious to accomplish.
The mental discipline gained from music study
is not confined to alertness and concentration.
There is perception, too, somewhat relatedlo both,
and which is sharpened by the several faculties
here brought into play. It has been proved again
and again that the best music students stand
highest in their other studies. An interesting
case in point is the evidence of Dr. J. Varley
Kobberts, of Oxford University, England.
Dr. Robberts, like many other educators, found
great difficulty in having music entered as a regu-
lar study in the university. But once accom-
plished, he records from his observations extend-
ing over thirty years, that while only ten per cent
of the student body had been exposing themselves
to music tuition at the university, seventy-five per
cent of the scholarship honors of the entire univer-
sity have been won by this ten per cent group.
We are going back to our more primitive fore-
fathers for many ideas, and one of them is a mod-
90 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
ern application of the action song. Folk songs
were long ago always done with action, and now
this intuitive form of musical expression is being
introduced into our school-rooms, stimulating at
once both interest and imagination. For instance,
you should hear several hundred youngsters sing
with a vim a song like *^IVe Come to See Miss
Jennia Jones,'' after which general introduction
the various accomplishments of Miss Jones, such
as washing, baking, sewing, knitting, are enthusi-
astically set forth by words and tune and rhythmic
movements. This makes for grace of body and
for self control.
In addition to formally prescribed material,
progressive and well-equipped teachers are using
much material of their own by means of which
their work becomes individualized. In the early
grades they are making up jingles, set to succes-
sive tones of the scale, so that scale-singing be-
comes an easy and always pleasurable task, and
incidentally — quite incidentally — the scales are
learned almost without trying. And it's not even
a sugar-coated pill. It simply is no pill at all !
And so the fundamental material that goes into
the making of music is learned right along with
an appreciation of its beauty, and through it all
the greatest care is taken of the voice. The tones
are pleasant and well placed. Different syllabic
sounds bring control of production and it is all
done sensibly. By the time the third grade is
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 91
reached the eight and nine-year-olds can write
any rhythm on the board with chalk strokes as the
teacher sings the song, and their action-songs as
well as just their singing-songs have taken on a
great variety. Later they are able to write
original melodies, to read in several parts readily,
and always to sing with dynamic shadings that
sincerely express their reactions to the music.
The children are urged to put expression into
their faces, to sing with their eyes, as it were, and
although there are youngsters who occasionally
overdo the facial singing, with the majority it
becomes just another natural way to express the
meaning of music. And it is to be hoped that this
training carried over into the adult choruses of
the next generation will make them less stolid
looking than the repressed groups of present day
humans who can sing anything from a humorous
ditty to ^^ Glory Hallelujah!'' without change of
countenance. This attitude that modern train-
ing requires from its devotees is a means towards
self-expression without which no art interpreta-
tion can be effective. And it is an attitude in
which we, as a people, stand in great need. Our
tendency to repression of emotional feeling is bad
for art. Our progress is measured by the extent
to which we are breaking away from it.
The fundamental taste of children is good, and
this should by all means be catered to. The foolish
notion that meaningless jingles and jingly music
92 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
is all right for children, is absolutely wrong.
Nothing but the best is good enough for them.
But, of course, the music must be selected to suit
their age as well as their good taste. Music with
good, strong rhythms is what children like, and
sound harmonies and sounder tunes. And for the
younger ones it must be correspondingly simple.
Singing is a valuable physical exercise, too.
The children sit up straight when they sing, they
learn to breathe deeply, thus strengthening their
breathing apparatus, it quickens the circulation,
and altogether acts like a real tonic. The good
effect on health is also one of the beneficial results
of the rhythmic work as carried into action-songs.
Here there is bodily exercise of a health-giving
kind which can be carried over into folk dances and
interpretative dancing. This phase of the music
work has been one of the most valuable assets of
the training given in at least one school for defec-
tive children, and in some cases resulted in prac-
tical cures, or at least in a surprising measure
corrected their infirmities.
For the aid of the ** appreciation" work nothing
better could be found than the phonograph. For
the development of the sense of tone-color and
knowledge of orchestral instruments, records can
be used by way of illustration. When a song is
learned like the ^^ Anvil Chorus" from **I1 Trova-
tore" the teacher will find time to tell a little story
about Verdi, the composer, and during one of the
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 93
music periods will play some records of other
parts of the opera. The hitching-up method is
invaluable for driving home information in such
a way that it will stick. The practical use of the
phonograph for purposes of music education is
of far-reaching possibilities, and up to the present
the scope of its function has only been scratched
on the surface. Not only every school but every
school-room in the United States should have a
phonograph as well as a piano. The phonograph
recommends itself both by reason of its compara-
tive cheapness and the small space it occupies.
Its proper use can be a real inspiration.
The bands in our public schools for the little
ones and the older boys and girls bring with them
all the factors so valuable in rhythmic and vocal
drills. There is pictured here one of the kinder-
garten bands with a dignified youth wielding the
baton. Note the attention. All kinds of instru-
ments suitable for little people are in use, repre-
senting various tone-colors, as well as a variety of
musical effects. The late war having emphasized
the importance of music in our national life,
orchestras and bands are becoming a still bigger
factor in our schools. In many cities the board of
education appropriates at least some funds toward
proper instruction in such instruments and pro-
vides some of the material needed. As a rule this
is supplemented by the efforts of each school to
raise additional funds. To facilitate class instruc-
94 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
tion, music publishers are trying to meet the need
by publishing suitable instruction books.
In many families where there are several chil-
dren, and particularly some boys, the study of
something besides the piano or violin is urged.
The clarinet, the flute, etc., offer facility for much
enjoyment, and excellent opportunity for playing
with others, and it is that, as much as anything,
that helps to make music a live factor in school and
home life.
As a further proof that music study is a social-
izing influence, there is now being inaugurated
over a wide territory an experiment of tremendous
importance that promises correspondingly large
returns. It is the introduction in our public
schools of music memory contests for pupils of
the sixth, seventh and eighth grades for the pur-
pose of familiarizing them with good music, its
standards and its composers. A list of perhaps
sixty compositions is selected by the music super-
visor and the committee, and these compositions
are explained, played and sung in the school-room
during a certain number of weeks of preparation,
until the pupils are thoroughly familiar with them.
After a certain time a contest is held and the
winners receive prizes. Parents of the competing
children naturally desire to supplement the train-
ing for the contest received at school by further
drilling at home. To this end player-piano rolls
and phonograph records of the music on the list
IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS 95
can be played, or other and original forms of the
music may be performed. You can readily see
how this stimulates interest, rivalry, and a con-
tagious enthusiasm, with the result that at the
close of the contest the children have learned to
know, and what is more, to like a considerable
library of ^^good" music, and from that on it is
easy to continue the work of appreciation. These
contests are a direct link with the private music
lessons taken at home, and are aiding in crystal-
lizing the fluid question of outside credits in
music, a plan already placed on a working basis
in several cities.*
The fundamental principle of all music study
in the school-room, in the home, and in the indi-
vidual music lesson, should be to make the study
vital. It is not a question of teaching notes, or
songs, or ^^ pieces, ^^ but of bringing into the lives
of children the refining influence of an awakened
sense of beauty. The old notion is dying out that
education has for its purpose solely the discipline
of the mind. Instead of giving information edu-
cation is assuming the infinitely greater function
of developing in the individual the right kind of
social behavior, of making him a better citizen.
In our public schools we are making the Ameri-
can of tomorrow, and no stronger Americanizing
*Details of how to conduct such contests may be obtained
from C. M. Tremaine, National Bureau for the Advancement
of Music, 105 West 40th Street, New York, or from the west-
ern representative, Anne F. Oberndorfer, 520 Fine Arts Bldg.,
Chicago.
96 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
influence is to be found in the curriculum than the
study of music. It makes for patriotism, love of
country, brings the spirit of cooperation to the
foreground, stirs the emotions, and makes the
individual a well balanced man or woman.
■
''I^B''^^^^^ ^S^m
H
*■ Bk^^^K '''^- ^?''*'*^^l
^^H
* ■^t«d*^f^i-/4i ■'■ ■
H
'*' I^BHr^^ii J
H
* "^ i^Hi ^^ ^^'^^S^ ^sii-.?^B
■
2
^Hfl^K -"^f^^^^^^jjB*
^^H
o
"'^ fi^^^^^R dr ' ttj^^^^NN^lB
' ~'^
>
V ■^^^H^HBPr"'^ ^w^ ^^ i^^vw
-x|
5
' "^ /HHb ^^'^^^^^^m
'■'■l
S
* mU^a^ ^ JII^I^^^^Ib
c
JMEMMBw^^iS»^..Jf ..^^HHf^M^V^^HI
B
^ lH^^HP''^^^^lMff"^y^^ f^H
P3
^SM^^^Sm ~ w^fe - ^<^ »«««. j^|i^^B|
W
^ ^JH^H^ ^A ^^9B
>
felJ^HJHHBf ^SHr %. 'iBBlMI
iz;
^fl^^^^^^HI ^^^^^tff wSSm^
0
^^m^tt^^^^^^m..jSHtf^^m "^NHl^^B
M
P^^|^^^^^BHhH|^^^^^^K-~v n .yflH
z
I^^^^H^HH^^^^HQHHk^ ~ ' iilHHI'
M^^^^^^^^if^Kr^ pvp
H
^*fl^^^^^^^"''^ -^^^
h3
^^'^'^^^^^BI^^^'^K- jMm£^^^^tf
..■^i^
r
o
1 .jyipH^ -^^^ W|j|^M
^^K^Kr^ "^^^^^ 4!iTr^ w^BI
■
^'' i^hB ' ^^P^^^I^^hH
■
8
' * ^Hil^n .^^^•^^^"^'■""^ ^B^^^^l
r
/^H^Bifl^BlH ^^IH^P^^^''''''^««k^ .^^9>ti ^^^B^^^^^^^H
^^^^^H
w
CHAPTER IX
LINKING UP WITH THE SCHOOL
Hallo! — What? — where, what can it be
That strikes me so deliciously?
I never in my life — what, no!
That little tin-box playing so?
— Leigh Hunt.
Yes, it is just a ^' tin-box/^ or more accurately,
perhaps, an attractive mahogany phonograph-box
standing shyly in a corner that furnishes one of
the strongest links between home music and school
music. And this is said with no desire to dispar-
age that time honored family friend, the piano.
The latter is almost everywhere and continues to
radiate joy in millions of homes. And probably
the time is not far off when there will be a musical
instrument in every home.
But nevertheless the piano is a mute, inglorious
object in many domestic sanctums, simply because
there is no one to perform on it. Frequently
enough it is subjected to a sort of heartless bang-
ing, to be sure, but that kind of playing makes for
deaf ears rather than musical ones and the piano
so treated is apt to be neglected in other ways.
The tuner is far too seldom a visitor, and the
piano, growing restive under the strain, takes it
out on the family by responding in a querulous
voice that has lost both pitch and quality.
97
98 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Unmusical habits being as easy to acquire as
any other undesirable ones, the family gets ^^used
to'* the untuned piano while all the time their
selective sense of hearing is gradually deteriorat-
ing. When the piano is tuned at last it sounds
almost wrong. As a contrast an instrument that
can be played by everyone at the push of a but-
ton is a mighty convenient object, and the influ-
ence of the phonograph has been one of the
astounding musical changes of the last few years.
In the previous chapter its place as well as that
of the piano, was merely touched upon, but I be-
lieve it was agreed that a phonograph in every
school-room should be the rule. This might as
well be applied to the home.
There is nothing more desirable in the growth
of one's musical development than to do it one's
self. Making music, whether by singing or play-
ing, makes us for the time being creators, and
that, probably, is the reason why we are happy
when so occupied. And of all the phases of
musical activity that of singing brings with it the
greatest joy. Nowhere is this more noticeable
than when a number of children are singing
together, either in the class-room or in the larger
assembly room or auditorium where a thousand
or more often join in one chorus. Therefore let
it be emphasized that the creating of music by
doing it ourselves is of the greatest possible bene-
fit. But there are times, in the school, and cor-
LINKING UP WITH THE SCHOOL 99
respondingly, in the home, when letting someone
else or something else do it, is desirable. And
here is where the phonograph with its ready made
repertoire has its innings.
**How can we help if we have no technical
knowledge r' is one of the questions uppermost
in the minds of parents when approaching the
subject of how to link up with school music. Here
is music education of formidable proportions
being given our children by teachers especially
prepared for this work. How can we, who are not
musical at all, hope to compete with them? And
the answer must be that it is just as easy now as
it was in those years of earliest training when the
same doubts arose. The cooperation of the parents
is not only desirable but necessary if the music
training of the school is to be wholly effective.
Children are never happier than when they can
carry home their latest achievement to show the
fond parent what progress is being made. And
since the spirit of the newer teaching in public
school music is rooted in the socializing instinct,
there is a constant urge to the children on the part
of teachers to carry their music home. Not with
the showing-off spirit rampant but with the ambi-
tion to bring joy to others. One of the questions
frequently asked in the music hour at school is
**How many of you children sing at home for
your mothers r' Or possibly the question is
varied to ^ ^father" or ^^the baby^' or even to ^^big
100 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
brother. ' * In any case the large majority of hands
in the class-room fly into the air at such a ques-
tion, accompanied by a glance of eager pride. ^
The mechanical music devices having equipped
father and mother with a ready repertoire that can
be extended to suit the taste and the need of eve'ry-
one, parents are prepared to plunge fearlessly
into the business of linking up with the school
when it comes to music. The subject by being
made a study of vital interest, fills young minds
with eager questions that are not always satisfac-
torily answered in the classroom, or for which pos-
sibly there is no time. These questions may be in
relation to the songs the children sing, or some of
the music they hear played during an apprecia-
tion class. The teacher gives as much information
as time permits, but there are many things crowd-
ing every passing moment.
So Johnny or Mary comes home full of enthusi-
asm about *^The Soldiers' Chorus '^ and it is
asked for again on the phonograph. Of course it
would be even nicer if mother or big sister could
thunder it out on the piano, but the family with a
repertoire at its finger tips is only a rare happen-
ing. But everyone can have a record of it, so
there it goes again and its enlivening rhythm tunes
up the entire household. But Johnny wants to
know something more about the piece. Has it a
story! So the forehanded parent will bring out
the book on opera with which every family should
LINKING UP WITH THE SCHOOL 101
be equipped, and will read or tell the story of
*' Faust/' the opera in which **The Soldiers'
Chonis ' ' occurs. Then it will be easy to find some
other records, too, that illustrate other parts of
the story, and so the music comes to have an added
meaning.
There are other ways to associate music with
the general scheme of the child's development.
Here is a familiar Italian tune, for instance. The
children love to sing it without knowing perhaps
that it is Italian. But mother might tell them a
bit about the sunny land of orange blossoms and
how the swarthy complexioned people of that fair
country love music. That, too, will put a new zest
into the singing of it.
Father is very apt to be confronted by music
questions that pertain to physics. Your boy is a
member of the school orchestra. He is learning
to play on a horn and he wants to know the prin-
ciple of it — ^why it makes that kind of a sound. So
out comes father's long forgotten physics, and a
lesson in acoustics is the order of the evening.
The piano becomes the center for a million ques-
tions, while sound vibrations, the idiosyncrasies
of wire strings, and the mysteries of the sounding
board are gone into and explained. Who can deny
that father gets about as much out of this as the
boy? And after all it is quite the same as giving
a needed lift' over a hard problem in algebra or
geometry.
102 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
The ramifications of music study are so wide-
spread that they touch other interests at many
points, and progressive teaching methods are
widening this scope immensely. Aside from
answering questions and trying to help along the
appreciation of music by supplying outside infor-
mation correlated to it, it is the duty of parents to
acquaint themselves with what is going on in the
schools. And this the Parent-Teachers Associa-
tions are doing, but there are many parents who
as yet do not take any active part in such organiza-
tions.
Parents should visit classes and acquaint them-
selves with the way the study is being conducted.
The parents' interest will bring improvement in
those communities where that is needed, and it
will either help the local board of education in
progressive undertakings, or will bring those
about where they are still absent. Poor public
school music is too costly. Even in these days of
the H. C. L. it should be done away with as being
beyond all the bounds of extravagance. Just see
the toll it takes (very similar to that of inadequate
private instruction) of time and energy and the
dulling of ambition. Poor music teaching in the
schools makes the subject itself abhorrent, and at
the same time deprives the school life of one of
its best influences.
There is no other element in the educational
scheme that more directly acts on the child 's char-
LINKING UP WITH THE SCHOOL 103
acter. The socializing influence of music is almost
beyond computing. And in school, as in the home,
it exerts (when rightly conducted) a unifying and
harmonizing spirit. Every important school
function, every holiday has its special music to
which the parents may come and listen. Not only
single classes but often all the classes in a city
school of 1,500 or more children gather together
for assembly singing. The school orchestra and
special choruses of boys and girls add variety to
the program of mass singing, and proud parents
can acquaint themselves right there with what is
being done or not done.
In one southern state a certain school chorus
was so well trained that it traveled over a great
part of the state one summer to sing at a series
of state functions, and it was voted a huge suc-
cess. This singing together in the school is the
true foundation of the community singing which
optimistic workers in this field hope may in time
deliver us from the seemingly inarticulate bond-
age that to this day envelopes us.
Children are learning so well in the schools how
to sing spontaneously and merely for the joy of
it, that this training will undoubtedly bring with
it a letting down of the barriers that unwittingly
place a damper on any such self-expression out-
side of the school-room, whether indulged singly
or in community. **Why,'' it is asked, *^ after
eight years of public school music and perhaps
104 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
some vocal lessons from a special teacher after-
wards— why after all this is there no spontaneous
singing about the house ?'^ Or at best, why is it
confined to the strenuous efforts of the kitchen
maid?
Daughters with the many years of training are
seemingly as helpless at musical self-expression
as though they had no music in their souls. They
can sing certain songs in an accomplished man-
ner, but seldom arrive at a degree of proficiency
that does away with self -consciousness, and as for
just singing about the house — that is something
quite unheard of. It is all very well for Swedish
Katie to sing in the kitchen, or for Sadie Af ricana
to give voice to her gospel hymns, but to be so
natural in the front of the house really does not
seem quite decorous.
Some such reasoning it must be that actuates
the artificial attitude whereby instinctive self-
expression is practically killed. And the older
methods of public school music were right in
league with this embalming process of the music
spirit. It is only our children of the present who
are being exposed to a more modem treatment.
Just because of this it is of the first importance
that we, on the outside of the school-room, keep
up with the procession.
Our youngsters today are learning that music is
a wonderful vital thing, a something that is open-
ing up to them a whole new world of beauty, and
LINKING UP WITH THE SCHOOL 105
best of all, that it is something with which to
bring joy into their own lives and the lives of
others. This is an awakening that is bound to
bring with it an urge for expression that will
result in singing, singing everywhere, for almost
any provocation or occasion.
^^ After learning to reason,'' says Euskin, **you
will learn to sing; for you will want to. There
is so much reason for singing in this sweet world
when one thinks rightly of it. . . . You will sing
all along the road then.''
Yes, ** singing along the road" is the very
spirit of spontaneity, of joy in the doing that is
the underlying motive power by which our chil-
dren like to burst into song. If we can learn to
be as wise, as natural, and as spontaneous as our
children, we shall sing *^all along the road^' too.
The teaching material in the schools is of the
best, and as children instinctively have good
taste in music, they will carry this atmosphere into
the home and then cultivate the parents too, and
increase their capacity for intelligent enjoyment
of music.
The memory contests, mentioned in the preced-
ing chapter, are putting father and mother on
their mettle as nothing else could. Each child, in
its study, either on player-piano, the phonograph,
or some instrument it plays itself, will be eager to
learn the list of compositions well enough to get
into the **team" of its class, and from there into
106 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the **team" of the school, and you may be sure
father and mother will be glad to help. Faith in
our own is always a wonderful incentive to effort.
Then when the time comes for the final public con-
test, all the parents will be as eager as the chil-
dren, and although they won't *^help guess, '^ when
the testing program is played, they will enjoy
knowing what is going on, and the chances are in
the months of preparation they have kept up with
their offpsring in the matter of the sixty com-
positions listed. So again there has been a gain,
both for parent and child, and a linking up with
the school.
The parent's responsibility is just as great when
it comes to cooperating with the music study in
the schools, as with the private lesson taken at
home from a special teacher. The most signifi-
cant aspects of music study are frequently the
corelated ideas that open the child mind to the
power and meaning of music, while at the same
time stimulating the imagination. And it is the
duty of the parent to be as nearly ready as possi-
ble for this work.
CHAPTER X
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY?
You are trying to make that boy into another
you. One's enough.
— Emerson.
Parents are just beginning to learn that music
study is not exclusively girls' business, in spite of
the fact that there have always been individual
boys who have been given lessons (especially
piano) generally much against their will. As a
rule the time and energy spent in this direction
have been practically wasted, the reason being the
psychological attitude of the youngster and his
parents.
The chances are that dad — harking back to his
own music] ess days — looks with indifference upon
Johnny's musical education, while fond mamma
thinks it a desirable pink tea accomplishment, and
so insists upon it for that rather frivolous rea-
son. The small boy himself is firmly convmced
that music is a matter for curls and petticoats,
and secretly rebels at this feminine business.
What wonder then that his music lesson is a bore
rather than a delight and he periodically demands
release from this feminine thralldom until finally
father steps in Avith his ^'I want my boy to be a
real man,'' and the music lessons stop.
107
108 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
That has been the generally conceived notion.
What more natural, then, that music should be
looked upon as girls' business exclusively, and
that only rarely, where the boy's urge for music
has been strong enough to overcome prejudice,
has it been looked upon with favor as a masculine
accomplishment. This is still almost uniformly
the attitude taken by parents, but the sane and
constructive work in the public schools and the
preaching of foremost educators and men of
science is slowly changing all this. The old time
prejudices are giving way before a new enlighten-
ment with music gradually coming into its own
as an integral part of the educational scheme.
When a man like Edison, a keen, calculating
scientist, says that ^Hhe time is coming when
music will play a more important part in the
affairs of the world than books'' it means some-
thing. Music is being taken out of its petticoat
environment, and is being asked to hold its head
up as one of the chief mind-trainers worthy of a
place side by side with reading, writing, arith-
metic and geography. More than that, it not only
supplies needful mental discipline, but affects the
character, makes for good citizenship, and is con-
sidered valuable for its socializing influence.
Several of these points will be discussed con-
siderably in detail in later chapters. For the time
being we are especially interested in our boy and
the definite problems of his music study.
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? 109
The public school music in its modem mani-
festations is beginning to reach out and get your
boy. Unconsciously he is looking to music not
merely as a relaxation, but as a worth-while study.
Less than ten (one might almost say five) years
ago, it was customary in the schools to begin to
excuse boys from the music classes with the third
and fourth grades, the number excused greatly in-
creasing with each year, until only a small per-
centage remained to add their changing quavers to
the music of the upper grades and the high
schools.
Why was this ? The fault lay with the methods
of teaching, with the frill idea predominating.
Slower to accept the laws of applied psychology
than the exponents of other studies, music teach-
ers suffered from their own antequated methods,
but they are now making up for lost time, and as
a consequence it is becoming a vital study. The
boys now like it as well as the girls. There is no
more of that shame-faced muddling along at some-
thing that they would rather not do. All you
need to do is to go into a seventh or eighth grade
class, or in high schools, and see the shining eager-
ness with which the boys — everyone of them — join
in the lusty strains of ^^The Home Eoad*^ and
other songs like that.
There is just as much competition among the
masculine contingent as among the pigtail divi-
sion, just as much joyous singing among the boys '
110 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
glee clubs as among the girls' choruses. The man
of tomorrow feels the inspiration and the swing
of rousing music, the rhythmic contagion of large
numbers doing a thing well together. There are
songs of patriotism, good rousing marching songs,
songs with a wholesome (not sanctimonious)
flavor. All these are good to feel and to know and
to do.
The reaction of little children towards music is
practically the same with boys and girls, up to the
tenth year. Then their manner of response begins
to diverge somewhat in the selection of instru-
ments each prefers to play, and the kind of music
that stimulates them the most. School bands and
orchestras are a splendid outlet for your boy's
growing sense of music, and it is incumbent upon
parents to recognize this fact. The '*do some-
thing'' spirit that makes your child a creator of
music rather than a passive listener, is a spirit
that should be encouraged in every possible way.
Your boy wants to play in the school orchestra.
Very well. Find out what instrument he would
like to play. Usually there is a preponderance of
violins. See the music director at the school.
Have a talk with him regarding your boy 's musical
bent. And then arrange, if you can, to have him
study, if he will, some other instrument, say the
clarinet or cornet, flute or even the oboe, if a
teacher of these instruments is available. In any
event encourage your boy in his music making.
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? Ill
If he selects the flute for his qnasi-artistic ven-
ture, get flute records for your phonograph at
home. Learn a little about it yourself. Show that
you like to hear your boy play. Probably mother
or sister will attempt piano accompaniments, and
there will be the fun of doing things together at
home. Then there will be the inspiration of play-
ing with others in the school, of having a place in
the big celebrations and special functions of the
year, perhaps proudly marching behind the flag
on some patriotic occasion. All this will make
your boy happier and freer in his school life. His
enthusiasm, the more fun he gets out of it, will
carry over into his music-making at home, and at
suitable times it will become to him one of his
dearest relaxations.
Wouldn ^t you rather have your boy playing his
flute or his fiddle at home than surreptitiously
shooting craps with a group of undesirable boys
in some out of the way corner of the neighbor-
hood f Now wouldn ^t you ?
And the chances are what your boy is doing his
chum is eager about too, and his chumps chum, or
otherwise your boy wouldn't have cared about the
music game in the first place. Now do you see
how it all works out ? And how, without anyone 's
preaching about it, music is being lifted out of
its apron-string niche and being classed as a
manly relaxation and accomplishment I
In the matter of selecting the instrument for
112 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
your boy's musical outlet, some care must be exer-
cised. It is advisable to avoid the larger brass
instruments, up to the age of sixteen, at least,
owing to the fact that too much energy may be
expended in the blowing. The *'blow hard*' ten-
dency can easily be overdone under the spur of
sharp excitement and serious physical mishaps
result. So at least this danger should be avoided
as there are enough instruments that can fill the
music need without any danger. The parent
should consult a musical expert regarding the
choice of instrument, always, however, conforming
as closely as possible to the boy's special taste or
talent.
There is no sense whatsoever in trying to **sex''
the arts. They are useful to men and women alike,
and belong equally to both. It used to be that
curious distinctions were made as to certain
instruments.
Queen Elizabeth and her ladies played upon the
virginal, an instrument in vogue in Shakespeare's
time, much like a tiny piano key-board resting on
a table. As this became a very popular accom-
plishment with the fair sex, the descendant, the
piano, came to be looked upon as belonging ex-
clusively to the feminine gender at least for the
purposes of public performance. At Oxford Uni-
versity in 1827 at a concert the first male pianist
who had ever appeared there was received with
hisses. You see the idea of a man playing the
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? 113
piano was not considered good form. Similarly
the violin, although a small and dainty instrument,
was not considered suitable for a woman and it
was not until the middle of the nineteeth century
that a woman violinist was even tolerated with
anything like good grace.
Although these customs seem laughable to us
now we might just as well try to get a bird's-eye
view of ourselves as we are today, just for the
purposes of comparison. It is barely possible that
we should find just as unreasonable states of mind
existing in the world about us today if we could
stand off and look at ourselves in a truly unbiased
fashion. In fact it is not only possible but very
likely.
Talk to ten men of your acquaintance the next
time you meet them. Ask them if they want their
boys to study music, and at least nine of them
will flash back with ^'I should say not! I don't
want my boy to be a mollycoddle." In fact the
percentage of possible affirmatives is probably too
large if we make it one out of ten. The chances
are that one out of a hundred would be nearer
right.
And the root of all this lies in the father's own
musicless education. He argues pretty much
along the lines of the man who has succeeded in
life without a college education. Therefore a col-
lege education is all nonsense. What was good
enough for him is good enough for the boy, etc.
114 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Having had no music in his educational scheme
also makes father look at the thing in the dubious
light of an accomplishment — a non-essential, and
without going into it at all, he thinks that a mean-
ingless ta-ta-ta has a softening influence on a
man. It has, but not in the sense in which he
thinks it has. So it is tabooed as a mollycoddle
business, and once more the beautiful art of music
faces a prejudice which it must and will over-
come.
And in the face of all this is the undeniable fact
that men are more musical than women. Where
jollity reigns, among men, they invariably burst
into song. It is not only true of exuberant college
boys who will sing their lungs hoarse, and wear
their fingers sore strumming the harmless man-
dolin or the innocent ukelele. It is just as true of
**us old fellows'^ if they get together where good-
fellowship reigns.
But can you imagine a group of young girls
spontaneously bursting into song about a piano,
and having the time of their lives doing it unless
there are some **unmusicaP' males present to urge
them on? And can you, by the widest stretch of
your mind 's eye, see a group of perfectly respect-
able fifty-year-old ladies drop their work at a
sewing circle, in order to sing! You cannot, and
if by any chance you did find them doing it, you
would think them crazy.
Now the trouble with father is that he has never
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? 115
grown up. He is still just a boy in his feelings
and the way he shows them, and any woman who
has ever loved a man knows this. So when he and
his friends, who are just grown up boys too, get
together, they act like boys if the meeting be one
of relaxation, and that is where music comes into
the program. Told that he is musical, dad will
scoff at the idea, but he may add that **he knows
what he likes. ^' Exactly.
And are you too one of that vast army of peo-
ple who say they are **not musical'* but who
* * know what they like ? ^ * Probably you are. And
have you ever stopped to think what you mean
when you say So-and-So is *^ musical' ' or **not
musical?'' Of course you haven't, but without
hesitation and with a complete avoidance of
analyzing the question, you will nevertheless
promptly reply: **Why a musical person is one
who knows about music" — which is no answer at
all.
Just as though studying music made one
musical I ' It makes for a technical appreciation,
to be sure, and it makes for a fuller understanding
of the inside workings of the art — of how a piece
is put together, or the particular style that this or
that composer has developed into a sort of per-
sonal label — all that the study of music brings
with it, but more real appreciation (by which we
actually mean enjoyment) — never!
Now of all the persons in the wide world who is
116 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
most sure of his supposedly unmusical ground,
friend father is the worst. He vociferously ex-
plains how he has no use for that classical stuff
that seems to have no tune in it, and how in his
few moments of relaxation he wants something
light and airy to rest his tired brain. And all told
he works hard, poor dear, to make out a good case
for himself, though rarely deceiving anyone but
himself while he^s doing it.
Does Dad know, and do you know what sort of
a person he and you would be if you both were
really unmusical? It would mean that as you
walked down the street and a band, perhaps of
boys in blue or khaki, came along, blaringly
sounding ^^The Stars and Stripes Forever'^ or
**Over There '^ your pulse would not leap to meet
the music, nor would you fall in line with the
swinging rhythm, or your heart beat a little faster.
Can you imagine that?
It would mean that if you heard a singer with
a John McCormack voice going through some
simple song like **I Hear You Calling Me,'' or
'^Dear Old Pal of Mine,*' that you would rather
talk straight through the song than listen to it.
It would mean that if you heard a party of boys
and girls out on a porch on a moonlight night
singing sentimental ditties, you would not be
reminded of the days when **It was from Aunt
Dinah's Quilting Party I Was Seeing Nellie
Home" was the invariable accompaniment to a
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? 117
haywagon ride, and you always introduced your
uncertain bass or tenor in order to be part of it.
In fact if you were truly ** unmusical" you would
be a heartless, hopeless excuse of a human, fit for
even worse things than the *Hreasons, strategems
and spoils" Shakespeare tells us about. And
surely you are not that.
Now the funny part of it is that Dad, in spite of
his protests, is very apt to be the most genuinely
musical member of the family. He it is who likes
soft, slow homey tunes, the old songs he has
always hummed, and when he thinks no one is
within ear-shot, lumbers through a well-loved
melody with the index finger picking it out note
for note on the piano.
You see the appeal of music is a direct onslaught
on the emotions. You don't have to KNOW about
a thing technically to FEEL it. It is right there
with its rhythm, its tune and its sentiment, and
you must be made of stone not to meet it with at
least some degree of response. You can't help
yourself, music is bound to get you, like the gob-
lins, ^4f you don't watch out," and once cap-
tured, you will be held fast.
Much of the so-called *^ classical stuff" seems
terribly highbrow simply because it is unfamiliar,
or else because Susan, since her return from
boarding school, has practiced it by the mile until
the life is fairly beaten out of it. Let it become
familiar and be presented as the composer in-
118 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
tended, and immediately ^^ unmusical" Dad will
find himself a music fan in spite of himself.
Familiarity with music is all that is needed.
The greatest boon to the spreading of a liking
for good music has been the canned article in its
several varieties, although these have not yet
reached the ^^57" stage. For instance, there are
ever so many people just like a friend of mine who
became the owner of a phonograph. He was abso-
lutely sure of his *^ unmusical" state, but never-
theless something made him expose himself to the
recording of good music by some of the world's
greatest artists. Pretty soon he had his favorites
among a few records, and one day in a book he
came across an anecdote about one of the pieces
he liked. His interest was stimulated, and so he
found out a bit about the composer. Found out
that he was a real human like himself, not at all
a queer freak of a highbrow, but a regular man
who had had his ups and downs in life like all
the rest of us.
At once that piece of music took an a new mean-
ing— it became an intimate thing that he could
know and enjoy thoroughly. And so his knowl-
edge extended from one piece to another, from
one artist to another; until finally when a singer
or a violinist whose records he knew came to town,
nothing on earth would have kept that man away
from the concert, although two or three years
before he would have declared himself bored to-
WHAT ABOUT YOUR BOY? 119
death even at the thought of going to such an
affair.
Dad is just as potentially musical as all of us^
and the chances are he will get his enjoyment of
music much more directly and simply than mother
and the girls who often let a little bit of technical
fuss clutter up their emotional reaction. Here is
where a little knowledge is not dangerous, but
simply an inconvenience, as it makes one lose the
reality in a maze of scarcely understood details.
This superior attitude also makes mother and the
girls sometimes laugh at father's choice of the
good old tunes because he persists in living up to
his declaration that *^he knows what he likes,''
and that is a pretty safe creed to follow.
And your big boy has this same heritage — the
love for music, only in his case he is being made
aware of it, and instead of being half ashamed of
liking music he welcomes it as one of his greatest
pleasures.
CHAPTER XI
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR
Our house that long in darkness dwelt,
And long in silence, day by day,
Before the mountain snows could melt,
While yet the world was black and gray.
Received an impulse from the play
Of sudden fingers on the strings,
That made the new-born meadows gay
With magic touch, as 'twere the Spring's.
— Thovms W. Parsons.
We are now coming to the point where it seems
natural to make music a family affair. After
having dragged father into the game as an active
agent it should be easy. Mother and the girls very
naturally fell into line long ago, but the male con-
tingent of the household had to be treated with
some circumspection. Even now in some quar-
ters music is still looked upon with suspicion. It
has such an insidious way of undermining its
worst enemies and bringing them over to join the
tuneful phalanx.
The magic of music is surely making itself felt
in the American household. ** House-music'' is
not nearly so exclusively a foreign term as it
once used to be. The home is becoming a verit-
able music center, and promises to be more and
more so in the future. There is nothing like it for
12Q
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 121
awakening the get-together spirit. It is a relax-
ation, it is engrossing, it is fun.
*^More good music in the home'' should be
everybody 's slogan. If you make it yours be sure
and set about it, via your piano, your singing, or
your phonograph, just for the purpose of having
a good time. Try out all sorts of things — jolly
music, music with melody, music to which you can
attach a story. Make it a game, an entertainment.
Forget to think of it merely as an object of educa-
tive uplift. It is useful on that score, but remem-
ber what Victor Hugo said : * * The beautiful is as
useful as the useful — perhaps more so.'' It is
right to think of music as uplifting, but when that
side of it is emphasized unduly — and that is the
crowning mistake of most professional musicians
— it takes the edge off enjoyment of it.
So let us rather resolve that music is placed
here for our pleasure. Let us look upon it as ideal
relaxation in the home, and if, as a by-product,
there is a residue of educative uplift, well and
good. But *^good" music is still so frequently
confounded with ** classical and unpopular" that
the over-anxiety to emphasize its highminded in-
fluence is the bugbear that keeps much ^*good"
music off the piano rack. The pity of it, too. Jazz
and ragtime are not the only effective blues
chasers.
So in your campaign of **more good music in
the home" go through your phonograph catalogs.
122 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
There are thousands of lovely things to choose
from that you have never thought about before.
The same is true of the player rolls, or get easy
selections from standard operas to play on your
piano. If mother and daughter both play, why
not send for some jolly duets? Perhaps brother
is outdistancing the eiforts of the neighborhood
canines in his efforts on the clarinet. Perhaps
you can help to hide some of his hopeful vagaries
of sound by getting him to join in the family con-
cert. And it will improve his playing too. Get
father to join in by whistling a tune. Let the
youngsters keep time and sing too, whether on or
off the key. Make music a family affair. Give
it a chance.
The home lure may be strengthened by music
in various ways. A music game can be made
out of a memory contest. Various pieces can be
played on the phonograph, for instance, and every-
one can try to guess what it is, by whom it is
composed whether it is a single piece or part of
an opera, the nationality of the composer, the
time when it was written, etc. It would be quite
simple for mother or some other interested mem-
ber of the family to get up such information about
the records the family owns, by referring to a
musical biographical dictionary and a book on
standard operas. It is surprising how it adds to
the charms of a piece of music to know some-
thing about it. In the case of phonograph records
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 123
or player rolls there is the added feature of the
personality of the famous artist whose interpreta-
tion has been reproduced.
Another plan that should appeal especially to
the grown-ups is the neighborhood opera club.
Had you ever thought of that? You can, have such
a club right in your own town or even just in your
own street — if you want to make it very exclusive.
A club whereby you may have regular good time
evenings with the most famous operas in the world
that will be almost as satisfying as the real thing.
It is very easy. You and a group of your friends
probably all have phonographs. Have some partic-
ular opera in mind, like ^ ^ Faust ^' or ** Carmen'^
or **H Trovatore^' or ^^Aida/' and see how many
different records of it are to be found in your
friends' collections. Get up a small fund for the
supplying of a few more, bring them all to one
house some evening, have someone read or tell
the story of the opera and as you come to a point
that has been recorded, set the machine going or
the piano player rolling, and hear the music just
where it fits into the story.
I know of one small town where this was tried
with such success that the active members of the
little club have in turn brought up enough records
of certain operas to get almost a complete set,
so that now they have quite a list from which to
€hoose an evening's entertainment. It is not neces-
sary to confine the interpretative medium to the
124 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
mechanical reproduction. It wouM be highly de-
sirable, by way of variety, to have someone play
the piano or violin or combination instrmnental
selections, and to have someone sing one or two
famous solos. All this would add considerably
to the evening's enjoyment.
The point of this suggestion is the value that
attaches to the idea of music telling a story. None
of us are ever too old to like a story, and the
association of any music with a story, or cor-
related facts, makes it of that much more interest.
Any single composition may bring in its train an
association of ideas that are of striking appropri-
ateness. For instance, the music of Italy, particu-
larly some of the folk songs, may be linked up
into the geography lesson. It may lead to a
description of the people, their customs, their
traditions.
The ** Tarantella, '' made familiar by numerous
musical settings, will be listened to with renewed
appreciation if the superstition of the peasants as
to the whirling dance freeing them from the ill
effects of the bite of a poisonous spider, is made
clear. Then the whirling excitement of the **Tar-
entella'' (Italian form of tarantula) as expressed
by music will make the meaning clear, or if it is
not an instrumental **Tarentella'' you are listen-
ing to, then perhaps it is a famous vocal interpre-
tation of it sung by one of the greatest tenors in
the world, Enrico Caruso, and you feel impelled to
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 125
know something more about him too, after you
have heard him sing.
Or here is a piece called ''The Swan*' played
by a famous cellist. It is a beautiful melody with
smoothly flowing accompaniment of rippling
chords. In your mind's eye you can see a stately
garden. There are long green vistas between the
straight avenues of trees — enticing white walks
leading to charming nooks — gay flower beds dot-
ting the green here and there — and over yonder,
beyond the trees, you catch a glimpse of silvery
fountains splashing into a mirror-like pool where
majestic white swans are leisurely swimming. All
this the music tells you in this lovely piece written
by Saint-Saens, one of the foremost of French
composers. You will like it so much that you will
want to know more about him, too, and of other
music he has composed and you will probably
omit no opportunity to follow out this new in-
terest. Then too, there is the artist who inter-
preted it so beautifully. Perhaps it was Pablo
Casals, 'Vthe great little man" of the cello who,
scarcely taller than his huge instrument, wrings
from it a tone that goes straight to your heart.
Examples like these might be multiplied a thou-
sand-fold. The point is that by linking up music
with its correlated ideas, you get much more from
it than in any other way. It commences to take
on an aspect of being something quite different
from just ''a well-disposed group of notes'' and
126 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
becomes something human, something tangible,
something nice and neighborly and close to us. It
destroys that ridiculous notion that the art is a
thing to hold aloof, to consider only from a dis-
tance and that it defies any intimate relationship.
This attaching a story is just a further applica-
tion of the suggestions indicated for the kinder-
garten years by means of which the meaning of
music may be brought home to the child. It is
imperative, however, that there be reason and
logical association as a basis for your story. By
^^ attaching a story'' it should be kept clearly in
mind that the phrase is used somewhat in a meta-
phorical sense. It should be used for one of two
purposes : either by way of emphasizing musical
speech — as in the case of representative music in
which dancing snow-flakes, rain-drops, bubbling
springs, bird-songs, or any other sounds in nature
are the direct inspiration; or, it should be used,
as indicated above, for the correlation of ideas,
such as nationality, customs, traditions, composer,
artist.
There is a very fallacious idea rampant, hov/-
ever, concerning story-telling possibilities of
music, and that is the absurd notion of making any
composition of general character tell a concrete
set of facts.
By this means the beautiful nocturnes of
Chopin, for instance, are frequently used as a
basis for all sorts of wierd tales. Teachers who
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 127
find this method an easy way out, and mothers
and club women who grasp at this lazy straw
without realizing the harm it does, fall for this
sort of suggestion readily.
I remember being the guest of a small music
club where this sort of thing was indulged in
much to the supposed edification of the members.
The president was about to play one of the
smaller of the Chopin nocturnes, the one in Gr
minor, but before ^^ rendering '^ it she proposed to
make her performance more interesting by tell-
ing the story supposed to be attached to it.
Whether the tale thereupon unfolded was one
which she actually thought authentic, or whether
she made it up out of whole cloth I do not know.
But I do know that this perfectly harmless and
lovely nocturne — the musical interpretation of a
mood — was made to represent the following scene
and story.
Chopin, the composer, was lying on his death
bed. It was a bright and warm day, and the gentle
breeze blowing in through the open window
brought with it the sound of fluttering leaves and
the song of birds twittering in the branches of
the nearby trees. All was calm and serene, evi-
dently, in the poetic soul of the composer, but
he was slightly sad too, so the lovely melody
outline of the first part of the nocturne found
itself onto the sheet of music paper that
constantly lay by his side waiting for just such
128 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
sudden inspirations. There, if you please, you
could hear the twittering of the birds and all the
pleasant sounds that were wafted through the
open window. But presently an organ pealed
forth its weighty message from a neighboring
church. Straightway this went down on paper
too, and the result was the middle part of the
nocturne that sounds like a solemn chorale. After
this was finished the first theme returned, only to
die away at the last with a great man's dying
breath.
Now all this sounded very affecting, so that
when the piece was finally actually played the
dear women heard all the things that had been
suggested to them, and enjoyed themselves ac-
cordingly. This would all have been very well
if, in the first place, the piece in question had
been intended to be representative (program-
matic) music, and if, in the second place, the
story had been true. But the actual facts of the
case were that this is simply one of the poetici
mood pieces that Chopin gathered into his famous
collection of ^^ nocturnes,'' and the particular one
in question was written while he was living down
on the Island of Majorca, off the coast of Italy,
it being the happiest period of his life. So much
for the death-bed story.
Now it may be claimed that it should not be
wrong to attach a definite story, even where none
was intended, simply because by this method the
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 120
imagination would be appealed to. But the fact
remains that this kind of wrong interpretation is
actually a distortion of the imagination rather
than the right kind of stimulus. In fact, when
you come right down to it, it is not even a stimulus,
but rather a lazy substitute.
The beauty of music is that it leaves the imagi-
nation free to roam with the music only for a
guide. The same piece may mean one thing to you
and another to me, and in any case it simply
establishes a mood to which you and I respond.
Here, for example, is a lovely quiet twilight piece.
Its mood is that of the close of day. It bespeaks
a lingering sunset, a serenity of spirit, a time for
retrospection. We hear it, you and I, and quietly
we sit and drink it in. It inspires in both of us
the same quietude of mood, but this mood brings
to each a different line of thought and association.
To you perhaps it brings up a picture of pleasant,
walks along garden paths with some well loved
friend — perhaps something lovely that has gone
out of your life and left just a quiet sadness be-
hind. To me it may bring dreams or half de-
fined hopes of pleasant twilight hours to come.
In either case we hear the music, and we love it
for the message it brings. And our dreams or
reminiscences would be rudely jarred by the in-
troduction of a definite story to which we should
have to glue our impressions. In other words it
is the magic of music again manifesting its mys-
130 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
terious power by which it reaches out and makes
friends of each of us and brings to each of us
just what we need the most. This is too beautiful
a thing to lose by pasting our own artificial mis-
interpretation all over it. It is better to let its
hidden meaning remain hidden. By that means
its emotional quality will find its true response.
Another very necessary matter to be taken into
account in the ^' music in the home'* campaign is
the question of good manners. The art of listen-
ing to music should be cultivated as assidiously
from the earliest years as the art of politeness
in conversation. You do not, if you are a cour-
teous person, interrupt someone who is talking, or
fail to heed what is being said, openly paying no
attention. And it is just as important to culti-
vate the same degree of courtesy in the matter of
listening to music.
There is much unthinking rudeness going on all
around us when music is performed. In a sma:ll
company someone is asked to play the piano.
Scarcely are the first notes struck when a low
buzz of conversation starts up in different parts
of the room. The speakers seem to think the
music will cover up their whisperings, and in any
event they give only a poor semblance of listening
although it is possible that the most glib conversa-
tionalists will be the ones who will the most glibly
tell the pianist ^^That was perfectly lovely** when
it is all over.
MAKE MUSIC A FAMILY AFFAIR 131
When mother plays for the children they should
be taught to listen whether they seem interested
or not. At least they should learn to be quiet dur-
ing the music. It is just as important to enforce
this rule later on when someone is performing
presumably for their enjoyment, and this listening
attitude should even be carried to the time when
phonograph records or player rolls, other than
dance music, are played. The mere fact that the
helpless machine cannot talk back does not make
it the less an obligation to listen, for if you do
not listen what is the use of having it going!
By not paying attention when a machine is
making music, as is frequently the case, the habit
of not listening is unconsciously carried over to
those times when a human being is making the
music, and at least it becomes just that much
harder to concentrate on what is being performed.
But the harm lies not only in politeness. It is a
dulling of the emotional effect. If you habitually
hear music and pay no attention to it your music
sense will soon become so dulled that you will be
conscious of it hardly at all. It becomes a mean-
ingless drumming to you, mentally affecting you
only as so much noise. The result to your music
sense will be quite like that of the alarm clock
that you set for a certain hour each morning. At
first it will wake you up, and if you obey its warn-
ing you will get up. But if you lazily turn over
and go to sleep again, after a few trials, the voice
132 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
of the alarm clock will sing into deaf ears, and
you will not hear it at all.
In many families — one might almost say in
most families — where there is a phonograph, this
habit of setting the machine going and then pay-
ing absolutely no attention to it excepting to take
off one record and put on another, is the rule
rather than the exception. And these same per-
sons, when they go to a concert are very likely
to belong to that vexing coterie who think music
is to be treated as an accompaniment to conversa-
tion. Without consideration for others, and with-
out consideration for themselves, they busy them-
selves in various annoying ways while the music
is going on, apparently quite impervious to its
message.
Learning to be a listener has its twofold reward.
It makes for a development of the music sense,
and it makes for a respectful attitude toward the
art and its votaries.
CHAPTER Xn
MORAL INFLUENCE
To neglect the daily growth in one's capacity
for the beautiful is absolutely harmful to the indi-
vidual especially in the matter of his moral and
spiritual nature.
— Darwin.
To determine the moral influence of music its
status as a psychological factor in education must
be fully understood. It is so usual to consider
only the esthetic and cultural effects of art edu-
cation that the wider aspects in which it acquires
the power of psychological force are entirely lost
sight of or overlooked. And yet there is abundant
proof that music instruction, rightly conducted,
does influence the child as well as the mature man
or woman in unexpected ways.
With the first class singing in the school-room
the backward child gains poise and assurance,
and breaks away from the burden of a too great
self -consciousness. Whether he can sing or not,
he is urged to take part, to get into the game.
He becomes one with his fellow-playmates, he
gains confidence in himself, and he is a creator!
He is doing the music. He becomes the song. He
finds it inspiring. He is carried outside of him-
self. He is a part of it all.
133
134 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
This makes him a better student in other classes,
more alert, more interested. The school is a nice
place. Something to be proud of. Teacher is
wonderful. And so by such easy, tuneful means
the very foundations of a happy school life are
based on the first song. With such an incentive
it is easy to feel a loyalty toward the school. By
such means new friends are won, the surroundings
take on an added attractiveness, and the young
child — later the growing boy or girl — learns to
wield a certain influence over both friends and
strangers as the pleasant self-assertiveness we
recognize as poise makes itself felt. And poise
is power. Music establishes itself at once then as
one of the chief character building influences of
the school curriculum.
This is in direct line with the newer theory of
education that it is not so much a matter of mental
discipline as of character discipline. It is now
considered not nearly so important what a man
knows as how he uses what he knows. The study
scheme is worked out to fit in with the idea that to
be of real value, or rather, of the best value, the
whole of man ^s nature must be taken into account
— the mental, moral, emotional and physical. And
there is no subject in the educational scheme that
as wholly and directly affects every one of these
elements in man's make-up.
It is conceded that music is one of the best mind-
trainers.
MORAL INFLUENCE 135
Its emotional appeal is obvious.
Its beneficial effect on the physical well-being
of the child has been indicated. Its broader ap-
plication as a means to health will be treated of
later.
The question before us now is of its moral in-
fluence— its value as a character builder, for we
always assume that character building means de-
velopment in the right direction.
Can music aid in making the child a better
citizen? Will it function as an asset in helping
him to cope with the social problems that life will
bring him! And the answer to these questions is
unequivocally, Yes !
If we accept as correct the theory that educa-
tion should be a rounding out of the whole of
man^s nature, then the purely intellectual educa-
tion that finds no room for the development of the
esthetic sense, makes no allowances for emotional
reactions and their effect on character, becomes a
one-sided proposition. Like all one-sided proposi-
tions it has its stultifying effect, and we see the
products of it on all sides. Such men scoff at all
that is beautiful as being something quite outside
the business of life — something that cannot touch
any man of affairs. It is all very well for women
and children and long-haired sexless beings to
dabble in if they like, but for men who are doing
the world ^s work — never!
Themostocles, a great statesmen and soldier of
136 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
ancient Greece, when asked at a feast to play the
lute, said with disdain *Hhat he could not play
music and yet he could make a small town a great
city ! ' ' And we can hear hearty applause arising
from our fellow- workers who take the same stand.
But they and the mighty Themostocles make the
same mistake — that of looking upon the perform-
ance of music as an accomplishment. The ^^ doing''
is of quite negligible importance. In fact, in
most instances, it is highly desirable that you do
not do if you have any consideration for your
friends. The value lies not in the doing but in the
liking of music. *^I should rather have my boy
like it than do if one wise mother said who was
conducting her boy's musical education along the
lines that would later in life bring him the greatest
profit. Call it appreciation, or what you will, by
incorporating the study of music in the educative
scheme it awakens a sense of a whole new world
to which the man's interest without this prodding
remains forever deaf and blind. Again it must
be urged that its value in giving him a new slant
on life lies altogether in the liking of it. And
that liking can only be established through
familiarity.
The properly balanced education of the future
(and even of the present) will take into account
the effect of the properly aroused esthetic sense.
This brings in its train broader sympathies, a
truer brotherliness, a more wholesome citizenship.
MORAL INFLUENCE 137
By this means emotions are refined without being
softened (your unesthetic scoffer to the contrary).
It makes for a saner and more progressive out-
look. Mental and moral influences will then more
easily work hand in hand to the very distinct
betterment of the human race.
Typical products of the purely intellectual edu-
cation that believes its value lies in the quantity of
knowledge pumped into the human cranium, and
that bothering with the esthetic or the cultural is
a waste of time, are to be seen all about us — in
our colleges, in the office, even in the professions.
A case in point is an occurrence at one of our
large universities. A fine orchestra was giving a
program of musical masterpieces. These college
boys, trained to scoff at anything ^^ highbrow'* in
the arts, although they were bright and alert stu-
dents along other lines, did not know how to listen
to music and worse yet, thought they didn't want
to. Someone shouted a demand for ragtime. The
clamor grew, until the demand became so insistent
that the concert came to an abrupt end. Here was
a fine lot of young college boys, discourteous in
the extreme, who showed not only a total lack of
consideration for others, but eloquently proved the
void in their own educative preparation.
These men will go out into the world and many
of them will gain a very respectable material suc-
cess, but they will not be the men whose names
will be linked with the greatest Institutions, the
138 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
most progressive movements and the finest
achievements.
Shakespeare knew what he was talking about
when he said so many years ago ^'The man who
hath no music in his breast is fit for treasons,
strategems and spoils." The man today who has
shut himself off from all the refining influences of
music and the other arts, may be a brainy alert
man, and a certain degree of material success may
be his. But he is a man of action only, measuring
every move by a yard-stick with a view to what he
will get out of it. He can see only as far as his
immediate needs and interests carry him. His is
a shortsighted vision. He is no builder of dreams.
Unlike him is the man who can see through the
wall of the next minute, who has vision, sympathy
and insight, whose dreams come true, and it is
on these dreams that the progress of the world
is builded.
We all know what an important part music
played in the late war. If it was used success-
fully by the enemy for the putting across of a
wrong ethics, that was because its value as a psy-
chological force had been tried and tested. It
was used as a weapon just as surely as gas and
gun-powder.
With us its psychological force was still un-
recognized, and it was not until the war was half
over that music began to be used on a large scale
**to help organize victory." From then on it was
MORAL INFLUENCE 139
used in every conceivable form as a comfort, as
a relaxation from the horrors of war, and as a
stimulus to the morale of our men. During that
time the Congress made a half-hearted attempt to
place music in the class of luxuries which would
have sadly interfered with its prolific dissemina-
tion. But happily the movement was side-tracked,
and sweet harmony played its great part in the
war. Jazz on the battle-line and other vigorous,
martial music, with singing a lusty part of it all,
helped mightily when marching to an unknown
fate, and it brought the equally great benefit of
its solace to those behind the lines.
How the men craved music is proved by the
care and invention that went into the making of it.
A victrola was carried lovingly almost into the
firing line; it dispensed its sometimes doubtful
harmonies (fancy keeping a victrola or any other
music machine in apple-pie order at the front),
first to one group and then to another, and then
it was trundled back to a nearby hospital where
it acquired all the sacredness of a ministering
angel.
Imagine if you will, the surprise and even con-
sternation of a perfectly innocent tin cracker box
lying quiescent with the comfortable knowledge
of duty well performed, finding itself suddenly
manipulated by eager hands into a twangy-pangy
guitar. Its metamorphosis completed, it hence-
forth allowed itself to be tweaked and plucked
140 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
and strummed and *^ vibrated'^ to the limit of its
own and its proud creator's endurance.
Similarly bewildered was the wholly innocuous
(when empty) cigar box that suddenly found itself
transformed into a fancy mandolin, minus the
conventional number of strings. Its solitary trip
of suspension (made of heaven knows what) did
noble duty by way of camouflaging the single-
track pang-pang box into a veritable Pandora
treasure chest of soothing rhythms. In the hos-
pitals the patients fell to making comb music, if
there was nothing else to be had. So it would
seem after all that our boys wanted and needed
and ** appreciated '* music.
The threatened classification of music as a non-
essential, finally happily side-tracked, at least had
the salutary effect of bringing the music industry
interests together in the fight. And it was un-
doubtedly due to the well organized plan of op-
position to the measure, led by George W. Pound,
general manager of the Music Industries Chamber
•of Commerce, that the government discontinued
the non-essential attitude. Not only was music
mobilized as an auxiliary to the war, but more
and more we found that it was needed at home,
too. That, however, was quite another side of
the picture.
In the meanwhile music as a cure for physical
ills reached the dignity of a clearly defined func-
tion during the war, and its most ardent devotees
MORAL INFLUENCE 141
now hold that it may soon solve your domestic
problems likewise. As a universal panacea, its
power would seem, therefore, to be unrivaled.
Music in hospitals performed (and is perform-
ing) many modern miracles. As a therapeutic
agency it is functioning wonderfully well. And
while the direct applications of its effects is still
a matter of study, enough has already been estab-
lished to make it of real help in the beneficial
treatment or cure of certain mental and physical
conditions.
Hospital music for purposes other than that of
entertainment is neither as senseless nor as new
a proceeding as is commonly supposed. It has
been tried spasmodically in many places over a
period of many years. In fact the ^* corridor sing-
ing" today in St. Thomas's Hospital, in London,
is a custom that had its inception from Florence
Nightingale's request for ward music in hospitals
during the now almost forgotten Crimean War.
But it is this last war that brought its greatest
opportunity.
We know that Dad's son is as responsive to
music as his father, and he admits it after he
gets over the age when he thinks it unmanly to
acknowledge an interest in something that is *^ just
for girls." During the war our sons certainly
demonstrated that music meant much more to
them than anyone had ever supposed.
We know so much of what was done with it in
142 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
sending onr boys over the top, and we heard so
much of it passing our very door, that that phase
of music's share in organizing for victory is a
familiar story. Less spectacular, perhaps, but of
the greatest possible importance was the part
music played behind the scenes in the hospitals,
both by way of entertainment and as a genuine
therapeutic agency. It supplied to many a
wounded hero the incentive to go ^^over the top'*
back into good health, or at least back into the
best possible place life held out to those who were
severely handicapped.
Especially trained experts were appointed by
the government to direct the use of music in hos-
pitals, to apply this wonderful remedy where and
how it would do the most good, and with the full
approval of the medical profession. Music was
organized not only for recreational purposes, but
for purposes of health and so well were these
logically conceived ideas carried out that many a
wounded boy, or shell shock victim, now owes his
return to reason and to health through this bene-
ficent influence.
The music-cure was no hit or miss project, but
a carefully worked out plan whereby certain kinds
of music and certain tone qualities were used as
definitely as drugs to bring about a mental or
physical rehabilitation. Those who have been
most actively engaged in making music in hos-
pitals count for something divide it into three
MORAL INFLUENCE 143
classes — entertainment, occupational, reconstruct-
ive. The first characterization is obvious in that
it merely represents wholesome diversion with the
mind of the patient remaining entirely passive.
The second means the playing on musical instru-
ments by the patients themselves, their minds
and their energies occupied and stimulated. The
third, of the greatest importance, is the use of
certain music and certain instruments as an aid
to recovery. The music doses were. as carefully
prepared as any other kind of medicine.
As far as the proper use of mechanical devices
is concerned, the kind of movement and effort
needed to create a musical tone must be carefully
studied. In the war hospitals many a useless
hand became normal again through the plucking
of a mandolin, or flexibility came to aimless fingers
through strumming on a guitar. Both are in-
struments easy to learn. The helpless trembling
of the lip that interfered with the speech of shell
shock patients, rendering them self-conscious and
recovery slow, was controlled and frequently
cured quickly by properly guided playing on a
small wind instrument like the flute or oboe, or
even a jewsharp.
The point of greatest value in this work seems
to be that music under proper guidance became a
valuable occupation whereby interest that had
seemed dead was aroused in other things in gen-
eral, and a mind blurred by contact with un-
144 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
speakable horrors was quieted and made normal
again.
Music was found to be helpful in many a diffi-
cult diagnosis. It was used to accompany anes-
thesia. And it was found that not only different
compositions or styles of music, but different tone
qualities and rhythms established their own reac-
tions. **What is one man's fish is another man's
poison" is evidently as true when using musical
sounds for therapeutic purposes as when using
any other kind of medical treatment.
It was found that the harp was the most sooth-
ing of all instruments, and music without words
was more quieting and helpful than when accom-
panied by words when the effort to follow their
meaning would have seemed to the patient a
mountainous task. Music in the hospitals during
the war, and even now, has brought cheer to
many a dear homesick lad, has brought hope to
a suffering one where black despair had descended
like a nightmare, and has brought courage to face
life under new and hard conditions.
But it is not only in general hospitals that music
is of value when used with a knowledge of its
psychological and physical effects. **The punish-
ment fits the crime" quite as well in asylums for
the insane, the deaf and dumb, the blind, in the
care of defective children, and even in correcting
the criminal tendencies of inmates of peniten-
tiaries. In the problems of this clattering, every-
MORAL INFLUENCE 145
day life of ours music helps too. And while music
may be used as a curative factor with criminals
it should be of interest to note that only one half
of one per cent of the inmates of our jails are
drawn from the ranks of artists. They may be
weak, many of them, or queer or eccentric, but
they are seldom vicious members of society.
In her capacity as chief restorer of the mental
and physical equilibrium of the so-called human
race, the ** Heavenly Maid" is outdistancing all
her rivals as the benefactor of mankind. If Johnny
refuses to run on an errand for mother, play a
Sousa march or something else zippy for him on
the piano or phonograph. At once it will ** ener-
gize" him and send him flying along the street
with impetuous eagerness to be of service. If
Jane of the kitchen lolls over her work, pack the
lullabies and soothing syrup serenades carefully
on the top shelf, and jazz her up (oh yes, that
is perfectly proper), with the lastest syncopated
creations.
Letting your domestic pot boil to an Irish jig
may sound more tuneful than sensible, but the
energizing or soothing power of music is a matter
worth taking seriously. It will solve many prob-
lems for you.
CHAPTER Xm
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE
Familiar music is liked.
— Theodore Thomas,
In any large first-class motion picture house
you get your most typical American audience. It
is democratic, it is there because it wants to be,
and it knows what it likes — and incidentally has
no fear of expressing itself. When, therefore, in
the interval between ** pictures'' the orchestra
breaks into the favorite popular song of the mo-
ment, or the latest jazz hit, it is met with a spon-
taneous and vigorous burst of applause. Wliy?
Because the people know it and like it.
It is all very well for your *^real musician" to
sniif at this evidence of bad taste, and to raise a
supercilious brow at such ** ordinary stuff,'' but
the indisputable fact remains that the people like
it. And at home the same thing is going on, for
you find gathered around your piano a group of
high school boys and girls, lustily singing all the
songs of the day, and having an exceedingly good
time doing it too. If you disapprove, on the basis
of bad taste, what are you going to do about
it? What will you offer as a substitute? And
what do you think of when you say ** popular
music ? ' '
146
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 147
In the first place is popular music bad? If so,
how bad? Why, ragtime, of course! In condemn-
ing it are you quite sure you are not confusing the
music itself with the surroundings in which it
flourishes best ? It must be remembered that music,
in itself, is neither moral nor unmoral ; it is only
by association that it becomes so. And very fre-
quently the worst company your ragtime song
keeps is the words.
When songs are trashy it is the words that make
them so, and in this regard parents are surpris-
ingly thoughtless. It would not occur to you, for
instance, to permit a salacious story to find its
way into your house, or if it did, you would soon
get rid of it. And to place obscene or suggestive
pictures on the walls of your home would be ab-
solutely unthinkable. But it doesn^t occur to you
to watch the piano rack, although on it repose
often enough songs that you should be ashamed
to have in the house and that your youngsters and
their young friends would be ashamed to sing if
they gave the matter real thought. The saving
grace of the popular song singing lies in the fact
that it is done thoughtlessly for the most part, or
else pure-minded young girls could not bring
themselves to shout sentiments at the piano that
in conversation they would not dream of express-
ing. It is undoubtely true that much of this kind
of singing is done without a full realization of
any feature of it excepting the contagious pulse
148 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
of its rhythm. Therefore it is the music, and
nothing else, that is the attraction.
Nevertheless the truly trashy song, even if
done with a thoughtless swing, is harmful, and
your. collection of popular music should at once
be subjected to careful inspection. Strangely
enough, just after we entered the war there was
a new crop of popular songs of a particularly
nasty character. The words were so suggestive
that even the managers of first-class vaudeville
houses banded together and forbad the rendition
of them. And yet those same songs in several
cases were sold by the million and carried their
polluted sentiments into as many homes.
But such songs as those, represent only one
phase — and happily quite a small one — of popular
music, and it is utterly absurd to class all popular
music as trashy or even undesirable, for that is by
no means true. Wholesale condemnation will not
right matters.
An amusing instance of an esthetic censor run-
ning amuck occurred in a western city recently
when a sanctimonious civic censorship league had
the billboards decorated with huge posters bear-
ing the legend ^^Hold your nose!^' It was an
anti-jazz campaign. To the curious one who ap-
proached to read the finer print it was discover-
able that all good citizens were urged to show
their disgust at this ** degrading, nauseating, de-
moralizing^^ variant of the rag by shutting their
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 149
olfactory nerve center with a gesture that bespoke
utter contempt.
Color music had been with us for some time,
and now it seemed that the latest was to be (to
put it delicately), perfume music. Innumerable
theories have been put forward as to the manner
in which music reacts on the other senses. Color
music is an old story which has been esthetically
described and scientifically proved. So the quite
up-to-date person, with the properly controlled
esthetic sense, will see green when he hears Bach,
and mauve when he listens to Debussy, and heaven
knows what when he hears Wagner — probably red
until his war sentiments are all calmed down.
According to certain theorists the visual idea
is to be carried still further so that definite ob-
jects are said to be brought to mind through the
medium of sets of vibrations. In other words, fol-
lowing this theory, you are to see things, not only
colors, when you hear music. Which is a reminder
of the lady in ^^ Howard ^s End,'' who could think
of nothing but pink elephants when she heard
Beethoven's fifth symphony ! And the young man
for whom Elgar's Caractacus meant bananas!
The mistake these earnest workers for the pub-
lic welfare were making in their anti-jazz cam-
paign was to confound the music with its environ-
ment. That the conditions in which the jazz band
has found itself the most at home are in need of
reform, there can be no gainsaying. But to put
150 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
all the blame on this syncopation raised to the
n^th power is too much.
If persisting means anything, if universality is
a true indicator, then ragtime, including jazz, is
the one enduring type of music indigenous to
American soil. Although ragtime has not yet re-
ceived * * the clammy hand of fellowship from com-
posers and critics'^ that would appear to be no
cause for dismay. Independent of highbrow
opinion, indifferent to all the wrangling of which
it is the innocent instigator, this persuasive, in-
sinuating arrangement of syncopated rhythm has
spread its restless self from Podunk to Petrograd
— and been hailed with equal delight in both
places. Let us consider ragtime and all its
relatives seriously for a moment.
An illuminating theory put forward by Ivan
Narodny is to the effect that ragtime is entirely
a city product, and for that reason differs so
radically from the simple folk song. Mr. Narodny
says: *^ Ragtime is the very opposite of a folk
melody. - What the one denies, that the other uses
as its very foundation. Folksong is the product
of the village and the country; ragtime's birth-
place is the city. The one is of rural, the other
of urban nature. A folksong mirrors the joys
and sorrows, hopes and passions of the country
people. It has been moulded under the blue sky
in sunshine and storm. The songs of birds and the
voices of nature form its phonetic background. ' '
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 151
*^The place of the birth and growth of ragtime
song is in the city exclusively. It exalts the noise,
dust, rush and vulgarity of the street. Its rhythm
suggests the odor of the saloons, the smell of the
backyards and subways. Its style is decadent,
and its melody is the voice of a nervous society
figure.''
So that is it. Eagtime is born of the city. And
the city being the same the world over, reacts
enthusiastically to this phonetic expression of cul-
ture that so marvelously expresses the restless,
harried complexities of urban existence.
It has been noted with wonder by the neutral
observer and with derisive dismay by the arti-
ficially cultured musician (but all musicians are
not like that) that ragtime has a universal appeal.
This purely American product has found its ad-
herents in all the great cities of the world. You
are just as likely to eat your soup to the tune of
*' Everybody's Doing It" in Paris or Moskow or
Tokio as in New York. It seems to be the one
element that unites mankind, and is therefore a
musical phenomenon that is to be reckoned with.
Jazz was right on the battle line during the war,
too, and in spite of being *^ degrading music"
made a noble record. The first American negro
soldiers to get into active fighting formed a band
that became famous, and the way they put jazz
right up in front in the fighting, and pep into
their fellow fighters, and set France by the ears
152 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
afterward, is one of the most startling stories of
the war. A fighting band that could buoyantly
fling its tunes right into the face of an enemy
machine gun that was lustily exercising its lungs,
and could successfully compete with the tf-us-uf-ff
music of 12-inch shells hurtling through the air,
was certainly doing its duty.
The exciting influence of ragtime and jazz on a
throng of people who by force of circumstances
have to sit still and listen, is so nearly suffocat-
ingly cumulative that it hits you between the eyes
when you come into the midst of it. And yet there
are those who confound jazz with its, at times,
unsavory surroundings, and call it degrading, for-
getting quite that the wierd elemental wildness of
its insouciante rhythms is a racial expression that
holds everyone in thrall. Rhythomaniacs the
negroes have been called. Certainly they have an
uncanny ability to place the accent where, by all the
laws of white man's music, it should not be placed,
but that, if you please, is jazz. There is nothing
more contagious than this peculiarly American
music our dark brothers have given us, and which
so eloquently expresses our national motto, **Step
lively, please, '^ by which in these so-called peace-
ful United States we live and move and have our
being.
The true significance of ragtime is yet to be
definitely established. But it is so original and
so vigorous that it prevails with a persistence
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 153
that no amount or degree of evolution can render
nugatory. Like it or not, ragtime has come to
stay as a rightful heritage of certain phases of
the American spirit. It may be noisy, violent,
vulgar, but it also is natural and vigorous and
shockingly strong. It may be ** earth ^s saddest
music'' to the one who sees in it only the reflec-
tion of the city's ugliness. But it is the basis for
a newer musical art to him who sees in it a reflec-
tion of the condensed citified form of human
achievement.
So much in defense of ragtime. There will be
those who will feel it should not be defended at
all but that is because they lose sight of its basic
musical significance — one might say, its psycho-
logical significance.
Just what does and does not constitute popular
music is a broad question with many ramifications.
It will sufiice for the purposes of this discussion
to point out that ** popular '^ music need no more
be confined to jazz and its variants than that
*^ classical" need be marked as synonymous with
highbrow and dry. ^* Classical" and ** popular'*
are more often than not interchangeable terms,
and as the love of music grows some rather ridi-
culous barriers that have been set up by purists
are being carefully kicked into the limbo of false
standards.
Wrong notions about good and bad music, the
real and the pseudo, are being systematically com-
154 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
bated with the most astounding results. When-
ever good music is brought before the people not
as a sugar-coated high-brow dose of something
** elevating/ ' but simply as entertainment, they
respond eagerly, gladly, and cry for more. And
straightway it begins to be popular. So after all
what is, and what is not popular is a matter of
taste.
** Familiar music is liked.'' That is, as soon as
we know music well we begin to like it. The point
now is how to turn our children's taste in the
right direction. And is not the answer perfectly
obvious! Let the best become popular through
the process of familiarity. And that can be ac-
complished the most easily in the home. It is in
the home that good or bad taste is formed, and
taste is largely a matter of environment. Wise
parents want to have their children surrounded by
the best in art and books. Then why not with
the best in music too? And yet there are many
homes still without music, or with only the trashy
kind represented. In such surroundings the music
sense in the child is apt to starve to death, or
at least be sadly perverted. The lack of good
music does not seem to be realized, though it is
quite the same as starving a child's color sense
by surrounding him with blank, white walls and
ugly furnishings.
There is no excuse nowadays for the musicless
home, for the mechanical instruments will make
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 155
a world renowned virtuoso of every member of
every family who avails himself of the privilege.
The entire world of music and the most famous
interpreters are at your beck and call by the mere
push of a button. Equally so there is no excuse
for the preponderance of trashy music — trashy
at least as to sentiment. Too much ragtime play-
ing is all wrong because it is a one-sided activity
that perverts the taste and interferes with the
full development of the music sense by which all
music worthy of the name can be appreciated.
If there was a defence of ragtime it was on
behalf of its individual characteristics. It is in
a class by itself. But playing it is a contagious
disease that must be combated by other music,
and commonsense, or else it will become the domi-
nating musical influence in the home. It is not
wrong for your youngsters to like ragtime or any
^* popular'^ music, but it must be kept in its place.
It is not wrong for your child to like candy, but
to give him candy all the time is not good for him.
So it is with popular music. Wise parents will
permit it on the piano, that it may be played in
addition to music tasks determined by the music
teacher. But popular music will not be permitted
to usurp the situation in the well-regulated musi-
cal household, nor to drive other music out. The
music diet is an easy one to control if parents
will give it the requisite attention.
Children's fundamental taste in music beinsr
156 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
good, as has already been pointed out, it is the
easiest thing in the world to win their true ap-
preciation for what is most worth while. They,
even more than grown-ups, love the familiar which
might just as well be the best as anything else.
In the matter of selecting the music they are to
hear their age must be taken into account. By
boring them with music they are not ready to
enjoy the plan defeats its own purpose. Let them
hear simple, direct melodies from the music of
the greatest composers — the old classic masters.
As the years progress give them other music
of a more complex nature and make it possible
for them (when you can do so) to hear great
artists, an orchestra, etc. Whether at a concert
or at home set the example of listening when music
is performed. Good manners, like good taste,
might just as well become a habit.
Carry out the suggestions made in earlier chap-
ters of adding to the interest of the music heard
by using associated material — something of the
story, the composer, and, in the case of mechanical
reproductions, the artist whose interpretation has
just delighted you. Make the music interest an
active factor in the home life, not just a passive
affair. Let the child, as soon as possible, become
an active agent in helping to establish the musical
atmosphere. Get his cooperation and you will be
sure of his interest.
The man with *'no ear for music'' is made, not
CULTIVATING GOOD TASTE 157
born. He grows that way when he spends his
childhood in a home where music either does not
exist, or is an entirely negligible quantity. If
you want your child to grow into a music lover
you must give his natural born music sense some-
thing to feed upon. Make that something as at-
tractive and as worth while as possible, always
bearing in mind that lack of technical knowledge
need offer no handicap in this fine work. Every-
thing you need by way of creating a musical at-
mosphere in the home is yours just for the asking.
It is the greatest bargain being offered anywhere.
CHAPTER XIV
WHAT EVERY HOME SHOULD HAVE
Music is the C Major of this life.
— Robert Browning.
What every home should have is somewhat of
a direct continuance of the points brought up in
the preceding chapter, and yet there is a certain
angle that needs a more detailed explanation.
And that is our attitude toward music appre-
ciation.
Parents seemed filled with the idea that hav-
ing no technical knowledge ties their hands abso-
lutely in the attempt to help their children to an
appreciation of music. But it cannot be empha-
sized too strongly that this is a mistaken idea,
and not true at all. It is an opinion right in line
with the other one so often heard: **I can't ap-
preciate good music, I suppose it's because I don't
understand it." Let us puncture ** appreciate "
and '^ understand" as they are used here.
In the first place, in the phrase, **I can't appre-
ciate," the word is actually used as being dis-
tinctly and exclusively synonymous with '^like."
'*I can't appreciate" really means to the person
saying it, ''I don't like." Now what was in truth
the case is that the man or woman glibly announc-
158
WHAT EVERY HOME SHOULD HAVE 159
ing this familiar verdict was bored and uninter-
ested. The music seemed unattractive and mean-
ingless, all of which led to a sigh of relief when it
was over with. Why? Because there had been no
development of taste for music. And yet there
might have been appreciation without liking. The
two need not mean the same thing. A realization
that a painting or musical composition is a great
art work may still bring with it no enjoyment.
You can appreciate a thing and yet not like it.
The additional statement, ^^I don't understand
if is in reality a statement of the unexpressed
feeling that, somehow, music must be hard to
understand and that you, a musical layman, could
scarcely be expected to understand something of
which you have no technical knowledge. Here
you are all wrong.
The fact of the matter is there is nothing ex-
clusive about music or any of the arts. It is the
most thoroughly democratic expression of human
emotion you can imagine. It belongs equally to
you and to me, to the veriest layman and to the
musician who has made music the study of a life-
time. A little child may appreciate it to the same
extent as the greatest virtuoso. The appreciation
varies only in kind, not in degree. The child
responds because the music makes him happy, or
a bit sad, he knows not why. It has a strange
power. Whatever it is, it makes the child feel
something. And the musical layman, quite like
160 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the child, may if he will, get the message of music
in the same direct fashion, only that is more diffi-
cult for the grown-up to do unless he has trained
himself in such appreciation.
The great virtuoso, someone who makes music
himself either as a creative or an interpretative
artist, takes a far more complicated state of mind
to the hearing of music. He brings with him a
trained ear, a highly specialized music sense, a
critical attitude that discovers and weighs both
the best and the worst points, and an intelligent
understanding of the intention of the composer,
the technical details involved, and the command
of resourceful invention. In a sense he, of course,
gets more out of the performance than the musi-
cal layman but his reaction is correspondingly
complex, and from the standpoint of pure enjoy-
ment it is a grave question if he gets as much as
his untrained neighbor.
The chief aim of an art is to dispense beauty,
and therefore happiness. While training in the
art is desirable for many reasons, it is absolutely
true that the untrained listener, if he has been
taught to like music, will get equally as much out
of it and possibly more. Of course the develop-
ment of the music sense through association with
music, through hearing a great deal of it, is in
itself an education. It is one which in time devel-
ops a sense of relative values that in many cases
registers surprisingly accurate estimates. Best
WHAT EVERY HOME SHOULD HAVE 161
of all it is an education within the reach of all
of us.
Therefore you are to bring to your contempla-
tion of the tuneful art a mind open to impressions.
Clear the road of the conviction that it is hard to
understand, and that your ignorance of musical
tweedle-dees renders you incapable of liking it.
Listen to the kind of music you think you will
like, follow the most familiar path, and the way
will open up before you without any conscious
effort on your part to force it.
This mistaken notion that we should know all
about music before trying to like it is as wrong
as it would be to apply that to painting, but there,
too, it is imperative that we follow familiar paths.
Pick out pleasant landscapes, homey interiors,
subjects that appeal to you in themselves. Paint-
ings like that you are bound to enjoy, and it would
probably not occur to you to say, after looking at
one you had enjoyed, *'I don^t understand it,'*
simply because you have no technical knowledge
of the art. You would be quite satisfied with the
pleasure it gave you. And in that sense the paint-
ing would have fulfilled its esthetic mission.
Of course practice in seeing pictures, just like
hearing much good music, will make you more
hypercritical. You will gradually ^^ appreciate''
or learn to like certain modes of expression on
canvas that at first you couldn't abide, and your
growing familiarity will enable you to discover
162 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
faults where before you had seen perfection. In
any case no one can take away from you the en-
joyment painting or any other art may bring you.
That enjoyment is absolutely your property, and
while increased knowledge may give you a differ-
ent outlook, your emotional reaction after all is
said and done is its own reward.
So forget to think that you cannot ^* appreciate''
music without *^ understanding '^ it. Submit to
its wiles, let yourself hear it whenever and wher-
ever you can, and understanding and appreciation
of it will follow as naturally as the moon does the
sun.
Familiarity with music does not breed contempt,
the most convincing proof of this being the pres-
ent day concert audiences. These are getting
larger and more enthusiastic in city and small
town and the two reasons for it are the phono-
graph and the player-piano. The mechanical
reproduction of music has made good music
familiar to thousands of people where there was
but one music lover before, and no other argument
but this one is needed to show that all music re-
quires to become popular is to make it known.
Let us trace the history of a musicless household
into one that becomes a perfect music center, and
all through the lure of the phonograph.
This family never used to have a sound of music
in the home. Then someone decides to buy a
phonograph. At first it is looked upon as a new
WHAT EVERY HOME SHOULD HAVE 163
plaything, a rather lively piece of furniture, and
that is all. Probably a dozen or so of records
were given by the dealer to make his sale more
attractive. The family plays these over and over,
paying little heed but simply using the phono-
graph as a comfortable background for conversa-
tion. No one thinks of really listening, and natur-
ally the music makes no impression.
But some member of the household, getting
tired of the worn out tumty-tum, sets out to buy
one or two new records. Perhaps the dealer oifers
some good advice this time, perhaps the compre-
hensive record catalogue has been dipped into.
Anyway one or two records by some well known
artist, we will say a violinist like Mischa Elman,
creep into the home repertoire. These records are
liked. Somebody suggests getting another Elman
record. ^^The tone is so sweef This is done.
Who is Elman anyway? They become interested.
Presently Mischa of the gifted fiddle bow is an-
nounced to give a concert in that town. The whole
family wants to go, and does. The program is
eagerly scanned. Will he play one of their pieces!
Yes, there it is ! And in the course of the program
possibly one or two more of their favorites crop
up as encores. How they do enjoy them. They
are old familiar friends and the enthusiasm of
hearing these pieces carries over into everything
else the artist plays. It is wonderful. The family
has a magnificent time. And yet the chances are
164 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
that before owning the phonograph only one mem-
ber of that family, and very likely none, would
have even thought of going to a concert.
They go home elated. Some other records must
be bought. They get something by another violin-
ist to see if he can possibly compare with their
Mischa. Oh yes, the Russian violinist is actually
one of their friends by this time, and so the story
goes. It *s easy, this music appreciation. It comes
without any effort if you will just let it take its
natural course, instead of trying to produce it by
some hot-house process that has *'must'' and
^^upliff for its high signs.
That is the way to take music. As a joy and
recreation. Everyone must have some of both.
And the ideal recreation is the kind that takes the
mind off one 's work and produces a kind of pleas-
ure that leaves one mentally and physically buoy-
ant and refreshed. And all this music does.
Many of the most successful business men this
country has produced have not been afraid to come
out in print and to attest to this fact. ^And yet it
is surprising to some people that a hard-headed
business man would dare to express himself so
enthusiastically about an art. It sounds so dan-
gerously like a sentimental pose, they think. And
we should like to be thought anything but that.
It is this very attitude, however, that has made
us an inarticulate people afraid of our feelings,
and still more afraid to give them utterance. It
WHAT EVERY HOME SHOULD HAVE 165
isn't done just for fear of appearing sentimental.
We shrug our shoulders at honest emotion and
pretend that it is a thing quite foreign to our
makeup. We hide what we feel under an exterior
of calmness or indifference, and consider that we
have thereby accomplished one of the aims of
twentieth century civilization. We have.
To possess outward control of our emotions is
one way of making the wheels of life turn more
easily. But there is one danger — and that is that
constant denial of our feelings is apt to stultify
the emotional impulse in us, thereby rendering it
nugatory. The result is that we become inarticu-
late.
The war roused us as a nation and as individ-
uals. But nowhere did our slow awakening un-
dergo more of a transformation than as regards
our attitude toward the national anthem. We
blush to confess (or do we?) that we have had to
be told what to do and how. That we have waited
until a National Anthem Etiquette Book should
be placed in our hands with the principal rules
marked, is in itself a fact both ludicrous and
pathetic.
That we are running true to form now — that
is most of us — is due to the energetic efforts of
our National Etiquette Committee. It was self
appointed. That our education is not yet com-
plete is proved in any public gathering when
thoughtless persons still wander down the aisle of
166 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
an audience room to the strains of **0h, say can
you see/' and here and there careless ones chatter.
The end of the war had come before we had
learned consciously to recognize that the national
anthem is a sacred thing and that its lofty senti-
ments deserve our highest respect. We have
always known this. But it was just our happy-
go-lucky heedlessness that pushed our conscious-
ness of all this back into a nice little corner where
it lay undisturbed and unused. It was the clarion
call of war that brought it to light.
And it is the clarion call of the new era that is
making us proud of the arts, and proud to express
our appreciation. If music is not yet a familiar
guest it is at least a welcome stranger, improving
upon acquaintance. To be sure the average host
and hostess do not feel quite at home while enter-
taining this guest, and there is much that still
needs to be learned, but music as a general social
favorite is coming out a winner. What else can
you find that so readily may be all things to all
men? Music entertains, it is a recreation, it
brings comfort in time of sorrow, it cheers, it
solaces, it draws the family together in supplying
a common interest, it relaxes the tired brain, and
in fact, it will do exactly what you ask of it.
It is the one thing that every home should have.
CHAPTER XV
THE BUSINESS OF MUSIC
The time is coming when music will play a
more important part in the affairs of men than
books.
— Thomas Edison.
The father ^s objection to his son taking up
music as a profession is rooted in two lines of
experience. The one is the unspoken (or shall we
say outspoken) antagonism to the art arising from
the father ^s own musicless youth, which has
already been described from different angles in
earlier chapters. The other objection lies in the
irregular conditions surrounding music as a
business.
The long-haired apostles of harmony who affect
flowing ties and eccentric behaviour to hide their
vagaries and their weaknesses, not to mention,
often, their ignorance, have become so fixed in the
popular mind as being representative of the pro-
fessional musician, that the sane, short-haired and
clean-collared gentleman who actually does pre-
dominate in the music world today has not yet
succeeded in fixing his portrait in the public con-
sciousness. Perhaps he is not so picturesque as
the other. Perhaps he is too regular as a type to
be thoroughly exciting. Something bizarre is still
167
168 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
associated in the public mind with music-making
and there are still enough scattered charlatans
who help to keep this superstition going.
And then the women who predominate at many
music functions are still inclined, as a whole, to
take their ^^artisf a bit hysterically. Not that
they will admit it, but it is decidedly noticeable
at a fashionable morning musicale, for instance,
that the foreign looking gentleman who lets his
feverish temperament leap out at you inspires a
like feverish response to his performance, whereas
the perfectly tailored, straightforward, clean cut
American gets just a decorous response. We are
beginning to learn, however, that our own men
and women can compare with anyone in the world
and yet we still accept their success with a grati-
fication that has in it an element of surprise.
That is why father, quite naturally, also labors
under the delusion that being a musician is syn-
onomous with a bad shave and he wants none of it
for his boy. Aside from the fact that the pursuit
of music will have a feminizing influence (so he
believes) just see what it will make of his son!
No wonder father objects.
The music profession is undergoing about the
same transformation that the stage had to under-
go, and still is undergoing in the eyes of some
people. The antagonism to the actor was so deep
rooted that it has taken innumerable shining ex-
amples to prove it ill-founded. With music it is
THE BUSINESS OF MUSIC 169
the same. And the mistaken conception of the
present day man musician is most vociferously
expressed by the men who stay away from con-
certs and all other opportunities to hear music,
and consequently know not whereof they speak.
Much of the approbrium attaching to the pro-
fessional male musician these persons have
brought upon themselves in the past, not only by
eccentricities of manner and appearance, but in
being weak-kneed specialists instead of useful
and substantial citizens. Many a musician has
rather prided himself on not voting and in taking
no interest in civic matters or any public ques-
tions. He has been inclined to hold himself aloof,
and to leave the solving of practical problems
affecting the community to those men who were
by nature and business inclined to take an active
interest in practical affairs.
In like measure musicians have neglected to
understand and practice business principles. For
that reason many have failed to receive due mate-
rial reward. The unstable condition of the musical
market is another argument apparently in favor
of the father who wants his boy to go into a
*^reaP' business or profession.
While these lamentable conditions are still much
in evidence, a tremendous movement for better-
ment has been going forward in the last ten years,
and new standards have come in with a perfectly
clean collar and short hair. The big men of the
170 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
profession are proving that you can be a great
interpretative artist, or even a composer, and yet
be on speaking terms with a fashionable tailor.
And with a sane adjustment to a regular appear-
ance there has come about an equally sane and
business-like view of the profession by outsiders.
The men of our own country today who are digni-
fying the musical profession as teachers and
artists are of the finest type of American man-
hood. They are honorable, honest and substantial
citizens. They are financially successful, and they
are proving that music may be a business of which
anyone can be proud.
The modern musician is educated and cultured.
He can discuss the big questions of the day with
a politician far more glibly than could the latter
discuss the Beethoven symphonies. He visits art
exhibitions and reads the latest books. His eyes
are open to what is going on in the world about
him, and he uses what he can of human activities
as they touch him in order to make his own work
finer, broader, bigger. Of course there are many
small fish in the music pond who think that by
flirting their tails and making a loud noise they
can put over their pseudo-musicianship. And
there are still, and probably always will be, many
of those creatures commonly supposed to be born
every minute who will accept these pseudoists at
their own valuation. But so are there shyster
lawyers and charlatan doctors, and they and the
THE BUSINESS OP MUSIC 171
music fakirs will continue to live and thrive as
long' as there are gullible persons ready to feed
them.
Faking has had a freer reign in music than in
other professions because there is no law in the
land, up to the present time at least, that prevents
anyone who wishes to do so from hanging out his
shingle and calling himself a professor of music.
And gullibility, vanity, and false ambition strew
his path with roses.
But it should again be emphasized for the bene-
fit of Dad and his boy that all this is changing,
and changing rapidly. Music as a business is now
a going concern in which anyone can succeed who
brings to it enough natural talent and due prepara-
tion. You would not expect your boy to succeed
as a lawyer or a doctor without the right educa-
tion and the special aptitude and liking for his
chosen profession. The same is true of any other
line of work, including music.
The changing attitude toward music as a relaxa-
tion is another item worthy of thought. It is no
longer a feminine frivol, a high brow and rather
ladylike pastime. No indeed. Our American men
are just beginning to discover music for them-
selves. They are commencing to accept it as a
legitimate recreation quite on a par with cards or
pool. It is altogether the thing now for men to
go to concerts, and to go, moreover, because they
want to go, which is the only way they enjoy it.
172 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
It is a new recreation. Where no forcing process
is employed men easily learn to like music.
Where the Tired Business Man is dragged to a
symphony concert by friend wife because it will
uplift his soul, he naturally rebels. He wishes
people would leave his soul alone. He not only
does not listen to the music when he gets there, but
inwardly spends his time thinking how much more
comfortable he would be at his own fireside, with
his old slippers, the evening paper and his pipe.
Or he sees nothing in this *^ highbrow stuff ^' and
hnoivs the only thing he can enjoy is a ripping
musical comedy. In any event music in over-
symphonic doses does no good. But where men
are let alone to follow out their natural born in-
clinations, where the mechanical instruments and
the home musicians make him familiar with music,
where no uplift sign drives to antagonism, then
your Tired Business Man becomes a music fan in
spite of himself.
In every city where popular priced concerts
have been established these affairs have grown in
number and invariably boast a rapidly growing
patronage. And the percentage of men present is
constantly on the increase. In fact certain artists,
notably violinists, attract many more men than
women. This bears out the statement made in an
earlier chapter that men are more musical than
women. They know what they like and there is
no funny business about it. Man is a pretty direct
THE BUSINESS OF MUSIC 173
animal when it comes to pleasing himself. And he
reacts to melody as do the savage and the child.
He enjoys an emotional thrill and is not afraid of
indulging it.
Woman ^s attitude, for the most part, is more
complex. In the first place her ability for emo-
tional reaction has very mistakenly been carefully
educated out of her. She is not so honest as men
in her conviction of what she likes or doesn't like,
but watches, with wary eye, which way her neigh-
bor, the cat, will jump before she jumps herself.
She wants to be quite sure that this or that is the
thing to admire before she commits herself. There
is a lot of tom-foolery in her process of adjusting
her esthetic standards, and meanwhile much of
beauty is irreparably lost. While the man — well
you know what he thinks about esthetic standards.
He knows what he likes !
The father's second objection to music as a pro-
fession is rooted in his objection to the study of
music as a part of his son's education. His objec-
tion is obsolete in face of the revolution in music
study. It was maintained and proved in Chapter
X that music as now taught in our public schools
is one of the best mind-trainers and that it has
real value as a socializing influence. How often
we hear the remark: *^I should like to have my
boy learn to play so that when he goes away to
college it will help him to make friends." There
you have it in a nutshell. ^^It will help him to
174 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
make friends. ' ' It brings wider sympathies, helps
to make your boy's environment more pleasant
and to increase his influence.
It does not soften but makes him quicker to feel
for and with others, refines his nature, makes him
a human being and not a machine. Music study
makes him, in short, an all round man. He will
make the most of his opportunities, he will dream
dreams and carry them through, and will be un-
selfish rather than selfish. A certain youthful
buoyancy will be the key-note of his life. A hope-
ful optimism rather than a hopeless pessimism
will guide his steps. Through the study of music
as a profession or through the proper use of it as
a recreation, he will become a better citizen and a
finer, bigger man.
Must we not believe that the perception of the
beautiful — a gift we all possess — has been given
to us for some purpose? Is there any justification
for the prejudice that would pass it by as some-
thing utterly useless, something quite outside
practical life and no concern of the successful
man? We are finding out that the most successful
men are the ones who are leaning on music as a
live factor in their success. They are beginning
to give music its due.
All industrial plants and big business corpora-
tions are encouraging music organizations among
their employes. They find it the most stimulating
of recreations. They are, in many cases, usin^
THE BUSINESS OF MUSIC 175
music as an accompaniment to work. Why? It
makes for increased efficiency. The contagion of
rhythm is the pulse of life.
We dance to music, eat to music, sing to music ;
why not work to music?
Music is the dynamic force of successful indus-
try. If the strains issuing from a brass-throated
band of rooters can work a south-paw up to a
wild pitch of nervousness, what is to hinder real
music from arousing lethargic laborers to a high
pitch of enthusiasm! Work accompanied by
music is never hard. In war it was proved that
music made even murder easy. Generals screwed
up the courage of their men with music by the
regimental screw-driver known as the band. Ob-
viously, if music can take the sweat out of sweat-
shop the principle that harmony makes burdens
light and work easy is susceptible of wide appli-
cation.
So it would seem that the business of music is a
subject w^orth your attention. Your boy may take
it up as his particular business and provided he
brings to it a special talent and the proper equip-
ment he will earn through it the success that is
represented by eminence and dollars. Or he may
make it his business simply in the sense of its
being a by-product to his success in another line
of activity. As an avocation music will be an in-
valuable aid. It will help him in selling bonds or
setting a broken limb or trying a big case, for it
176 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
will make liim a broader individual, more keen in
his perceptions and more thoroughly alive. The
man whose emotional nature is atrophied is half
dead. The man who is not ashamed of having
^^feelings'^ is the man to bank on in any emer-
gency.
This idea of making music an integral part of
your preparation for coping with what the fates
may have in store for you is not new. Plato
preached it hundreds of years ago to the extent of
dividing a boy^s education up to sixteen years of
age as follows : The first ten years to be used
toward forming his disposition, then three years
of grammar with collateral sciences, and then
three years of music. In other words, just as
gymnastic exercise is necessary to keep the body
healthy, exercise in music is necessary to keep the
soul healthy. From this one would judge that the
proper development of the intellect and the proper
control and use of the emotions cannot be accom-
plished without the study of music.
And so, Mr. Business Man, in case you may look
upon Plato as an old fogy, let us repeat here the
dictum of our own Thomas Edison: *^The time
is coming when music will play a more important
part in the affairs of the world than books.''
Why then not use it for all it is worth in helping
your boy to real success in the game of life?
CHAPTER XVI
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE
Chant me the Poem that Comes from the Soul
of America.
— Walt Whitman,
Musicians have been for the most part a sorry
lot of hide-bound specialists, everlastingly occu-
pied in repressing the natural function of music,
thereby preventing it from asserting itself as an
important factor in social evolution. And yet is
there a single human activity on which music does
not touch? From the quiet of the nursery to the
clatter of the factory, from the gay boulevard
enlivened by the military band to the romantic
seclusion of a love song, from the brilliant lights
of the theater to the sombre shadows of the
church, everywhere music pursues us and modifies
the complexities of our modern existence. It
touches us at all times in all places.
Consider the cheapness of music, and its acces-
sibility. Great paintings require long purses and
wonderful galleries, and although these may be
thrown open to the public free of charge, some-
body pays for them. But a singing group of two
hundred factory workers can make the greatest
choruses ever written their own! You may have
right at your own hearthstone the most wonderful
177
178 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
music interpreted by the world's most famous
artists. And through the magic of reproduction
you may have all this for almost nothing. But the
most economical music on record is probably the
supposedly divine music heard by Confucius, the
Chinese philosopher who lived 3000 B. C. The
heavenly harmonies had such a wonderful effect
upon him that he partook of no food for three
months afterward.' If only a bit of this music
were available now-a-days, how it would reduce
the high cost of living!
The universality of music is proved by the fact
that the more people get of it the more they want.
But the supply seems equal to the demand. Every
social institution is answering the call.
There are our public libraries for instance. A
regular music department has been installed in the
larger city libraries, and in a measure the libraries
in smaller towns are following suit. The typical
music department of our city libraries is a verit-
able music world itself. Here are to be found the
complete scores of nearly all the standard operas
and oratorios and a large collection of music in
sheet form. The well-informed attendant can help
the club woman or the music student in the study
of almost any phase of music. There are musical
periodicals and books on music, as well, to refer
to.
For obvious reasons the music in sheet form
cannot be put into circulation so it is available for
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE 179
reference only at the librar}^ itself. But the bound
volumes may be taken home like any other books.
This sort of thing has become invaluable to teach-
ers, parents and students, and makes available to
them any amount of music it would not be feasible
for them to own themselves. The generous patron-
age bestowed upon these music departments wher-
ever they have been installed proves what a need
they are filling.
The growth of music *s power in the church
is another manifestation of the appreciation of
music. The time is not beyond the memory of
many of us when many a rural community was as
horrified by the innovation of installing an organ
in the church as though the devil himself lurked in
the pipes. The artificial expansion of their simple
gospel singing into something more complex and
artistic, although possibly not more impressive,
was an idea to which our grandfathers had to
learn to adapt themselves.
There are those who hold, and rightly, that this
elaboration of the musical part of the church
service has been the deplorable means of causing
it to lose its personal character. We have learned
to listen instead of taking as active a part in it
ourselves, and this tendency is very marked in the
slump suffered by congregational singing. We are
much inclined to let the highly paid choir praise
the Lord these days while we sit by in mute appro-
bation, rather helpless accessories to the act.
180 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
But something must be said for all this on the
other side. The highly trained choir, the profes-
sional soloist and the talented and learned organist
and musical director make it possible for us to
hear in our churches today music that was
undreamed of by our forefathers and there is no
question that although we are but passive listeners
to all this beauty, its influence is uplifting and
inspiring.
Movie music is another factor to be reckoned
with, and one to which the public school teachers,
special teachers of music and parents should all
give some attention. Everybody goes to the
movies. Or at least everybody's neighbor does.
And the music has become one of the big assets in
the attractiveness of this omnipresent form of
entertainment. It is being used as a real box-
office lure which is a positive proof of its value in
the eyes of the calculating manager. Of two mov-
ing picture houses in the same location and prac-
tically of the same class in every respect, the one
offering a good orchestra will be much more
eagerly patronized than the other. One needs
only to go to a show where the orchestra or the
individual player is using good taste and judg-
ment, and there can be heard on all sides the ex-
clamations of satisfaction and delight that the
appropriate music calls forth.
The right music makes the sad part sadder, the
tender scenes more tender, and the happy moments
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE 181
still happier. The daring feat becomes realistic-
ally thrilling, the horrible deed almost unbearably
grewsome, and the mysterious power of evil un-
cannily potent. Who can deny that under such
conditions a picture must appear much stronger?
*^Why/^ remarked a woman movie fan, ** appro-
priate music would simply revolutionize moving
pictures.'^ **And,'' said someone else, **I'd
rather not have any music than some of the stuff
they give us. ^ ' It will not be long before all enter-
prising directors will definitely tackle this prob-
lem and will conspire with musicians for the pur-
pose of solving it.
Now because you and your neighbors and your
children and the neighbors ' children all attend the
movies more or less it concerns you very directly
what music is being played. And it is altogether
desirable that pressure be brought to bear for
improvement wherever that is found to be neces-
sary.
In one town an enterprising music supervisor
in the public schools has hit upon a novel plan.
She is trying to do what all good supervisors are
doing, to make good music attractive from the
first grade through high school. At the end of
each month many of the selections studied are
given to the movie orchestras with the request
that they use them when possible. This is a
splendid means of distributing good music and
says this enterprising supervisor: ^^ Children are
182 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
very happy when they find their work functioning
outside of school.''
The relationship of the Woman's Club, both
musical and general, with the music life of the
community is naturally a very close one. It is
entirely in line with such a club 's activities to con-
cern itself with what the local board of education
is doing for music, to bring into existence a music
department in the local library, or if one is already
there to see what improving it needs, to investi-
gate movie theater music, and of course to link up
all these activities with music in the home. The
woman's club is also an active factor in all local
musical enterprises and much of the growth of
community music is due to the impetus given it
by the woman's club.
Community music whether it be the **sing" or
a community orchestra, or both combined, has the
saving grace of being something the people do
themselves instead of allowing themselves to be
entertained by others. It is the same creator
spirit that fills the kindergartner with bursting
pride when he beats the drum in the ** kinder-
band" or makes your boy march with bounding
step and beaming eye as a member of his school
band. Community music is for and by the crowd.
The crowd of which Traubel says : * * The scholar-
ship of the world has never made enough of the
crowd. Nor have the master classes in any of the
arts or in trade ever done it. Nor has the crowd
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE 183
itself done it. In fact, the crowd has belittled
itself. Yet all starts with the crowd. You can't
get away from it, because the crowd is funda-
mental. For after all even the top men in the
crowd are of, by and for the crowd, whether they
know it or not.*'
Crowd music expresses itself much better in the
general sing, usually dubbed * ^ community, ' ' than
in any other way. And the tendency to so indulge
the feelings is coming to be a fairly popular accom-
plishment. But still only fairly. In many quar-
ters it has been aggressively agitated as a wise
and valuable mode of procedure making for uplift
and all that sort of thing — which, of course, scares
nearly everybody to death and is apt to defeat the
very end it has aimed to achieve. As a nation we
are still extremely self-conscious about these
things, and when we know that we are being
dragged to a certain place for the sole purpose of
opening our mouths to sing we are so painfully
aware of the impending operation that our love
for music is apt to ooze out of our very finger tips.
In the foreign quarters of large cities results
have been wonderfully successful as far as intro-
ducing the community sing is concerned but it is
a totally different proposition when our real
natives are subjected to this process. Brave
attempts to inoculate the purely American part of
the community with a now-let 's-get-together-and-
sing spirit usually require a leader who could
184 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
galvanize a row of cigar store Indians into life.
Such occurrences, however, are becoming fre-
quent. Five thousand persons were brought to-
gether in Schenley Park, Pittsburgh, with a com-
mand to sing. A writer in Musical America, de-
scribing the occasion, said: ^'Some of them sang
well, some sang poorly, and some sang tenor, but
sing they all did and to get five thousand persons
in Pittsburgh to open their mouths for something
besides food and drink is a herculean task.'^
A very successful experiment has been carried
out in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, that is distinctly
novel and seems to be hitting the nail on the head.
They had been simmering and stewing about com-
munity music there for a long time without actu-
ally getting anywhere until the director of the
Civic Music Association worked out a plot with
the manager of .a leading moving picture theater.
The people, gathered there for quite another pur-
pose, found themselves confronted with the words
of a song thrown on the screen, a persuasive song-
leader up in front and the sound of a familiar tune
to urge them on. In a minute they were at it, heart
and soul, and from all accounts could hardly be
persuaded to stop for the picture part of the show.
This is a straw pointing out at least one direction
in which community singing might very naturally
and easily develop.
In New York City the appropriation of $70,000
for municipal music was cut to $17,000. A new
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE 185
mayor, having municipal music considerably at
heart, made up his mind to change the state of
affairs and appointed a commissioner of munici-
pal music and told him to find a way to improve
the situation. The commissioner decided to use
the bands of the fire, police and other city depart-
ments and enroll them at once for a series of free
concerts. In the summer these concerts were
given right on the steps of the City Hall.
Most writers talk about crowd and crowd-music
as if we were just discovering it. In a sense that
is true. But at the bottom, and outside certain
recent experiments, it is a revival rather than a
discovery. Music is now being applied to the
crowd in a way never tried before. The crowd is
the instrument which is being made and tuned, so
that in time it can be played upon for the entire
world.
Community interest in music is achieving other
results. Baltimore, Maryland, has gone on record
as the first city to make its symphony orchestra a
municipal affair, and the leading business men
of Baltimore say it has advertised their city out-
side of Maryland more than anything else that
has happened there. The Civic Music Associa-
tions of Chicago and New York have accomplished
wonders in settlements and various music centers
toward bringing music education and beautiful
concerts to the people — all of which links up
closely with the music of our public schools. Even
186 MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE
organized labor has stepped in and announces its
hearty support of any cooperative enterprise
whereby music may become a more active com-
munity factor. ^*You can count absolutely on the
support of organized labor, because organized
labor is fundamentally interested in securing the
best education facilities for the children of the
people,'' says the secretary of the Educational
Committee of the American Federation of Labor.
Just as we have music with us in all of these
definite lines of activity so we have it with us
in our hours of relaxation and recreation. It has
always been used at the theater to fill the be-
tween-act time, while people are getting seated at
public gatherings, and generally as an accompani-
ment in all kinds of places and all sorts of cir-
cumstances. But this is not the true function of
music as a factor in our playtime. Its real use
comes to the fore only when it is an important
adjunct or the sole purpose of our recreation. In
the latter sense we either make it ourselves in
our own homes or in public places with our fel-
lows, or, we use it as a recreation by listening to
others such as great artists, orchestras, etc.
As an adjunct to our recreation it crops out
in spontaneous tunefulness at the banquet table,
at club meetings, anywhere where men are friends
and the spirit of good fellowship holds sway. If
there are women present this is less likely to hap-
pen for the women apparently act as a deterrent
MUSIC AND OUR NATIONAL LIFE 187
or as a distraction. Now that prohibition has de-
scended upon the land music must shoulder a far
greater social responsibility than ever before. It
has to be the cocktail of the occasion. Men as a
rule drank for the spirit of conviviality and com-
radeship that came with it. It meant a letting
down of barriers, a thawing of reserve, a general
genial expansion. Now it is up to music to prove
it can supply all this hilarity without the head-
ache. And it can. The innate desire to express
good fellowship must find some outlet and the
jolly song that everyone knows will supply it.
People are happy when they sing and the more
they will do of it, the more surely it will become a
popular stimulant.
Singing in the home, which at present seems to
have been killed by a process of over-education
resulting from self-consciousness, will return.
Presently the parlor will be as full of harmony
as the kitchen end of the house where Katy at
the washtub works to a jiggy Irish tune and
Sadie Africana over her cooking shouts her
*^ spirituals. '*
Our inarticulate selves shall become articulate
through music of our own making. The ideality
native to us may thereby come to its most beauti-
ful expression, and music will attain its rightful
place in the life of the individual, in the life of the
community, and in the life of the state.
CHAPTER XVII
EVERY MAN HIS OWN TUNING FORK
Music is a national necessity.
— Thomas Edison.
Conversation about ^^tlie music of the spheres,'^
on being **in tune with the universe,*' and similar
phrases carry with them a vagueness that renders
their immensity altogether nugatory. But when
some one asks : Are you in tune with your sur-
roundings? Do you harmonize with your environ-
ment?— then we are getting down to brass tacks.
Do you then, fit into your environment, or are
you a square peg in a round hole, vainly trying to
overcome the eternal dissonance of your exist-
ence? If that is the case, find your ovra keynote,
vibrate to it and proceed to get the most out of
life!
There is going on about us continuously a
process of clashing vibrations, minute particles
fighting each other with a persistence that is
eternal. And however accustomed we may be-
come to this wearing down process, we must watch-
fully bear in mind that it is just that — an expendi-
ture of destructive and not constructive force.
The interminable clatter of the inappropriate
may lull us to sleep, but says Chesterton, **when
an appropriate thing happens it wakes us up like
188
EVERY MAN HIS OWN TUNING FORK 189
the pang of a perfect chord.'' It is like the silence
in the country at night. More awful, more in-
tense, more loud to the city child than the thunder-
ing traffic of the streets in a human bee-hive. But
to come back to that perfect chord. Just think
how it sets us vibrating, what a degree of re-
sponsiveness it wins from us!
Vibration is the first or primal expression of
energy, and an understanding of the orderly laws
of sound will open up a whole new world of beauty.
This realm of sound when subjected to the en-
lightening process of the science of acoustics,
quite loses its air of mystery, and becomes at once
a simple array of definite facts. To the scientific
mind all is law and order. An authoritative
knowledge of a certain subject makes the most
wonderful processes of nature serve as a lesson,
a guide, an example.
A sound is defined as an air disturbance which
reaches the ear, and causes the sensation of hear-
ing.
A noise is a sound too brief or too irregular
to have an assignable pitch.
A tone is a sound continuing uniformly for an
appreciable time and having an assignable pitch.
Vibration is the moving to and fro, or oscilla-
tion, of a body or the particles composing a body.
The pitch is determined by the number of vibra-
tions in a given period of time.
When the number of vibrations per second is
190 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
greater than thirty and less than thirty-two thou-
sand, certain delicate tissues of the ear vibrate
in sympathy, or respond. These vibrations ex-
press as sound, and we hear. When the number
of vibrations per second is greater than two hun-
dred and eighty-two trillions, and less than one
and one-quarter quadrillions, the organs of sight
respond. These vibrations express as light, and
we see.
Until separated into its component parts by
means of a prism, light was considered a unit.
By experiment tone was found to be composed of
numerous partial tones, just as light is made up
of colors.
The distinctive, individual quality of a tone is
determined by the relative intensity of its par-
tials. We may hear sounded the pitch known as
middle C, and, without seeing the medium used,
will recognize the tone as coming from the piano,
or the violin, or cornet, or a tenor or contralto
voice. In each case the proportionate loudness
of the partials varies, resulting in the particular
tone quality that makes that tone different from
every other and this introduces us to the wonders
of tone-color.
Just as innumerable tints may be formed by a
varying proportion of the primary colors, so an
infinite number of qualities follow the combina-
tion of partial tones in varied proportions. A
simple tone (one sounding few or no partials
EVERY MAN HIS OWN TUNING FORK 191
above the first) is free from roughness, therefore
agreeable, but has very little carrying power and
is dull, particularly at low pitches — for example,
the tuning fork, the wide-stopped Bourdon-like
organ pipe, and the low notes of the flute.
A tone composed of a moderately loud sequence
of partials up to and including the sixth is con-
sidered musical. The piano, an open organ pipe,
the softer tones of the human voice, and to a lesser
degree, the French horn offer familiar examples.
When the first partial predominates the tone qual-
ity is rich, when higher partials predominate the
quality is. poor.
Now, these coldly scientific facts may be of
wonderfully fruitful application if rightly used.
They may revolutionize human beings. Every
one, by listening attentively to a continuous tone,
may learn to distinguish the first six partials.
He may learn promptly to recognize the medium
of expression, even where that medium is closely
allied in character to another instrument. The
multicolored, composite tone of the orchestra may
be separated into its component parts. The
trained listener has already accomplished this, to
a certain extent at least. But it should more gen-
erally he made a part of the ear training of a
child.
To become a nation of music lovers, we must
become a nation of selective listeners, and this
training cannot begin too soon. This is one of
192 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
the most important angles of music application.
How to accomplish it was described in Chapter IV.
All matter is responsive. It vibrates in sym-
pathy to a certain key-note, and having once re-
sponded, the habit, as it were, grows (if the sound
is persisted in), the vibrations becoming more and
more responsive. You strike a note on your piano
that calls forth an answering sharp vibration from
some part of the chandelier in the middle of the
room. That tone, sounded repeatedly, will result
in an increasingly louder vibratory answer. A
glass vibrates to a certain pitch — the tone, if per-
sisted in, will eventually shatter the glass!
And not only inanimate objects, but every living
thing responds to its own keynote.
The fire chief of a certain small town owned a
dog which was a model of decorous behavior, ex-
cepting when the fire bell rang. Then he would
set up a howl of derision. The fire chief declared
his dog knew that bell, and could distinguish it
from all others. This was scoffed at, but one day
the dog proved the truth of his master's conten-
tion. The funeral of a prominent citizen meant
the ringing, in quick succession, of all the church
and other large bells in the town. The dog was
watched. He made no sound during all the din
until the clang of the fire bell rent the air.
Promptly came his howl in response to its vibra-
tions.
Responsive vibrations create the desire to ex-
EVERY MAN HIS OWN TUNING FORK 193
press oneself. It is psychology applied uncon-
sciously. The farmer who plods along in the same
old way, his slipshod manner of living but a dull
gray path of hopelessness, who jerks along to
market in the same rickety wagon, and at the vil-
lage store meets his familiar cronies who are but
replicas of himself, who spits at the stove and
sententiously remarks, **I guess what's good
enough for me is good enough for the children,''
needs waking up.
His vibrator is all run down.
A trolley line is built past his door. What hap-
pens? This new element in his drab existence
starts something in him to vibrate, creates the de-
sire to express himself, to be different, to have
more from life. The chickens and pigs that used
the front yard as a rendezvous are penned up
somewhere out of sight. The yard is set to rights.
Some flowers appear. The fence is mended. A
small porch is built on the front of the house.
The boards that held up the barn door vanish and
hinges once more give it an air of well-being, and
presently the man himself emerges a new creature
— in tune with his improved surroundings.
The theory of responsive vibrations, while it
has newly found its scientific explanation, is not
by any means a thing of yesterday. Pythagoras
used it as a basis for his musical scale, and Plato
held that *^ education in music is of the greatest
importance, for more than anything else rhythm
194 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
and harmony make their way into the inmost parts
of the soul.'^
These wonderful laws of sound are as old as
creation, but, in their application to individuals,
as new as the dawn. Scientists may prove the
facts. It is up to us to live them.
Find your own keynote, respond to it, and life
will deny you nothing.
CHAPTER XVIII
THE HOME REPERTOIRE
Here are a few suggestions of music for the
home repertoire that anyone will like. The com-
positions listed include all kinds of good music
and knowing these will lead to the knowing and
liking of others. Nearly everything mentioned
may be obtained in the original instrumental or
vocal form, or as records or player rolls.
Air de Ballet Chaminade
Anitra 's Dance Grieg
Anvil Chorus from II Trovatore Verdi
A Perfect Day Jacobs-Bond
Badinage Herbert
Barcarolle, from Tales of Hoffman Offenbach
Berceuse, from Jocelyn Godard
Butterfly Grieg
By Moonlight Bendel
Cabaletta Lack
Cavatina Raff
Dance of the Hours, from La Gioconda Ponchielli
Dancing Doll Poldini
Evening Star, from Tannhauser .Wagner
From the Land of the Sky-Blue Water Cadman
Gavotte, from Mignon Thomas
Gypsy Song, from Carmen Bizet
Gondoliers Nevin
Habanera, from Carmen. • .,. Bizet
Happy Farmer Schumann
Humoreske Dvorak
Hungarian Dances Brahms
195
196 PUTTING YOUNG AMERICA IN TUNE
Intermezzo, from Cavalleria Rusticana Mascagni
KnoAvest Thou the Land, from Mignon Thomas
Kermess, from Faust Gounod
L 'Arlesienne Suite Bizet
Last Hope Gottschalk
Love 's Joy Kreisler
Le Renouveau (The Spring) Godard
Marche Militaire Schubert
Melody in F Rubinstein
Minuet in G Beethoven
Meditation, from Thais Massenet
Minuet Boccherini
Minuet Paderewski
Moment Musical Schubert
Murmuring Zephyrs Jensen
My Rosary Nevin
Narcissus Nevin
Nocturne in E flat Chopin
Nocturne, from Midsummer Night's Dream . Mendelssohn
Orientale Cui
Peer Gynt Suite Grieg
Polish Dance Scharwencka
Prelude to Lohengrin Wagner
Prophet Bird - Schumann
Pizzicati Delibes
Quartet from Eigoletto Yerdi
Romance Rubinstein
Romanza Schumann
Reverie Schumann
Sextet from Lucia Donizzetti
Serenade Moszkowski
Scarf Dance Chaminade
Simple Confession Thome
Serenade Schubert
Second Rhapsody Liszt
Shepherd 's Hey Grainger
Second Mazurka Godard
Spring Song .Mendelssohn
Tarantelle Heller
THE HOME REPERTOIRE 107
Tarantelle Sternberf?
Tarantelle G. Sehiimann
The Bee Schubert
The Flatterer Chaminade
The Little Bird Grieg-
The Swan Saint-Saens
The Sandman Brahms
To a "Wild Rose. MacDowell
Toreador Song from Carmen Bizet
Toreadors' Chorus from Carmen Bizet
Triumphal March from Aida Verdi
Venetian Boat Song Mendelssohn
Venetian Love Song Nevin
Voices of Spring Sinding
Waltz from Faust Gounod
Waltz, Op. 56 Godard
Waltz, Op. 18 Chopin
Wedding March Mendelssohn
Wedding March from Lohengrin Wagner
William Tell Overture Rossini
SONG COLLECTIONS FOR CHILDREN
Tree Top Tunes for Tiny Tots Helen Phillips Eddy
A Nursery Garland Kittie Cheathem
A Birthday Greeting Frank Damrosch
Four-and-Twenty Little Songs David Stanley Smith
Folk Songs for Children . Jane Byrd Radcliffe- Whitehead
Creature Songs Louise Ayres Garnett
Mother Goose Songs L. E. Orth
Posies from a Child 's Garden of Verses
William Arms Fisher
Booklet of Four Songs Carrie Jacobs-Bond
Little Kitten Songs Carrie Jacobs-Bond
INDEX
Action songs 55, 59, 90
Apollo ^ 17
Appreciation classes 92
of music 158
Attaching stories to music 126
Baby, its ear for music 25
Birds, miraculous Ig
Boys, instruments for 112
Business of music I74
Care of piano 80
Censorship of jazz 149
Character building I34
Child, innate sense of 23
Children, play of 55
taste of 26
Chinese legend 17
Church music 179
Glass singing , 87
Club, opera 123
phonograph opera 123
women's 182
Community music 179
Contests, memory, in home 122
memory, in school 94, 105
Correlated ideas 124, 125
Creative instinct 46
Discipline, mental 89
Ear training 43, 191
Effect of rhythm 14, 56
Exercises, rhythmic 26
tone sense 42, 43
Expression, rhythmic 55, 56
First musical training 23
Folk music 55
Fundamentals of teaching 38
Games, teaching notes by 44
tone guessing 42
199
200 INDEX
Glasses, musical 36
Good manners 130
Grace, rhythm and 59
Harmony, nursery 22
Health, affected by music 26, 30, 92
Home atmosphere 60
contests in memory 122
help in music 33
training in music 74
without nnisic 162
Hospitals, music in 141
Infant 12
melody enjoyed by 27
Impulses, natural 13
reaction to 13
Instruments for boys 112
lyre 16
piano 80
phonograph 49
xylophone 27, 51
Interpretation, wrong 129
Japanese legend 19
Jazz, censorship of 149
on battle line 151
Jingles in the nursery 57
Kinderbands 87
Kindergarten training 31,46
Konei, Chinese god 17
Labor, organized 186
Learning to listen 48
Legend, Chinese 17
Japanese 19
Orpheus 16
Pan 15
Syrinx 15
Lessons, beginning 64
Library, music 178
Liking music 40
Listeners, selective 42
Listening 35
how learned 48
Lullabies 22
Lyre 16
Manners of music 130
INDEX 201
Melody, infant enjoys 27
Memory contests 94/ 105 122
INIental discipline '.....'. 89
Methods, new in teacliing 69, 71
Miraculous birds \\ ' ' ig
Mother Goose songs 57
Mother, as a teacher 33, 38, 43, 58
help by .'...'..,. 72
Motion picture music 180
Music, business of I74
church 179
community I79
effect of 14
folk '.'.'.'.'.'.['. 55
health affected by 26, 30, 92
hospital 141
library of 178
motion picture 180
nature's 42, 48, 53
origin of 13
prohibition and 187
popular 153
primitive 12
ragtime 150
stories about 39, 47
study of 85
supernatural source of 14
war-time 138
Musical glasses 36
toys 50
Musicless household 162
Nation, unmusical 10
Natural impulses 13
Nature music 42, 48, 53
Noise 189
Notes, teaching by games 44
Nursery, harmony in the 22
jingles for 57
training in the 21
Opera club 123
Opera club, phonograph 123
Orchestra, school 93, 110
Organized labor 186
Origin of music 13
of scales 17
Orpheus, legend of 16
202 INDEX
Pan, legend of 15
Parents, responsibility of 34, 73, 77, 106
Pattern, rhythmic 53,54
Phonograph 49
how used 58, 92, 100, 118, 162
library of records for 61
opera club by means of 123
Physical benefits of singing 92
Piano, care of 80
Pipes of Pan 16
Pitch 37, 189
Play of children 55
Popular music 153
Preparedness, lack of 63
Primitive music 12
Prohibition, music and 187
Psychology of rhythm 55, 56
teachers of 69
Ragtime music 150
Reaction to impulse 13
Response to sound 12
Rhythm, effect of 14, 56
grace affected by 59
psychology of 55, 56
response to 24
Rhythmic exercises 26
expression 55,56
pattern 53, 54
Savages, music of 12
Scales, origin of 17
School contests in memory 122
orchestra 93, 110
Selective listeners 42
Singing, physical benefits of 92
spontaneous 104
Songs, folk 55
Mother Goose 57
Sound 189
response to 12
Stories about music 39, 126
Story music ; 47
Study of music 85
Supernatural source of music 14
Syrinx, legend of 15
INDEX 203
Taste, children's 26
cultivation of 154, 156
foundation of '. 26
Teacher, mother as a 33, 38, 43, 58
of psychology 69
task of the 75
Teaching, fundamentals of 38
new methods of 69, 71
wrong 67, 76
Tone 189
guessing of 42
quality of 190
sense, exercises for 42, 43
Toys, musical 50
Training, ear 42, 43, 191
first musical 23
home 74
kindergarten 31, 46
nursery 21
Unmusical nation 10
Vibration 189
War, music in 138
Women's clubs 182
Wrong interpretation 129
Wrong teaching 67, 76
Xylophone 27, 51
.p
"(
1 DATE DUE
.■,:(;.,■• . . ■'J'-
k
[fr? -
r;r(; 1 1 tjf ■ '
MAY 0 7 2
)02
\
\
\
\